3 ms·
> That is, I'd conjecture that the good developers who can (or want to) memorize algorithms and regurgitate basic CS knowledge are one kind of capable dev, and
by joshuamorton 10y ago
> That is, I'd conjecture that the good developers who can (or want to) memorize algorithms and regurgitate basic CS knowledge are one kind of capable dev, and the good developers who rely on tools to a greater degree are another kind of dev. Call them types A and B.
I really dislike this characterization. I'm a googler. I've never tried to, or needed to, memorize algorithms. I don't know if this characterization comes from misunderstanding, rationalization, or what, but in my experience at least, neither do most of my coworkers.
That is, I at least don't recall a rote algorithm when interviewing In fact in one of my interviews (not at google, but I could see a similar question happening there) I had to derive a solution to a problem in a space I was totally unfamiliar with (locking and multithreading).
It seems like, if you assume (incorrectly) that somehow you can't cheat the system, Google is selecting for people who can solve unfamiliar, complex, problems by applying first principles. That is, I think, orthogonal to the idea of 'theoretical or practical' computer scientist.
- ivraatiems 10y agoWe have something interesting here, in that I'm looking at this from the perspective of someone the Google system rejected (and who later decided/rationalized/realized participating wasn't really worthwhile) and you're looking at it from the perspective of somebody it embraced. Naturally, it wouldn't boil down so easily in practice to these two types, even if they are the correct ones. Everybody is a mix of both (and plenty of other things); plus, we have to assume that, like you say, occasionally somebody incompetent or strongly type B "cheats" the system and gets hired. But I guess the question is: How, to you, does "selecting for people who can solve unfamiliar, complex, problems by applying first principles" not seem to jive with my definition of category A?
- joshuamorton 10y agoIndeed we do. So, I think my biggest issue with your A/B dichotomy is that I don't see it. That is, in school, in myself, in coworkers, there isn't this large group of people who are trying to do all the theory at the expense of practicality, as opposed to this group of stuff-accomplishers who aren't theoreticians. I mean, occasionally those people exist, both the "fuck it I'm going to sit down and type until it works" people and the "I must understand this concept before I write a single line of code" people. But as you say, everybody is a mix of both, and I think most people are nearer the middle than the sides, which makes the possibility of mild bias towards one side or the other a lot less harmful than you maybe expect.
- ivraatiems 10y agoThe thing is that as an outsider looking in, I see a lot of evidence that Google has this dichotomy and suffers from it. I mentioned some of it in my posts above, but in general, a lot of the company's pain points from my perspective - and from the perspective of employees less satisfied with their experiences[1] - fit what we'd expect from such an enterprise. Here's an example of what I mean: Google is a company with incredible tech and quite a lot of money, but its products tend to fall into clear patterns. First, create something awesome, then fail to support it, then fail to monetize it, and eventually, it fall to the wayside and is discontinued. There are so many apps Google has created that fit this mold that people have done meta-analyses on how long the average Google product lasts.[2] Obviously, not all Google's products fit this mold - but I think Google is unique in being able to support this pattern, fiscally and from a development fatigue standpoint. This pattern is exactly what I would expect to find at a company that is mostly based around theory and concept, and that is either inexperienced at or disinterested in support work after the initial execution. [1] https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-disadvantages-of-working-at-Google https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-disadvantages-of-working-... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/mar/22/google-keep-services-closed https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/mar/22/google-ke... It's probably true that most people, even at Google, are somewhere in the mid-range. However, a large enough group of people with a small bias will result in a shift in the policy of an organization. I still think it's fair to say that, if my dichotomy exists, it would effect Google's institutional behavior even if the degree of difference between people is low on average. That is to say that while you may not see it, it also may not be obviously or even at all visible from the level of one person in one part of the organization, whereas its effects are visible from both within and without. It's kinda like dark matter - you don't know what's happening in someone's head, so you can't observe it directly, but you can predict outcomes based on hypotheses and see what comes true.
- joshuamorton 10y agoInteresting, when I read those answers, what I see is more or less people saying "management can sometimes be downright bad, and is often stupid". I very much doubt that many of the people (broadly) deciding which products to support and which to drop were hired via a new-grad-like interview process. For things like moonshots/other bets, the "build something awesome but don't monetize it" makes a lot of sense, since the entire point of that division seems to be "build something awesome and see if it is sustainable too". More often than not, unfortunately, the answer is no. In fact, if anything, I'd reverse the cause and effect in your idea. If we presuppose that there is this dichotomy in people and it affect google's motives and goals as a company, then this would influence the tech hiring practices to be the way they are, not vice versa.