3 ms·
1. Most students may not be interested in research, but my question WRT to that and the research university model is, are they best served by a facility that do
by hga 17y ago
1. Most students may not be interested in research, but my question WRT to that and the research university model is, are they best served by a facility that does real research?
I think so, at least in those fields where cargo cult science/engineering/humanities/etc. don't have a strong hold. Professors who are doing real world stuff have a variety of advantages ... then again, in too many schools too much instruction is handled by callow grad students.
2. I use MIT as an example as an example. I.e. what's your excuse for not doing this (directed at those schools that don't do it). We are talking about reform, so I'm drawing on my knowledge of what works and what doesn't.
3. We'll have to agree to disagree.
5. I'm not so sure enough of the country has it, especially if this further saturates the overloaded satellites that serve a lot of rural folks.
I don't think it's a red herring, I think you should acknowledge it's an issue that needs quantification and workarounds. E.g. satellite learning centers that have good connections that those who don't have broadband or good enough broadband (which includes more than you'd think of Silicon Valley) can go to each day when they need that much bandwidth.
However, the above compromise loses the ... immersive aspect of residential undergraduate education that I think good broadband could provide a version of.
6. If co-op is mandatory is precludes e.g. doing real research in a professor's lab during the summer. Which could be addressed by defining co-op to include that.
Let's take my major, chemistry. One friend did a co-op at Exxon working on figuring out why one of the four huge oil coking ovens they had built was producing "gunk". She learned a lot, found it valuable. I would have preferred doing academic research, since that was the path I was going on. She wasn't wrong and I probably wasn't either.
7. I'm not sure acquiring a Ph.D., or at least a Masters, is only for a tiny minority of students. There are a lot of engineering fields that need more than four years of instruction. In the sciences, not getting the Ph.D. relegates you to a dead end of lab work at the direction of others. However, in these fields you do get paid to do your post-graduate work, which tells us something.
In other fields I don't know, but we can be sure many are producing too many doctorates. Or undergraduates for that matter. But if someone wants to pay their own way, who are we to deny them? Many of the current excesses there should get rung out as the higher education bubble pops.