5 ms·
Better title: "Green power subsidies are disruption the power economy". Subsidies are good for wind and solar, but corrosive to existing infrastructure, which a
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
Better title: "Green power subsidies are disruption the power economy". Subsidies are good for wind and solar, but corrosive to existing infrastructure, which are being squeezed to stay in business. Maybe some more measured plan would be good. Instead of blind enthusiasm.
- dmix 10y agoOnly 45% of energy subsidies in the US are going to renewable energy (that was in 2013). Quite a bit go to fossil fuel and nuclear as well. Historically from 1950-2010 only 9% of subsidies have gone to renewable energy. Fossil fuel was heavily subsidized for decades with hundreds of billions of dollars. Now it's shifting more to green tech but it's still not the majority. The effects of past subsidies to fossil fuels can still be felt in the industry as mines and wells subsidized long ago are still operational. So renewable energy is not entirely unique in this aspect. But I agree the real costs of renewable energy are not always obvious given how much of the federal/state government's thumb is on the scale. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_subsidies https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_subsidies
- spangry 10y agoNot trying to defend fossil fuels here, but I'd interpret that 2015 global fossil fuels subsidy figure ($5.3 trillion) with some caution. Looking at the paper, they're not really talking about direct subsidies. They're counting 'implicit subsidies' like "undercharging for global warming", "air pollution", "broader vehicle externalities" etc. These unpriced externalities make up at least 78% of the total estimated fossil fuel subsidy. This is a fair thing to do in theory, assuming the same approach is used when pricing other forms of energy generation. But deciding what is and is not an attributable externality is a bit subjective, and externalities themselves are notoriously difficult to quantify. All that aside, even if global warming somehow didn't exist, it still makes a lot of sense to phase out coal power generation, as it causes around one million deaths per year (mostly from air pollution).
- dmix 10y agoIs this the study you are referring to? http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X16304867 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X16... I believe he's pretty honest about the limits of the estimations and the difficulties defining "subsidy". > While there are many caveats (discussed below) to the estimation procedures and findings, the policy implications of the paper are clear: energy subsidies are very large and their removal (which entails levying Pigouvian taxes) would generate substantial environmental, fiscal, and economic welfare gains. All of those subsidies still have an overall effect on the market prices. The external costs (accidents, gas prices) are factored in as people decide to buy cars and company financial officers always consider tax deductions or other benefits. You don't have to hand cash to a firm to significantly reduce their operating expenses. Although I do agree that the decision by the study author to include things like congestion and road accidents is questionable... > Broader externalities associated with the use of road fuels in vehicles, such as traffic congestion, accidents, and (less importantly) road damage. Although motorists may internalize some of these costs (e.g., the average costs of road congestion, the risk of injuring themselves in single-vehicle collisions), they do not take into account other costs (e.g., their own contribution to slowing travel speeds for other road users, injury risks their driving imposes on pedestrians and other vehicle occupants). Even if you add say a carbon tax, what are the alternatives? Some people can't bike to work. Or taking public transit is not an option (especially in the US and Canada). And if you drive an electric car then you have the same problems of accidents and congestion.
- spangry 10y agoI agree on both your points re: the paper - the author was very upfront about the methodology and the car thing was a bit of an eyebrow raiser. Sorry if I gave the impression I was accusing the author of dishonesty: I didn't mean to suggest that. On road congestion specifically, the current 'mainstream' thinking is that variable congestion charging is probably a good way to price that externality. Weight also needs to be considered: large trucks do quite a bit more damage to roads than smaller vehicles. Unfortunately fuel taxes are a poor proxy for these kinds of externalities. That is to say, these should ideally be levied in addition to a carbon price. Singapore has variable congestion charging, but I guess it's a little easier to do if you're a small, autocratic island state. For me, a carbon tax or cap and trade system are by far the best policy responses to climate change and air pollution. Although (at least in Australia) they are rather unpopular. My observation is that people (and politicians) prefer lavish subsidies for this or that 'green' technology, because there's a greater sense you're "doing something", plus everyone hates tax. Unfortunately, direct subsidies are also horribly inefficient and almost certainly will cost far more than just pricing the externalities and letting the market figure the rest out. People seem to forget that the money being spent on these inefficient subsidies are their tax dollars, meaning the government has to cut services or raise taxes elsewhere (likely further compounding the efficiency cost of 'picking winners').
- 6d6b73 10y agoAnd nuclear, oil, coal were never subsidized? It's not like most of these huge power plants were built with gov money ,right? It's not like we spent billions to protect our interests in places that have abundance of oil, but lack of stability. It's not like we subsidize coal industry, farming and other part of the economy, right?
- dmix 10y agoCapitalism is responsible for fossil fuels and climate change but only kept alive by greed. Government is responsible for renewable energy and saving the planet but only kept alive by subsidies. That's the reductionist narrative that you find everywhere but largely misses the bigger picture. You don't have to dig very deep to find counter points.
- 6d6b73 10y agoWhile I would prefer that our society didn't have to depend on fossil fuels, without them our advanced society would not be possible. Fossil fuels are bad but they were/are necessary. All we need to do know is to just recognize that they will not be needed in the future, and keep investing into renewables.
- dmix 10y ago> All we need to do know is to just recognize that they will not be needed in the future, and keep investing into renewables. They may soon not be needed in western society - which can afford the capital investments into renewable tech and the subsidies to push rates to competitive markets rates. But all of those oil wells and mines still exist. They will just find a market in developing countries such as Asia and Africa. Africa is going to be where the greatest amount of population growth will be for the next few decades. Combine that will a flood of cheap oil and it will likely partially offset the benefits of renewable energy in the short term. Eventually renewable tech will be so cheap that it will no longer make economic sense to use oil/coal but I don't think that will happen globally as fast as people hope.