4 ms·
Empire Strikes 30: Ars looks back at an amazing film
- akkartik 16y agoI always thought it was the height of indulgence for star wars to be a trilogy. Compress episode 4 down to 10 minutes, episode 6 down to 20, and slap them on either side of Empire Strikes Back, untouched. I suspect the result would be startling. I didn't realize Lucas contributed so little to this movie. That explains a lot.
- loganfrederick 16y agoI disagree. Having just watched Episode 4 when this story was posted, there is no way on the stories of Luke's origin with Obi Wan, development of the Force, meeting Han Solo, rescuing the princess, establishing the power of the Death Star and Darth Vader, having Vader fight Obi Wan with meaning, and have the Rebels fight the Empire all in 10 minutes and still have people understand and care about what's happening. tl;dr: You'd lose all the character development and be forcing plot into a film where no one cared about any of the characters.
- philwelch 16y agoThis isn't Reddit or anything--the quality of discourse is (hopefully still) high enough on HN that people can be arsed to read a three line paragraph without needing a tl;dr.
- zb 16y agoBasically there are only two stories. I don't mean in Star Wars; just in general. Let's call them The Iliad and The Odyssey. A New Hope was essentially just The Iliad In Space. So far, so good if you like that kind of thing (I personally never cared for it). The next two were basically The Odyssey. In space. Which was one more movie than was strictly justified. (I agree with the article that The Empire Strikes Back was the one good film in the series.) The three prequels probably cover about the first 10 pages of The Iliad, which was three more movies than was justified.
- dkarl 16y agoSo, is there anywhere in the world where a person can legally buy a copy of the original trilogy? It's 2010, I'm all grown up, I make a good living, and I still can't buy Star Wars. This sucks.
- percept 16y agoIf it helps, an update mentioned an unaltered 2006 DVD release . . . Based on what I've read (and semi-relevant here) I see Lucas as a good founding entrepreneur-type who created an awesome world and then was at his best when he stepped aside and let others handle the technical details. Four words you don't want to see consecutively: "George Lucas will direct."
- philwelch 16y agoThey released the unaltered trilogy on DVD in 2006. Not sure if it's still available. http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Star_Wars_DVD_releases#Star_Wars_Trilogy_-_Unaltered http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Star_Wars_DVD_releases#Star_W... UPDATE: Yep, still available. http://shop.starwars.com/catalog/product.xml?topcatID=1300264;product_id=1307374 http://shop.starwars.com/catalog/product.xml?topcatID=130026... "Featuring the Special Edition and original theatrical versions of all three films in the original trilogy"
- dkarl 16y agoThat explains why I never found it: I'm kind of allergic to the Special Edition. Is there any way I can buy the original without paying for the Special Edition as well? I'd rather my money not be used as proof of fan acceptance of that abomination.
- philwelch 16y agoSorry, that's the best I can find :( There are, of course, ways to get the original unaltered trilogy...but we'll leave it at that.
- 16y ago
- simonsarris 16y ago> Star Wars: The Empire Strikes back is one of the best science fiction films ever made. I do think that Empire Strikes Back is an enormously enjoyable film, but I take at them calling it science fiction. I feel this might be a bit of an unpopular sentiment, but Star Wars was never really science fiction at all. It had all the things Ars said it did: Good story, good character development, good settings, good effects, but at the end of the day it was literally a Fantasty/Romance with a large FX budget (for the time). There was no science that was actually integral to the series itself, or at least none that could not have been replaced with Knights-and-dragons style elements just as easily. Compare to the story elements to (just for instance) Ghost in the Shell, which was a science fiction that asked a lot of questions: In the future, how will people deal with cyborgs? How will they deal with longer lifespans? How will they deal with 21st century governments breaking down? How will society deal with a new and more pervasive "net?" The show tries to deal with many of the pains of emerging technologies and an evolving world. Compared to such sci-fi, Star Wars was just a romance novel plus lasers. Empire Strikes Back was good, definitely, but not precisely because of sci-fi elements.