3 ms·
Nobody's saying it's "good enough". Once we see one attack we expect to start seeing more. What's being pointed out here is that this particular attack does not
by jerf 10y ago
Nobody's saying it's "good enough". Once we see one attack we expect to start seeing more. What's being pointed out here is that this particular attack does not let you craft custom git repos whose HEAD matches one of an existing repo. Nobody is asserting that to be generically impossible, and this new attack is at least weak evidence that such an attack may eventually be practical.
- mike_hearn 10y agoI think this is perhaps not the case. HEADs move. People contribute code. Sure, if you take a snapshot of every git repo you will ever use today and never move past those commits, this attack doesn't help. Obviously nobody will do that. People, potentially malicious people, will continue to contribute commits which they could have collided with one that does something different. I'd think that using commit hashes as a security mechanism will soon be dead.