5 ms·
>What is the market for +10% on groceries and basic necessities? People who live in the suburbs without cars. Cities are successfully discouraging car ownersh
by closeparen 10y ago
>What is the market for +10% on groceries and basic necessities?
People who live in the suburbs without cars.
Cities are successfully discouraging car ownership by making parking scarce near downtown offices and even the suburban transit stations that lead to downtown offices. At the same time, cities aren't permitting the construction of dense, walkable neighborhoods, at least not fast enough to make them affordable. So you have a large and growing segment of the population with:
- A built environment where distances are scaled for driving.
- A hard time justifying car ownership, since it isn't useful for commuting.
- Neighborhoods which are now becoming crowded enough that parking is a hassle, but haven't become dense enough to have useful businesses within a convenient walk. (When they reach this point, they may cease to be affordable).
"Outsourced driving" is immensely popular in such environments. Instead of Target and Walmart and BestBuy, you use Amazon Prime for most purchases. Instead of driving the SUV to the supermarket every week, you use Amazon Fresh, or (in the case of Instacart) pay someone else to do it or you. Instead of going out to eat or picking up takeout, you order from UberEats/Grubhub/whatever. Each use case for personal car ownership can potentially be replaced with a fleet of service workers from further outside the city, and each permanent parking space can be replaced with one of them double-parking for 30 seconds every few hours.
How do the economics work?
- Labor + car operating costs for some contractors < value of the land the people they serve would otherwise park on.
- Delivery fees and markup on everything you buy < parking, gas, insurance, maintenance, and depreciation (by a couple hundred bucks maybe) < rent premium to live in similar apartment in a walkable area (by $1000+/mo) < psychological cost of the tradeoffs you'd have to make, like roommates, to live in high density on a middle-class income.
Whether that's $2bn, I don't know. But I think selling car-based services to the carfree will be a winning proposition as long as NIMBYs and anti-car activists remain simultaneously empowered.
- flukus 10y agoThat sounds like a small market that's destined to shrink.
- closeparen 10y agoIn the very long run, maybe. I don't see NIMBYs losing steam and I don't see the migration into major metros slowing down either. Maybe when the self-driving car comes?
- prostoalex 10y agoRetailers go where the customers go, though. Two years ago downtown L.A. didn't have a Whole Foods Market, and Instacart-branded packages were commonplace in residential complexes. Low and behold downtown L.A. gets a Whole Foods Market. Someone at Instacart probably has the right numbers, but combined with Costco delivering more of their everyday stuff, anecdotally I see fewer Instacart bags around.
- flukus 10y ago> Retailers go where the customers go, though. If they're allowed and if the customers have enough density to support the retailer.
- jellicle 10y agoSo your argument is that Instacart will profit by delivering long distances to sparse neighborhoods of people who can't afford a car but like marked-up groceries?
- closeparen 10y agoSparse enough for free parking and easy driving < Instacart's addressable market < dense enough to support neighborhood-level grocery stores.
- misingnoglic 10y agoIt's also very useful for college students with no cars, that live in off campus apartments with 3-4 people (can split delivery fees, tip, etc).
- muzz 10y agoVery useful for lots of people-- busy parents, office deliveries, people who would just rather pay 10% and save the time, etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- grandalf 10y ago> People who live in the suburbs without cars. I've ordered lots of Instacart in NYC and Chicago. I used to have it drop off a few things at the office for lunch, and a few to go in the fridge for lunches later in the week. Consider that Instacart will charge 10% to deliver a baguette and some cheese, which can make lunch for several people. This is a way better deal that Seamless. Seamless charges what amounts to a 25% markup to deliver food which has often taken so long on the way to its destination and ends up relatively unappetizing. In NYC the startup Maple has tried to solve the soggy Seamless problem by improving logistics. I haven't tried it, though, so I don't know if they were successful.
- brokenmasonjars 10y ago> People who live in the suburbs without cars. I live in the suburbs with multiple cars. That said I would love if a service (ideally for grocery and restaurant delivery) was in my area. I just don't feel like dealing with rush hour; or the time it takes to grocery shop. I have tried taskrabbit and hiring someone off craigslist. I had better luck with craigslist (for grocery shopping), yet then all sorts of legalities some up that I don't feel like dealing with either.
- grandalf 10y agoDownload the app, Instacart might be there. I know it's in a lot of the Chicago suburbs.
- brokenmasonjars 10y agoeh I've checked all the ones I know of; postmates, amazon, instacart, caviar for restaurants etc etc.
- ftlio 10y agoYou just described my life and why Amazon gets all my grocery and household goods money now.
- mc32 10y agoI think if cities make car transportation a hassle, what will happen is dense locales will see more Aldis, Trader Joes Lidls, etc. (small footprint, high turnover goods at affordable prices) and that will enable more people to walk to their grocer, rather than use shopping and delivery services. These services are basically luxuries. Middle class people with families aren't the ones using these services. Upper class and upper middle, sure. DINKs, sure.
- r00fus 10y ago> These services are basically luxuries. Middle class people with families aren't the ones using these services. I use these services occasionally (2-3x/mo) for a family of five (DI3K). When you're outnumbered and have to play zone-defense against your kids, taking a trip to the grocery store at rush hour is neither fun nor productive (kids are usually hungry by then and late snacking = poor appetite for dinner). I'd love to see the US cityscape turn into something more akin to Europe's (what you described), but I think you have to instead promote mass-transit (to be better) instead of making car transportation a hassle. The flip-side though is that car and petrol industry do lobby to prevent electrified mass transit from being viable.
- CalRobert 10y ago"dense locales " They have to stop making it illegal to build dense locales, though. The grandparent makes a great point. Anecdata, but it mirrors perfectly my experience living in a moderate-density mixed use neighborhood (South Park, San Diego). My wife and I managed without a car for several months largely through techniques they describe.
- coldtea 10y ago>People who live in the suburbs without cars. All 10 of them?
- cmdrfred 10y agoHow do they get to work? If they don't work, with what money do they buy food?
- closeparen 10y agoTo get to work, you might walk 30 minutes to a train station, wait 10 minutes, and ride a packed train for another 30 minutes. Many (grudgingly) find it acceptable to do this 2x/day for commuting, but aren't keen to do it for a quick grocery run. It's easier for public transit to do an okay job with "trunk" routes from the suburbs to downtown at commute time, than to do a passable job with connecting neighborhoods to their nearest grocery stores at all the times people might want to go shopping.
- davewritescode 10y agoI live in a major east coast US city in a neighborhood that has fantastic rail access during peak commute times to downtown but isn't exactly walkable all times of the year. These services are great for people who live in urban ring communities. I use uber to get downtown, prime same day delivery replaces trips out of the city and while I haven't gotten lazy enough to use instacart, I'm probably going to give it a try one of these days.
- uxp100 10y agoThere are inner ring suburbs in the US that have good transit access, short bike trips to jobs, and even dense portions with trendy bars and restaurants, but getting groceries for a family there can still kinda suck. Even if the store is only a mile away, liquids are very heavy. I've have never used instacart though.
- jdhn 10y agoWhat cities are these dense inner ring suburbs near? The only ones I can think of that would have dense inner ring suburbs are NYC, Boston, or Philly.