2 ms·
> "removing soda for poor people" isn't really even the case. it's just not allowing food stamps to pay for soda. I think, effectively, people will just use cas
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> "removing soda for poor people" isn't really even the case. it's just not allowing food stamps to pay for soda. I think, effectively, people will just use cash for that, and not change their habits. So $5 less for gas, or rent, or whatever they might actually use the cash for.
It's worse than that, because SNAP isn't intended to, and generally doesn't, provide 100% of your food budget. So removing unwanted things from the list of what you can buy with it is completely ineffective because yesterday people were buying soda with SNAP and meats with cash and tomorrow they just buy soda with cash and meats with SNAP.
This is one of the reasons why replacing things like SNAP with a UBI gives an efficiency gain. Because of that substitution effect, the entire bureaucracy dedicated to making sure people buy "the right things" with SNAP doesn't actually restrict what people buy and is a pure dead-weight economic loss.
Compare education subsidies, which actually do restrict what people buy, and are therefore worse than a UBI because they do this: http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/06/06/against-tulip-subsidies/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/06/06/against-tulip-subsidies...
And if you actually want people to drink less soda, stop subsidizing the production of corn syrup.
- yourapostasy 10y ago> And if you actually want people to drink less soda, stop subsidizing the production of corn syrup. Eliminate all sugar subsidies would have better health outcomes. Big Sugar is a real lobbying force to reckon with in US politics. Considering how damaging sugar is to the US healthcare system's overall affordability that all US citizens pay for, I'm not opposed to an instantaneous elimination of the subsidies, and let the chips of the attendant unemployment associated with Big Sugar fall where they may. Those subsidies come with a horrendous long tail of consequences.