5 ms·
This runner cheated consciously, lied afterward, covered up the cheat with a conspiracy later (biking the route to create a fake data trail). Its hard to smear
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
This runner cheated consciously, lied afterward, covered up the cheat with a conspiracy later (biking the route to create a fake data trail). Its hard to smear any investigation as 'obsessive' compared to that.
And cheating at public events is not innocent. Its a rupture of the social contract, up there with stealing and libel. It should be dealt with promptly and vigorously. She should be banned from all further events. This is not the sort of person you want in your society, in your business, in your life.
I'm more disturbed with the evident impulse to forgive. Is nothing important any more? Is character and honesty so worthless?
- nswanberg 10y agoI think those who would forgive her believe that the response is disproportionate, and that the cheating doesn't rate worldwide infamy. I guess I side with runnr_az on this in that what she did is not right but it also isn't very important. But maybe he and I share the same worldview on running and racing, in that in almost all cases racing's value comes from doing the race, not the result. Yes, in the moment I'll do whatever I can to scratch out one higher place in the result, but after the race is done it really doesn't matter if I got 23rd or 123rd. Those that finished faster could have trained harder, trained more, had more experience, had better coaching, had better genetics, or even cheated, but I found that in the end those places don't matter nearly as much as the experience I got, and even if I found out that one or five or twenty people had cheated in the races I've done, it wouldn't have taken away from that experience. I guess if one subscribes to the race-as-life metaphor, where cheating in a race is tantamount to stealing from someone, and how one acts in a race is how one will act in the rest of life, I can see more reasons to get angry, but I think that viewing this as "rupturing the social contract" is a more extreme view, and is entering the area that Hugo was exploring with the Inspector Javert character. Yes, she cheated, yes it's wrong, and yes, she should face consequences, but how much mental energy should we expend in the pursuit and punishment of this cheating? I think I'm almost as disturbed by the obsession with the cheating as by the cheating itself. Maybe this thinking is objectively wrong, but at least for me that's why, if forgiveness means not to ban her from all future events, my impulse is to forgive.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThat seems like a kind of double-think. The race is important or it isn't; its meaningful to ban her or it isn't. If the race isn't that important, then 'banned for life' is a symbolic gesture only.
- nswanberg 10y agoOther people are saying this in other ways in the thread, but the race is what someone makes of it. If what someone cares about is their place, and that's all that's important, I can see how what I wrote could be black and white. But for a lot of people, especially as the race distance gets longer unless one is on the podium one's place really doesn't matter for a race to be important, and it isn't worth caring much about whether someone is cheating.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoExcept that cheats must be exposed and excoriated, for all our sakes.
- npunt 10y agoI didn't mean 'obsessive' as a smear, more that they were dogged in their pursuit, going as far as crunching biometrics and zooming in on a watch for evidence (enhance.. enhance.. [1]). It was an entertaining read since it looked eerily similar to how conspiracy sites construct their hilarious conclusions. And yet, it was real. Also, 'relatively innocent' was meant in context of buying instagram followers, not in cheating. > I'm more disturbed with the evident impulse to forgive. Is nothing important any more? Is character and honesty so worthless? The thing I'm most disturbed by in these threads is how easily nuance is lost to the power of righteous indignation. It's like we're reading an entirely different set of comments. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vxq9yj2pVWk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vxq9yj2pVWk
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoYou have to draw a hard line on cheating. Else it all falls apart. This person is not 'nuanced'. They are a calculating conniver, a con, a selfish calculating persistent cheat. The 'I'm sorry' letter reads like a con trying another tack. Cons are very skilled at manipulating the audience. They want exactly the reaction the 'forgive and forget' crowd are giving them.