3 ms·
What the article is talking about and what that bill seems to address are two separate issues. Whether you have high or low evidentiary standards for a new trea
by jerf 10y ago
What the article is talking about and what that bill seems to address are two separate issues. Whether you have high or low evidentiary standards for a new treatment is, under our current system and almost any system I've ever seen proposed, independent from whether doctors will end up completely correctly using those new systems. Doctors already have that responsibility and are already failing in that responsibility for a variety of complicated reasons, apparently, but it's easy to construct "solutions" that make it even worse. How do you out-expert the very people you've trained to be experts in the first place? That may not be unsolvable but it surely isn't a trivial problem to be fixed with some regulation here and some pamphlets there.
We've frequently discussed on HN the idea that sky-high evidentiary standards for new treatments may have passed the point where they are doing more harm than good. While I'm sure there are disagreeable details in the new bill, the broad strokes of the bill are things that the HN gestalt has at least been talking about for a while. It's not like it's a sudden out-of-the-blue idea that nobody's ever heard of before.
- Hnrobert42 10y agoThe term "sky-high" means the evidentiary standards are by definition harmful. One wouldn't describe them as sky-high if one thought they were reasonable. If one starts with the premise that existing standards are sky-high, then of course one will conclude they should be lowered.
- jerf 10y agoI am obviously speaking about the end result of that debate and my personal opinion, which I won't try to hide. The debate itself was substantial, however, not merely word games.