3 ms·
So, it seems highly likely that the device doesn't have the information the police want. Barring any nasty surprises, Alexa only stores the actual requests mad
by mcphage 10y ago
So, it seems highly likely that the device doesn't have the information the police want. Barring any nasty surprises, Alexa only stores the actual requests made to it.
However, Amazon doesn't want to win this case based on the technical details of this specific device, because maybe a future device will store more—and then they'd need to fight this battle all over again.
So they're trying to make an argument that doesn't rest on the technical details of their current devices. If they win that, then they won't have to worry about this kind of case later.
- curun1r 10y agoThat part makes sense, but it would seem that the fourth amendment (or even the fifth) would be the one they'd want to cite. The first amendment would only make sense if they government was trying to punish someone for the content of their speech. That isn't the case here. The government is trying to punish someone for murdering someone else. That is in no way protected under the first amendment. The fourth amendment is usually the one where judges find privacy rights. The first amendment is the opposite...it guarantees you the right to be public without being punished for it. It would even make more sense to argue that the fifth amendment protections on self-incrimination cover these recordings, though that would be a really hard sell considering wire taps don't enjoy that kind of protection.
- harryh 10y agoThe 5th amendment says you can't be forced to testify against yourself at a trial. It says nothing about things you say outside of a trial being used against you. It definitely doesn't apply here.
- ghaff 10y agoFurthermore, as I've read some of the commentary around this case, it's pretty clear that--even in technical circles--a lot of people assume that everything that's said in Alexa's earshot goes back to the mothership. I think it's a safe bet that the typical consumer isn't up on nuances like listening for a keyword is a local operation. Barring "Alexa: How do I clean up blood stains?" there's unlikely to be anything here (and would a Google search be any different?) But, if there were something incriminating in Alexa queries, the last thing Amazon wants is the inevitable headlines about how someone was convicted based on an Alexa recording which many would read as being an always-on ambient record.