3 ms·
Surprised every time I'm in the US and see commercials for drugs and procedures that are administered by doctors being directed towards patients with the ending
by alkonaut 10y ago
Surprised every time I'm in the US and see commercials for drugs and procedures that are administered by doctors being directed towards patients with the ending "ask your doctor about xyz".
I'm fairly sure this kind of thing ends up with patients asking/pressuring doctors for treatments they don't need.
- coldcode 10y agoI find these utterly idiotic: you are telling patients about side effects of some drug with pretty pictures and a pleasant voice but only a doctor can prescribe them and you would assume understand the side effects and contraindications. What is the point? Other than obviously make drug companies more money.
- noxToken 10y agoThat is the point. Drugs x, y, and z are all the market. They do the same thing with the same side-effects for the same cost. An ailment that the drug cures pops up in someone's life. When they go to the doctor, they can ask specifically for drug z, because they saw drug z in a commercial. If our drugs, for all intents and purposes, are the exact same, then there is no point in a doctor prescribing drug x or y when the patient specifically asked for drug z.
- randcraw 10y agoAny two drugs are most definitely not the same unless one is a generic of the other. And even then, because different manufacturers package drugs differently, this can slightly affect a compound's delivery. Even when two drugs use the same mechanism of action (an agonist or antogist toward the same receptor active in the synthesis of a target protein), different generations of drugs often produce significantly different pharmacodynamic profiles of efficacy and toxicity that affect people differently. A good example are the diabetes drugs Actos vs Avandia -- same MoA (glitazones), but the latter has proven to be toxic. Fact is, no two drugs are the same, unless they both do nothing.
- noxToken 10y ago> If our drugs, for all intents and purposes, are the exact same This include the above. The point was that the drugs are the same in every way possible. Although this is most certainly not the case for drugs x, y and z, our example hinges on them being the same. Otherwise the doctor always should prescribe the best medication for the given situation.
- alkonaut 10y agoIf there are multiple treatments/drugs that achieve the same thing then the job of the SG is to recommend which to use. Usage of anything else should be viewed with a healthy amount of suspicion.
- SilasX 10y agoBecause, as shocking and offensive as it may sound, not every doctor is 100% diligent about researching a patient's options. They also may not have sufficient incentive to care about whether a non-life-threatening condition is actually cured.
- Symmetry 10y agoNot everybody is going to tell their doctor that they're impotent or whatever unless they have some idea that there's a pill that cures that. People don't even necessarily have regular checkups if there's nothing they want a doctor to fix.
- jessriedel 10y agoUnsurprisingly, the FDA thought of this. They have concluded so far that drug ads are a net benefit for consumers. > Other highlights of the surveys include: > Most physicians agreed that because their patient saw a DTC ad, he or she asked thoughtful questions during the visit. About the same percentage of physicians thought the ad made their patients more aware of possible treatments. > Many physicians thought that DTC ads made their patients more involved in their health care. > Physicians thought the ads did not convey information about risks and benefits equally well. Seventy-eight percent of physicians believe their patients understand the possible benefits of the drug very well or somewhat, compared to 40 percent who believe their patients understand the possible risks, and 65 percent believe DTC ads confuse patients about the relative risks and benefits of prescription drugs. In addition, about 75 percent of physicians surveyed believed that DTC ads cause patients to think that the drug works better than it does, and many physicians felt some pressure to prescribe something when patients mentioned DTC ads. > Eight percent of physicians said they felt very pressured to prescribe the specific brand-name drug when asked. > DTC ads help patients have better discussions with their physicians and provide greater awareness of treatments. The study demonstrated that when a patient asked about a specific drug, 88 percent of the time they had the condition that the drug treated. And 80 percent of physicians believed their patients understood what condition the advertised drug treats. > Doctors believe that patients understand that they need to consult a health care professional about appropriate treatment. Eighty-two percent responded either "very well" or "somewhat" when asked whether they believe that their patients understand that only a doctor can decide whether a drug is right for them. https://www.fda.gov/Drugs/ResourcesForYou/Consumers/ucm143562.htm https://www.fda.gov/Drugs/ResourcesForYou/Consumers/ucm14356... Folks can argue that the FDA is biased in favor of drug companies at the expense of consumers, but then this would be a huge problem with the central mission of the FDA. It's not clear why we would trust it for approving drugs/treatment, but not trust it for considering the affects of adverisements.
- intopieces 10y agoIf the ads help, is it reasonable then for the FDA to instead run ads based on the target demographic's most common diseases/ailments? Then they can talk to a doctor and the doctor can decide the best medicine.