6 ms·
> appropriate investments in infrastructure to support their variability Erm, why didn't you make appropriate investments in infrastructure? Because it cost m
by dragontamer 10y ago
> appropriate investments in infrastructure to support their variability
Erm, why didn't you make appropriate investments in infrastructure?
Because it cost money. Why should you expect someone else to make an unprofitable venture if you yourself were unwilling to do so?
In any case, the variability in solar and wind is known. To keep the same level of electrical service will require a HUGE increase in energy storage.
The thing about coal / gas / even nuclear to some degree... you can "turn it off" if there's too much power being pumped into the grid... and you can "turn it back on" if there isn't enough power. That's why natural gas "Peaker Plants" continue to be built, despite the fact that they're much more expensive than Solar or Wind.
The enemy of "Peaker Plants" is cheap energy storage. Coal and Nuclear power is more efficient if you just keep it on 100% of the time and then store the energy anyway.
And believe me, utility companies HAVE been building cheap energy storage. They're called Pumped Hydro for the most part. Other solutions for cheap energy storage simply didn't exist until recently. Lithium Batteries are expensive and don't provide much storage believe it or not... not on the Gigawatt scale needed to last more than a few minutes.
We will likely continue to use "Peaker plants" for the near term, at least until the energy storage issue is solved with something much much cheaper.
- jartelt 10y agoWhy didn't I make the investment? Because I am a private citizen and not a public utility... Utilities are able to rate base their investment and get a guaranteed rate of return on the investments they make. This rate base system is part of the reason why they often make costly and unnecessary investments in >$1B nuclear plants or expensive substations rather than in cheap energy efficiency measures or distributed solar. We have the technology to help mitigate renewable variability and could deploy it if we wanted to. Utilities just chose to drag their feet and not invest heavily in deploying those solutions because the wanted to keep building the same stuff they always build and get the ROI.
- dragontamer 10y ago> guaranteed rate of return > We have the technology to help mitigate renewable variability and could deploy it if we wanted to. Then build a company if you think its so easy. From my view: its clear that there are risks entailed and that the technology is far too expensive for widescale deployment. But its a free country. If you really think that building a Lithium Ion energy-storage plant is free money, then build a Lithium Ion energy-storage center. There's no reason to blame other people for not seeing the world the same way as you. EDIT: If building such companies isn't in your interest, then buy stocks in those companies that are working on energy storage. Like buy stock in ABB or something. Or maybe TSLA if you really think their Lithium Ion technology really is taking over the electric grid.
- Retric 10y agoYou can't actually start a power company and compete with say Dominion etc, as they are legal monopolies. You can't even buy one without regulatory approval.
- dragontamer 10y agoYeah, but you can start a solar plant to provide energy to Dominion / etc. etc. https://www.dominionresources.com/library/domcom/pdfs/electric-generation/2015-solar-rfp/solar-rfp-document.pdf https://www.dominionresources.com/library/domcom/pdfs/electr... Or you can invest into companies that compete against Dominion / etc. etc. that focus more on renewables.
- renesd 10y agoYou can invest in renewable quite easily by purchasing your power from a company that supplies it. It doesn't even require capital or much risk. Often they also provide cheaper power than the big players. The one I use is cheaper, and they also donate money to planting trees, and protecting old growth forests. Secondly you can invest your pension in ethical, and eco companies. Again, they often outperform others (mine has anyway). Thirdly, you can live in a place which does not waste power. Or you can at least do quite a bit to reduce energy usage yourself. Get a bike. You'll live longer, look better, and you'll not kill people with your pollution. Ya! for not being a murderer. Share a cargo bike so you can carry heavy things. All things which normal people not wanting to take on utility scale investments and risks. Look at your outgoing expenses and see how you can select the providers. When millions of people do it, it has a very powerful effect. Convince your city to also purchase renewable power. As an example, in Melbourne they used the purchasing power of their electric trams. They tendered out for a new renewable power plant to provide the power. With many urban people often voting 'Green', this is not a really hard thing to do or get support for. Good luck!
- dragontamer 10y ago> You can invest in renewable quite easily by purchasing your power from a company that supplies it. It doesn't even require capital or much risk. Often they also provide cheaper power than the big players. The one I use is cheaper, and they also donate money to planting trees, and protecting old growth forests. Not an option in all states. But yes, this is an option for me that I've been considering. This strategy relies on the local municipal (or state) government on "deregulating" the utility companies. And also on the government to force the utility companies to buy energy from a variety of sources. There's a lot of "political infrastructure", laws, deals, and agreements, that are needed to make such options a possibility. And it will do good to remember that the "option to buy renewable" isn't an option in many states.
