2 ms·
No, I claimed that all scientist would have had the experience of not reproducing something. Because if they do it a lot, as part of a regular process then they
by ZeroGravitas 10y ago
No, I claimed that all scientist would have had the experience of not reproducing something. Because if they do it a lot, as part of a regular process then they will eventually find something that doesn't work because the original scientist didn't document a step correctly or misread the results or just got lucky due to random chance.
Just like all developers will eventually find a bug in code they code review. This is different from all code they review having bugs.
- endorphone 10y agoWhile the wording may be vague, they aren't talking about the experiences of a subset of researchers -- they are saying that of the experiments they tried to replicate, 2/3rds weren't reproduceable. That is terrible, and has absolutely nothing to do with finding bugs.