4 ms·
The problem is it's very easy to make entering the country hard for legal immigrants and tourists - you just make tons of strict rules, tell border control to e
by smsm42 10y ago
The problem is it's very easy to make entering the country hard for legal immigrants and tourists - you just make tons of strict rules, tell border control to enforce them vigorously and voila! But it's much harder to crack down on illegal immigration, since by definition they won't follow laws and rules.
You'll need to spend a lot of money and effort on finding them and getting them out, on enforcing eligibility checks at workplaces, etc. And face very strong political opposition - since it's one thing just not to let the person in and very different thing to uproot a person who already has been in for a while, got some local contacts, established themselves, etc.
Now add people that oppose virtually any immigration enforcement for political reasons, and you've got the situation US is now in - there are about 10M illegal immigrants, about 1M have final deportation orders (which mean the state ordered them to leave now, all process, appeals, etc. have been exhausted) and ICE has in custody about 12K (yes, 12K out of 1M), where are the rest - nobody knows and nobody will know.
- al2o3cr 10y agoYou seem to have conveniently forgotten that there are two sides to undocumented employment and left the employer totally unmentioned. If we were serious about "solving the problem", it would be easy: the next time we bust somebody running a place with $2/hr undocumented workers we PUT HIM THE FUCK IN JAIL and seize the business as proceeds from illegal acts. Instead, we hand out puny fines and play along with "sure, I was paying them $2/hr but I had no idea about their status!" game while employers can use the threat of calling ICE to keep workers silent.
- bb611 10y agoYes, there's strong political opposition to immigration enforcement, but there's also strong opposition to illegal work enforcement. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/09/us/california-farmers-backed-trump-but-now-fear-losing-field-workers.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/09/us/california-farmers-bac... If anyone were serious about this problem, E-verify would be in force everywhere and the working population that supports 12M undocumented immigrants would be out of work tomorrow, and out of the country the next day.
- smsm42 10y agoThe article makes very little sense. Trump's orders were about a) limiting immigrants and refugees from Syria, Iraq, Sudan, etc. and b) removal of criminal illegal aliens (of which for vast majority of them ICE has no idea where they are so it's as useful as ordering the sun to raise of the west). But field workers are predominantly Mexican or Latin American, and vast majority of them do not commit any crimes except possibly illegal entry or visa overstay. So what's the connection with Trump orders?
- bb611 10y agoThe article's premise is that most people thought Trump was bluffing/lying about barring Muslims, as well as about increasing deportation of undocumented workers. These executive orders proved Trump was serious about Muslims, and the NY Times simply found people who then realized that he probably is serious about undocumented workers as well. Basically all the fears in this article were realized with the DHS announcements yesterday: https://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-immigrant-crackdown-worries-food-and-restaurant-industries-1487799016 https://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-immigrant-crackdown-worri...