- logfromblammo 10y agoI haven't invested in the infrastructure because electricity is not my business. If it were my business, I would still be at the mercy of giant incumbent competitors, and any dollar I spent on common infrastructure would benefit them more than me. They could then use that advantage to slowly force me out of the business. The largest firms have the most to gain from improvements in the industry's infrastructure. So the onus is largely upon them to make such improvements. In many cases, there is only one firm with significant pricing power--the natural monopolist--and everyone else in their territory has to dance to their tune. They're the only ones capable of improving infrastructure, aside from a government. The pricing power is the only way for a firm to afford projects that are neither profitable nor a competitive advantage. The only point for everyone else in the market to having firms with pricing power is so they can undertake those projects that benefit everyone in the long run. If you're not going to improve the industry, there is no advantage for everyone else to allow you to remain as the natural monopolist. The logical thing for them to do is to seize your capital by force and transfer it to someone who might do more with it (but might do less). A natural monopoly does not mean the same firm will always have pricing power, but that the modal situation is that only one firm has it at a time. When natural monopolists are protected as de jure protected monopolies, yes it does prevent redundant investment, but it also puts no competitive pressure on the monopolist to remain the monopolist. I would guess that electric utilities would make wiser decisions about infrastructure if they were less protected from competition. That introduces the risk that a particular market might not be adequately served in an economic dominance war that wipes out both incumbent and challenger, but I think those crises would be very temporary, and would likely invoke a government intervention less costly than protecting the monopoly in the first place.
- dragontamer 10y agoWe're talking about energy storage, are we not? If you think that energy storage "makes money", build a small 10MW battery plant to supply a neighborhood or two. Buy electricity when its cheap, sell it when its expensive. There's no "common infrastructure building" going on here. You own the batteries, and maybe you have to pay the big utility for some power-poles and comply with some basic regulations. The fact of the matter is: these sorts of infrastructure issues are being solved by the free market all the time. Frequency regulation, long-term energy storage (which really is just ~hours) and such are commonly subcontracted out to smaller companies who own small plants from the big utility companies. ------- > I haven't invested in the infrastructure because electricity is not my business. Then do the next best thing. Buy stock in companies that are doing grid-scale energy storage across this country.
- usrusr 10y agoGas peaker plants are storage. Well, half of it anyways. Utilities here in Germany are quietly (because that kind of business works best when not everybody is doing it) ramping up electricity to hydrogen converters everywhere. But not for the 1990ies vision of a full "hydrogen economy" complete with fuel cell cars that don't work and whatnot. They just use them to convert cheap (sometime even negative cost, hence the desire to not inspire too much competition) electricity at peak supply times to hydrogen that they push into the existing gas grid that has a huge storage capacity by itself (think months of national demand). That network is currently carrying mostly natural gas, but it used to carry much higher fractions of hydrogen back in the age of coal gasification. If you can work with natural gas, chances are that you can work with a conservative blend of natural gas and hydrogen with very little extra investment, very much unlike pure hydrogen concepts. (Also, utilities are building a lot of heat storage capacity, so that their cogeneration plants can be freely dispatched according to electricity demand, with the district heating function completely decoupled, even on the seasonal scale)
- epistasis 10y agoThat is really fascinating. Is the hydrogen conversion something that's happening so quietly that there's nothing on the internet about it? I can't find any sources at them moment.
- turbokoze 10y agoThis Wikipedia entry has some details: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_to_gas#Power_to_hydrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_to_gas#Power_to_hydrogen
- malloryerik 10y agohttps://energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-electrolysis https://energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-electr... Still not deleted by the new administration! It was near the top of Google results for "electric to hydrogen."
- WalterBright 10y agoAnother way to deal with variable supply is to incentivize the demand to be variable along with it. This is done with variable pricing of the electricity. People will then find it worthwhile to adjust use of the elastic part of their demand to when electricity is cheaper - such as charging their car.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoIt isn't just on the market or utilities. All of their prices are heavily regulated. Companies that produce baseline power are expected to make a set profit (no more or less) and the people lending them money and buying their stocks also expect a set return on investment. Any price increases have to be justified politically and the companies are expected to pay off previous investments and then return the majority of their profits to the shareholders. It is a case of an extremely conservative market being upended by rapid change. And the kinds of investments the grid needs to move to a majority renewable system are very different from what was needed in the past. Many of the best wind projects, for example, are located out in the middle of nowhere and require large transmission lines to bring them to the places that use the electricity. The distributed nature of solar and wind require more interconnections to bring in power from locations that have an excess of sun or wind to those that need the electricity. It is more difficult to keep these diverse sources of power synced so that the grid transports a steady amount of power at the right frequency, and that also needs more and different investments than in the past. It's not a simple matter of profit/loss, but of balancing a number of political considerations and a huge bootstrapping problem. I don't think any one company can handle this by itself.