7 ms·
I'd like to see a comprehensive breakdown of exactly what you should do in real situations when approached by cops. For example, do you literally utter no word
by baddox 17y ago
I'd like to see a comprehensive breakdown of exactly what you should do in real situations when approached by cops. For example, do you literally utter no words and just stare at them, or do you keep repeating "I'd rather not answer that." If the cops make a false claim, such as "we can arrest you for interfering with a police investigation if you don't answer," should you call them on the lie or what? Also a more specific breakdown by state would be great (e.g. do I have to carry/show ID while walking/driving/in my home. I've seen some rather cheesy video dramatizations (I think from the ACLU) of what to do in a traffic stop, but a nice comprehensive document would be the best.
- mootothemax 17y ago"No comment" all the way. I used to work with several ex-Policemen (UK), and their advice was exactly the same: "no comment." One thing I stupidly didn't ask at the time though was whether there was potential for badness if you expanded on your answer, e.g. "I don't want to comment without my solicitor being present." versus "No comment." Anyone have any ideas?
- ErrantX 17y ago> e.g. "I don't want to comment without my solicitor being present." versus "No comment." Anyone have any ideas? Yes. My Boss, an ex-copper, says that you should always do the former and never the latter. Also, be polite and restrained. Respond to small talk. Be honest. If you clam up, stay silent, and repeat no comment they will treat that as mildly suspicious.
- dotBen 17y agoOne issue with this is that if you pull out the "I don't wish to comment without my solicitor being present" line as soon as the cop starts talking to you then they can just detain you (ie not arrest you) and take you to the police station to give you the opportunity to get your legal counsel present so they can continue. Saying that you won't comment without legal counsel doesn't mean the police officer is going to go away. It just means the s/he will have to make a judgement call on letting you go or taking you in for questioning (detainment, not arrest) and so you are risking a loss of liberty if that occurs.
- ErrantX 17y agoYeh, absolutely. I'd say if a cop stops you in the street - just answer their questions if it seems reasonable. Or refuse (don't mention lawyers) if not. Never had any issues myself with this approach.
- jrockway 17y agoYeah, but then your legal counsel shows up, asks "is my client free to go", and then you leave.
- philwelch 17y ago"I don't consent to any searches" is a good thing to say if they ask to search you or your car, or if they just try and start to.
- jacquesm 17y agoWhy? I got stopped in Canada, and was asked that same question. I said sure, go ahead, took 5 minutes and I was on my way again. Same happened somewhere in Texas on a road trip, same outcome. I asked my lawyer in Canada what would happen if I did not consent to a search, and he said they would probably have taken that as a reason to stop me again a few miles down the road for some infraction and would have searched the car top to bottom with a fine comb. If you have nothing in your car it's quite ok to have it searched, what specific reason would you have not to consent in the knowledge they can force the issue if they want to?
- dotBen 17y agogood question. I would suggest: a) you might have passengers in the car who have something ilegal on them. in many states if a passenger drops drugs in your car so that it is not on their person, and no one admits to it, then it is considered the driver's property. Yes, even good friends might rat on you in this situation. b) If the cop is looking to find anything to make an arrest to help them go with a hunch about you then they can start inspecting your tires or placement of a GPS on the window (illegal in many states) and could then drum up a charge of driving dangerous vehicle etc. c) rental cars - you can never 100% check a rental car and it has been known for innocent people in Las Vegas to get stopped and the police find traces of cocaine powder etc in the ash try or coin holder, etc that belonged to a previous renter In my case... I drive a sports car and so I keep nothing in the car in order for it to be as light as possible (no junk in the back, no crap on the floor). I have nothing in the car, I've never been in the possession of a controlled substance, I know my car is in top condition, etc... and I still wouldn't let the police search my car.
- jacquesm 17y agoa) is a good one, b) is something I didn't know about, thanks for that one (currently not visiting the States, possibly never again, but a good warning all the same), c) I've been warned about and I check rental cars thoroughly. Probably not as thoroughly as a police search but more than good enough to spot the vast majority of items left behind by previous occupants (and I should probably make a listing of that some day, it makes for interesting reading). The most annoying stop ever was one in Germany in a relatively fancy car, when I was still young. They couldn't quite match the skinny kid in the jeans and the t-shirt with the car unless there were drugs involved and they took they time about it. I think they spent a whole hour and when I drove off they still thought I'd tricked them somehow. I've never before had my peppermints checked for illegal substances :)
- phren0logy 17y agoI am not a lawyer, but my understanding his that they must stop the interrogation at the moment you invoke your right to an attorney. My thought would be that if they continue to press you, politely but firmly tell them that you really don't feel comfortable answering any more questions until your lawyer arrives.
- jacquesm 17y agoSo, you get to visit the station until your lawyer arrives, I guarantee it. If an officer asks you a simple question and you give them the third degree, they'll respond in kind. "I don't know" is a valid answer and will work in all those cases where there isn't any hard proof that you do know (or a tip-off). If you do know and there has been a tip-off (so they know you know) they'll press you pretty hard for information. I've travelled all over the world in cars with foreign plates and that's a great way to meet the local law enforcement types (Canadian plates in the Southern US states for instance seem to have some magical property that attracts police vehicles), on the whole policemen (rather than 'cops') have a job to do and if you make it harder they'll make your life harder. If you feel you are being treated unfair simply shut up. Going lawyerly on them is going to backfire on you. The police can be really annoying in some countries, and any advice in this thread should be adapted to local customs. Not volunteering any information is a good start and is probably universal.
