3 ms·
I don't know Canadian law, but declining a search is your constitutional right in America, even if you're cited for a moving violation. No matter what a cop say
by philwelch 17y ago
I don't know Canadian law, but declining a search is your constitutional right in America, even if you're cited for a moving violation. No matter what a cop says otherwise. American cops are allowed to lie, imply, threaten, and be presumptuous assholes but if you assert your civil rights you still have them. (If they ask you to step out of the car and just casually slide right into the driver's seat, and you say nothing, you just consented to a search. So lock your door when you get out and don't consent.)
This is a very important point: they _can't_ force the issue if they want to. That's why they're asking (or just being an asshole about it) instead of presenting you with a warrant and instructing you to step aside.
I've never been asked to consent to a search of my home or vehicle, but there are tons of legitimate reasons to say no:
1. Privacy. You know how some people really don't want search engines and random hoodlums reading their facebook profile and status updates? Well, maybe I really don't want random cops poking around my car or apartment. Maybe my girlfriend and I have a whole box of sex toys and bondage gear.
2. There are so many damned laws you might be breaking one and you'd never know. It's probably a really stupid law, too.
3. Maybe you just don't want to unpack every damn thing in your car and pack it away again. I've got like two sealed emergency survival kits in my car and I'd be pretty pissed off if some cop opened them looking for drugs that weren't there. And have you ever seen a home that was searched by cops? You have to spend the whole rest of the weekend cleaning up and putting everything away afterwards, man.
BTW, the same reasoning applies if they knock on your door and ask to search your residence. If they have to ask, the answer is no.
Finally, if they present a warrant or go ahead and search it anyway even if you explicitly decline consent, then stay out of their way and get a lawyer.