4 ms·
At that point its actually not even science and shouldn't be funded
by michaelmrose 10y ago
At that point its actually not even science and shouldn't be funded
- toss1941 10y agoI remember my teachers in high school making such a big deal about the scientific method on how important it was, how experiments must be reproducible to be useful, but today you barely hear it mentioned one way or another.
- SilasX 10y agoWait, you're telling me that schools teach comforting lies about society that don't match how the real world actually works?
- dTal 10y agoIt's no more a "comforting lie" than your driving instructor telling you to check your blind spot. Not everyone does it, and bad things happen as a result, but all the more important to teach it. I'm actually surprised to hear of high school teaching good scientific practice. I don't remember ever being taught that. Widely may it spread.
- SilasX 10y agoHold on -- there's a category confusion here: "check your blindspots" isn't a comforting lie; it's a command. Converting it to "checking your blindspots will avoid collisions with careless drivers" would make it no longer a lie.
- dTal 10y agoI was pointing out the category confusion. Science teachers don't purport to tell you what scientists actually do (history or sociology teachers might, I suppose, but they don't usually "make such a big deal" out of the scientific method). They purport to teach science. As you say - it's not a comforting lie, it's a command.
- wycx 10y agoThe way you get funded is by being able to do things that others can't do, or by being better at some technique than everyone else. Giving away all your hard won tricks by putting all of them in a methods section takes away your advantage come funding time.
- FeepingCreature 10y agoSo what you're saying is science is dead and we're going back to mysticism and alchemy.
- michaelmrose 10y agoThe problem is that it is far easier and cheaper to produce stuff that looks like science but isn't so if you fund stuff without being able to prove it/reproduce it then you will probably end up funding 90% bullshit while starving real science for money. Any real scientists ought to recognize that secrecy as a strategy is terrible for science as a whole even if it is very temporarily good for them.
- bradjohnson 10y agoWhat's the point of funding something that won't help anyone because the author won't tell you how they did it? How is any conclusion that they've come to useful if nobody can verify if it's correct?
- 2xlbuds 10y agoAt that point it's just like funding magicians to come up with new tricks.
- notzorbo3 10y agoWho says the author(s) won't tell anybody? They only need to keep it secret from the competition, not the hand that feeds them.
- Too 10y agoThis can definitely be the problem. I've seen studies where 50% of funding came from university and 50% from a private company. University required study to be published in their database, company wants the end result and don't want media to know what they are working with. So the report is obfuscated just enough to be legible for publication without giving away too much data from the company. Especially for final masters degree projects this is very common as the students don't get paid by the university at all, so many try to find a company to sponsor. But the students still need the uni to publish the report for them to get their final degree so you get this conflict of interest again. Most of these reports are just written with the end goal of getting a degree, not of creating solid research, this really needs the stricter universities not letting through all that crap, for now they shouldn't really be trusted the same way as proper research papers.
- coldtea 10y agoLots of insights/technologies you use today were produced by scientists working in such and even more secretive conditions, even with public funding involved (e.g. nobody at the Manhattan project would broadcast their discoveries to the world and same for many other fields, not necessarily war related).