3 ms·
> I feel this points to the need to abandon adversarial approaches to truth-seeking and public oversight and look for more cooperative ones. Adversarial systems
by kbenson 10y ago
> I feel this points to the need to abandon adversarial approaches to truth-seeking and public oversight and look for more cooperative ones. Adversarial systems are really easy to game and tend to result in over-simplifications of complex problems which are then exploited in turn.
I agree, but know little about the topic. Do you have any information on information dissemination and consensus (which naturally would extend to governing systems to some degree) that are less adversarial? I'm a big believer in capitalism and competition (with appropriate controls) for some systems, but free markets only work efficiently when the information is good. Broken information systems lead to poorly functioning markets (in the general term of market, which in this case could be public policy decisions or elections).
- anigbrowl 10y agoI'm afraid I don't really know what to suggest on developing consensus systems. the only thing I can bring to mind right now is a rather dry but worthwhile book called Adversarial Legalism by Robert Kagan which I think has a lot to say about the psychology of disputation in the US and (indirectly) how our whole system of governance has become so politicized.