4 ms·
It's something you should share with your children (grown or not). I have a particular interest in this subject because of "zero tolerance" policies in schools.
by w1ntermute 16y ago
It's something you should share with your children (grown or not). I have a particular interest in this subject because of "zero tolerance" policies in schools. Too often, children defer to authority -- as they've been taught by ...uh... the authorities -- and when the principal says "Write out what happened and sign it," that resulting confession is often given to the police. Cops certainly can't demand that a suspect write a confession without first advising the suspect of their rights ("You have the right to remain silent..."), but school officials -- typically government agents in their own right -- don't seem to have a problem obtaining confessions for use against their own students, even without bringing in their parents first (let alone a lawyer). Kids (and adults!) often don't understand that they are sealing their own fate when they comply with such outrageous demands.
The kids don't have a choice in this situation, do they? From what I remember, the Supreme Court has ruled that students in public schools don't have constitutional rights. If the school wants to expel the student for not talking, they can do so.
- katanil 16y agoActually, the SCOTUS has ruled the opposite. In the case Tinker vs. Des Moines, the court ruled that the students who were wearing arm-bands as a protest against the Vietnam War enjoyed first-amendment protection and discipline from the school was illegal. The court has been much more lenient on searches -- see New Jersey v T. L. O. However, you still need at least some reasonable ground for a search to be legal. As for interrogations, the supreme court has yet to rule on it. There is, however, a case brewing: http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2010/0405/Supreme-Court-lets-stand-ruling-in-self-incrimination-case http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2010/0405/Supreme-Court.... The fact that it's written in such a fashion as to be assumed that students have Fifth Amendment rights and the court cases are arguing over a technicality of pre-trial processing would seem to imply that students don't shed that right, either. Specifically: "A juvenile court judge determined that Paul did not understand that he had a right to remain silent and a right to have a lawyer and his parents present for the entire interrogation. The judge ruled that police coerced Paul’s confession."
- scott_s 16y agoPublic school students don't have full first amendment rights. If the speech interferes with the school's ability to conduct classes, the administration can stop it. I don't know the case name, but this was established in a case with a high school principal censoring the school newspaper.
- dgordon 16y agoHazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier. "Instead of "teach[ing] children to respect the diversity of ideas that is fundamental to the American system," and "that our Constitution is a living reality, not parchment preserved under glass," the Court today "teach[es] youth to discount important principles of our government as mere platitudes." The young men and women of Hazelwood East expected a civics lesson, but not the one the Court teaches them today." --Justice William J. Brennan, in dissent on said case
- baddox 16y agoExpulsion is another issue altogether, outside the law. The point is, students shouldn't talk to police officers just like they shouldn't talk to strangers.
- code_duck 16y agoMy high school vice principal loved to remind me that he didn't need 'probable cause' to search students persons or possessions, only 'reasonable doubt'.