2 ms·
Isn't it very inefficient to heat with electricity to begin with? That's what I was told anyway. You are right, transforming electricity into heat is probably v
by Tichy 16y ago
Isn't it very inefficient to heat with electricity to begin with? That's what I was told anyway. You are right, transforming electricity into heat is probably very efficient. But generating electricity is more inefficient than generating heat directly, hence heating by other means is a lot more efficient.
He might be excused, though, if it simply was another era when there wasn't yet any kind of consciousness for that kind of thing.
- jacquesm 16y agoHold a second here, when you're from Europe you may not know this, but in the United States and in Canada 'baseboard' electrical heating systems are very common and natural gas systems (like you see all over Europe) much less so. Other heating systems common in the States are based on fuel oil ('red' diesel) that is atomized in a central burner and then used to either heat water (like in most European central heating systems) or air. Elecrical forced air heating systems combined with air conditioning for the summer are also pretty common. In Europe electrical heating is a rarity, unless for additional heat (small 1KW space heaters and such).
- Tichy 16y agoThanks - I am from Europe. So why is electrical heating so common in the US? Or is it really a legacy from the days of SUVs and cheap energy?
- nkurz 16y agoPartly a legacy: 'all electric' was a selling point in the middle of the century when lots of new houses were being built. Partly cost: if you already have a modern electric hookup, the equipment is cheaper. Also, I think a lot of subdivisions and rural areas in the US were built without gas hookups. Whether it's less efficient depends on what metric you're using. In areas that have hydroelectric or nuclear generation for electricity, the CO2 emissions are less with electric heat. Cost varies: there are places where electric simply costs less, particularly if you can spot heat instead of using a central system. Here's a couple links: http://www.iwilltry.org/b/projects/comparing-natural-gas-vs-electric-heating/ http://www.iwilltry.org/b/projects/comparing-natural-gas-vs-... (concludes that switching to electric makes cost sense in BC, Canada) http://www.leonardo-energy.org/webfm_send/377 http://www.leonardo-energy.org/webfm_send/377 (European view concluding that from a CO2 perspective electric is a win in Austria and France)
- _delirium 16y agoI think that varies by area. I've lived in Indiana, Texas, Georgia, and California, and I've had natural-gas heating in three of those (all but Georgia). I think pretty much every house in a populated area in the midwest has natural-gas heating, though I hear fuel oil is more common in the northeast, and electric heating is more common in areas where heating isn't very often necessary (like Georgia).
- jacquesm 16y agoYes, that makes sense. In Western Europe domestic heat is almost exclusively natural gas.
- _delirium 16y agoHmm, interesting. My European relatives are all in Greece, where natural gas is still a fairly new thing, only available in major cities. For a while, electric was the only alternative to fuel oil, which many people preferred to avoid if they could (produces soot, requires you to get the oil delivered, etc.). Since there's a big difference in daytime/nighttime prices, the electric-heating units, unlike American ones, are big bulky things with a bunch of batteries, which they charge up at night at the cheap rates.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's really interesting because charging and discharging a battery costs 8 eurocents per KWh in wear on the battery alone. The difference would have to be substantial to make up for that. My impression why large parts of the States like electric heat are closely related to your Greek relatives, America is huge compared with the number of people that live in the inner portion of the continent, so the only places where adding a natural gas delivery system would make sense would be the densely populated ones. Then there are large areas that have only a short heating season, there is the convenience issue (very little maintenance compared to heating oil or natural gas), and the perceived risk (which I think is largely misplaced). The recent changes in the electricity prices have made people more conscious about this and there seems to be a trend towards more natural gas for heating purposes.