4 ms·
This data is already in OpenStreetMap. Looking around, there are zero places in the Netherlands and I am certain I tagged at least a few places myself so this m
by lucb1e 10y ago
This data is already in OpenStreetMap. Looking around, there are zero places in the Netherlands and I am certain I tagged at least a few places myself so this map is less complete because they want to do it themselves.
It also contains opening hours, addresses, etc., which is all in OSM. I don't understand why people always try to start anew when the data is right there. I can understand there is some complexity in getting your user's contributed data back into OSM and dealing with edit conflicts and abuse, but at least use it as a starting point and see about contributing back later.
(Also, Google Maps is such a confusing map, I hardly even recognize the town I've lived in for 20 years. But that is probably because I'm used to OSM.)
- benguild 10y agoSo, I would say it's less about "everywhere" versus highlighting the best places. That's why there's a rating system involved.
- qrv3w 10y agoHow do you get OSM to display cafes or restaurants?
- rakoo 10y agoDepending on who you talk to, OSM means 2 different things: - For people involved or passionate in the project, OSM is the database. All information is stored there and is available for consumption - For people outside of the project, OSM is the website displaying the rendered map. As with all rendering, some information is lost, some is put in front. If you want this information, you can use the overpass API (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Overpass_API); https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Overpass_API); at higher volumes you may want to get extracts of the db and query it directly, or use a custom renderer to have your own beautiful map with the data you want. Unfortunately there is no way to make the OSM website display specific information on a case-by-case basis.
- lucb1e 10y agoUse a viewer like openstreetmap.org.
- SyneRyder 10y ago> It also contains opening hours, addresses, etc., which is all in OSM. I don't understand why people always try to start anew when the data is right there. It's a while since I played with OSM data for my own prototype, but I found most of the entries were 3 or 4 years out of date, and didn't include anything except a name and GPS co-ordinates. Some didn't even include a name. There was only one entry in my city with opening hours, and that entry didn't differentiate between days of the week. Some entries contained typos, and there was no consistency with naming of chains (eg one person calls it Dome, another Dome Coffee, another The Dome, and another Dome Coffee Fremantle). In short, OSM was a really bad dataset (at that time) and I found it better to start from scratch.
- lucb1e 10y agoQuality varies a lot, mostly from country to country (at least in western Europe, perhaps on other continents it's more regional). Whatever the quality though, it's a better start than nothing. Why would user data contributed to your application be any better than the user data contributed through OSM? It's a lot easier to edit an invalid property than have a completely blank map and start from scratch. Also, if projects like these would use OSM (some do, but not all), the quality gets better and it improves for everyone instead of for your specific project.
- SyneRyder 10y ago> Why would user data contributed to your application be any better than the user data contributed through OSM? I populated my data manually. I visited stores personally, talked to staff & store owners, measured GPS co-ordinates & WiFi speeds & counted power outlets in person. "Do Things That Don't Scale." Even as one person, I was able to create a dataset for my city that was 2.5x larger than OSM had, with better accuracy and more comprehensive attribute data. I got the idea after reading about the Google Maps Ground Truth team - turned out their secret sauce was an army of paid staff that could be sent out on demand to specific locations that needed to be verified in person.
- JadeNB 10y ago
- benguild 10y agoYou're incorrect. This data is not in OSM or elsewhere, it's fragmented. People have tried to build massive databases of places, yet there are clear gaps in the data all over the place. Perhaps topic-based apps and data are better. Here's the solution for that, starting with Café Wifi. If you think one company and site can do everything well, look at what is happening to Facebook.