- TomOfTTB 17y agoFor what it's worth this is what I would say... Look, I’ve been told in the past that it’s not a good idea to talk to the police without a lawyer present. The people who told me this were experts on this sort of thing and the point they made is that innocent people have been convicted by accidentally saying something that implicated them. They also made the point that this has happened even when the police officers themselves believed the person was innocent because those officers turned the case over to a District Attorney who really just wanted a conviction. So while I know you’re just doing your job by trying to get me to talk to you I need you to understand my outlook on this which is that my life might depend on me keeping my mouth shut right now. What I will say is that I’m completely innocent of these charges and I think you’re wasting your time talking to me. Beyond that I’m going to keep my mouth shut from this point on and wait for my lawyer. Thanks for understanding. ...As far as any false claims the police might make they don't have the right to do anything without a warrant so I'd use vaguely the same speech as above but substitute in "I've been told you need a warrant to search my person or possessions" Edit: I just IMed a friend who is a lawyer and he made a good point on searches. When the police claim they have the right to search your person or possessions you want to do two things. First, explicitly say you forbid them to search unless you are legally required to allow them to do it. Second make them take physical action (e.g. if they want to search you tell them you won’t empty your own pockets but you won’t resist if they search your pockets). Do these two things and you’ll never be searched unduly.
- dotBen 17y ago"I need you to understand my outlook on this which is that my life might depend on me keeping my mouth shut right now." I wouldn't say that, it implies guilt (by the letter of the law and justice an innocent person's life wouldn't depend on them keeping their mouth shut). Further more, the specific phrase "my life might depend on me keeping my mouth shut" could be interpreted by a cop as being more than what you mean - eg maybe you are harboring a criminal who has threatened to kill you. As geeks, I think we have a tendency to 'front load' a lot of this as we try to explain our logic. A short "No comment" is best and the more you say, even in trying to justify your logic, opens up opportunity for a cop to use something against you.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoAnd even beyond that... You're supposed to refuse to talk until "your lawyer" is present. Now, I've used a lawyer's services for making a will, and my boss's wife is a lawyer specializing in environmental matters. But I don't have any sort of connection with a lawyer that would handle criminal matters. Should one make contact with a potential lawyer today, before anything happens, and carry the lawyer's card in your pocket? Should you just call any lawyer you know at the point you need it, and ask for a referral?
- TomOfTTB 17y agoThis seems obvious to me. Put it this way, if you're ever accused of a serious crime your life will hang in the balance. So how much research would you be willing to do to save your own life? Now if you get arrested for a serious crime you'll have one phone call and no time to do research. So yeah, I'd at least ask around and find out who the best criminal lawyer in my area is (and make sure I have his number handy)
- CWuestefeld 17y agoThat much makes sense. But do you think I should just find out who he is and store his name and number in my phone? Or is there some standard process with a lawyer, where you contact him ahead of time and ask if you can keep him on file just in case?
- dotBen 17y agoIt would be wise to find out rates at the very least! Some lawyers might charge more than you can afford. You might also want to ask the receptionist/assistant who answers calls to the office how you contact the lawyer outside of office hours and whether they need a retainer on file in order to service clients in these kinds of circumstances (ie call them out cos you have been arrested at 3am on a Saturday night).
- ErrantX 17y agoNo, don't bother. The chance of you being able to get that specific person in all situations is low anyway. Don't ask for "your" lawyer. Ask for "a" lawyer. Unless you're in a serious mess (in which case you will need proper, expensive, legal counsel) anyone will do. Usually the rote lawyers provided by the tax payer (here in the UK that is a right, Im not sure if it is elsewhere) are fine for these situations. Lawyers can get expensive fast - especially if the Police decide to play awkward.
- keefe 17y agoA friend of mine got in trouble once so I have had the inestimable pleasure of being interviewed by police. Here's the thing - there's all sorts of technicalities they may or may not use. If you totally stonewall them? If they have any leverage, they will use that leverage. You want them to lose interest in you. A traffic stop you just comply politely, decline to be searched and say: there is no sense having a right to privacy if it is not exercised, Officer X. Here's what I did: 0) Officer : Keefe, I hear X happened, what about Y? 1) Keefe : oh, I dunno...mumble... I'm so embarrassed... this is so embarrassing <looks at feet> 3) Goto 0 After a while, he lost interest. I saw the police report afterwards where I was noted as "uncooperative". They don't know that you're not a social reject or something, just refuse to interact.
- tokenadult 17y agoI'd like to see a comprehensive breakdown of exactly what you should do in real situations when approached by cops. I just read a very helpful book about that, Arrest-Proof Yourself: An Ex-Cop Reveals How Easy It Is for Anyone to Get Arrested, How Even a Single Arrest Could Ruin Your Life, and What to Do If the Police Get in Your Face by R. Dale Carson, http://www.amazon.com/Arrest-Proof-Yourself-Ex-Cop-Reveals-Arrested/dp/1556526377 http://www.amazon.com/Arrest-Proof-Yourself-Ex-Cop-Reveals-A... which was recommended in another thread by another HN participant. Hat tip to him. The book is very interesting and practical. (I am a lawyer and used to be a judicial clerk, but I learned new facts from the book.)