4 ms·
It is because solving a non-problem here creates very real ones. And your analogy is backwards. The reason why it is a non-problem is that there is an establi
by btilly 10y ago
It is because solving a non-problem here creates very real ones. And your analogy is backwards.
The reason why it is a non-problem is that there is an established procedure for this that works quite well. Take the warrant from a US court to a court in the other country, cite the appropriate international treaty we have with them, and then access the information in that other country in accord with local law.
This is how we have to go about getting access to foreign bank accounts. Or getting your personal papers searched if you lie abroad. The same standard should apply to emails.
But US courts wish to apply US law to emails and people who do not live in the USA. Why should US law apply to them? What are the limits of a government of one place applying its laws elsewhere? Do you wish France to be able to access your emails? How about Iran?
Furthermore complying with US decisions like this puts Google in conflict with foreign laws about data privacy. This issue is already costing them a lot of lost business. What penalties are appropriate for their violations of local law?
- comex 10y agoThere are a few problems with your proposed solution, based on the facts as described in the opinion (and thus as alleged by Google's lawyers): First, Google's architecture supposedly constantly moves data from place to place, so US law enforcement could spend considerable effort going to a court in France and convincing them they should hand over the data, only to hear, oops, while you were doing that we moved it to Canada. It also potentially splits data into many parts, requiring the US to go to several different courts. (Google also didn't even say which country or countries the data is stored in, though I suppose the US could probably subpoena that information.) Second, Google says that the only system they have for giving data to law enforcement requires going through employees in the US, regardless of where the servers to be accessed are located. Makes sense, since their architecture is location-agnostic by default, and handling law enforcement requests is a specialized job. But a decision from a foreign court is not binding on those employees! US law enforcement would have to try to get the country hosting the data to go and physically seize Google's servers, and manually search through their hard drives. Admittedly, they'd probably only have to pull a stunt like that once before Google decided to get more cooperative, but it's still a messy situation. FWIW, I agree with your concerns about foreign data privacy laws, but the solution can't be to effectively make certain data immune to court-ordered access of any kind. (Well, at any rate, such a solution would be contrary to political orthodoxy even in the EU, though cypherpunk types might be happy with it - a category I count myself in to some extent. :) Maybe the US needs to pass laws explicitly addressing this situation, but considering the current political situation, I wouldn't expect that to happen anytime soon…
- btilly 10y agoReading the case at hand, there is a complication. The issue here is that the crime happened when all involved lived in the USA. The perpetrators have since moved abroad and therefore live outside of the USA. There is no question that at the time the crime happened, the warrant would have been reasonable and valid. The question is whether the warrant is reasonable and valid now. Apparently Google has moved the data abroad so it is no longer on US servers. Google regularly does this - they try to place information close to where it gets requested for reasons of efficiency. On the other hand this fact is something that nobody outside of Google can verify. Are we sure that there are no copies left in the USA? Did you look in your backups? Are you sure? So on a physical analogy, it is like a warrant for documents that were purportedly carried out of the country. If they really were, then you would appropriately have to deal with that other country. If they weren't, then Google should produce the documents. The court doesn't want to debate Google on unverifiable facts. The crime took place in the USA. Google can easily produce the documents. We only have Google's word that this requires accessing data from abroad. I can make arguments for this on both sides.