7 ms·
> Windows users would not switch simply because they didn’t need Linux. Not really. The author identified the real reason before that. Users wouldn't switch be
by shmerl 10y ago
> Windows users would not switch simply because they didn’t need Linux.
Not really. The author identified the real reason before that. Users wouldn't switch because most users don't even think about the choice of OS, which would mean switching. I.e. they only ever use what comes on the computer pre-installed, and that's it. They don't care much what it even is.
Therefore the main blocker wasn't the bad advocacy or anything of the sort, but the old and crooked stranglehold of MS on manufacturers. The only way to seriously increase Linux desktop adoption is for availability of Linux pre-instsalled computers to significantly rise. And MS use their heavy leverage of Windows pricing to prevent that.
> and the desktop itself became irrelevant
I hear this often, but it remains as wrong as ever. Desktop usage has its place, and it's not going anywhere in the foreseeable future.
> They still just want something that plays games and checks the Internet.
And Linux is good for that already. So, as above, that's not what prevents its adoption.
- jimmaswell 10y agoMost popular/AAA titles aren't released for Linux, unless you mean Facebook/other web games.
- shmerl 10y agoTheir number is gradually rising. Higher availability of games needs breaking the catch 22, it's not an instant process (i.e. bigger market means more games). Linux gaming grew in the last 5-6 years tremendously already. And it in turn increased Linux desktop usage. So catch 22 is eroding and things are progressing in the right direction. Recent bigger focus on improving graphics situation (Vulkan and etc.) is helping that as well.
- qplex 10y agoSteam Top 3 (# of players playing right now) Counter-Strike: Global Offensive (518008), Dota 2 (456350), ARK: Survival Evolved (58477) Linux version? 3/3.
- azemetre 10y agoHow many users of those games are actually playing on Linux? Genuinely curious because I doubt it's more than 10%.
- shmerl 10y agoThere aren't many stats on actual Linux usage for cross platform games. The only public data is from Humble Bundles, and it was for indicated usage (i.e. you could select what platform you intend to use the game on while buying). Even if it's 10% - it's a lot of users. There was some article, that availability grows gradually. I.e. if too many games will come out for Linux at once, the market will be too flooded with them, which will in turn hurt both developers, and users.
- qplex 10y agoProbably 1% or less (based on the steam hwsurvey). Considering the share that Linux has on the desktop, this is hardly a surprise.
- shmerl 10y agoSteam survey doesn't show percentage of usage per OS for cross platform games. At least I've never seen such data published. It's tossed around often, but it's not useful really.
- qplex 10y agoThat's true. However, I'd wager that the data would still correlate with the hwsurvey results. Would be interesting to see the actual numbers, especially for CS:GO and Dota 2.
- shmerl 10y agoI don't think it would. I saw some reports from actual developers, that differ quite a lot from that survey. So, I wouldn't use it as any sort of definitive metric.
- ageofwant 10y agoOf my steam library of 324 - yes, mostly Indie games, not AAA, which generally don't interest me - 230 is available on Linux. Now I have to admit I would not buy a Humble Bundle if there were not at least two Linux compatible games in it, but then why would I as I have 3 home machines none of which ran Windows. That changed when I bought a Vive, the same machine has not been switched on since October last year... Oh well another 2k invested in the "future of humanity".
- scholia 10y agoThe Steam survey says that 95.97% of Steam users use Windows, and almost 50% use Windows 10. Only 0.8% use Linux. http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey
- shmerl 10y agoSteam survey is not useful for estimating Linux usage of cross platform games. It's not even clear how accurately it represents all Steam users. But given that majority of Steam games are Windows only, such survey is pointless when you need to know percentage of Linux usage for a given title.
- ageofwant 10y agoHow is this relevant ? I was commenting on the availability of Linux games. There are very many and they generally don't suck. Avoiding Linux because of a lack of games is not a strong argument, if it ever was.
- jcranmer 10y agoAdmittedly, I don't own a lot of AAA titles, but only one of the ones I own doesn't support Linux (Skyrim). Even most of the indie games I own support Linux. Honestly, it feels like games that don't support Linux have been the minority in the past few years.
- icc97 10y agoThe reason people never switched is because Linux (almost) never came installed on desktops. If Windows is installed you use that. If OSX is installed you use that. If Android is installed you use that. Still even now compare the number of options available for buying a PC / laptop with Linux on it to one with Windows on it.
- shmerl 10y ago> The reason people never switched is because Linux (almost) never came installed on desktops. Yes, that's exactly my point. Solving that problem is key to improving Linux adoption.
- icc97 10y agoAh, sorry, my bad, too tired. Misread your post.
- icc97 10y agoAs much as I'm not a fan of some of Dell's dodgy multinational practices, I have respect for them pushing mainstream adoption of pre-installed Ubuntu. I tried to persuade a UK company Novatech that offers computers without an OS to go one step further and offer Linux. They liked the idea, but the support overhead wasn't worth it for them.
- Impossible 10y agoI'd go further and say that most users don't understand the difference between OS, hardware and form factor\case and see a computer as an all in one appliance no different from a smartphone or a console. You can see this when people talk "Mac vs. PC", they'll talk about the features of the hardware and the OS interchangeably (Macs are better because they get less viruses), even though bootcamp has been an officially supported path on Mac hardware for a long time. There is a marketing problem with mainstream users in that most people don't know what Linux is, but I'd guess that many people don't know what Windows is, probably don't know what Android is and don't know what iOS or OSX are, so I'm not sure if understanding what Linux or Ubuntu is actually matters for usage. I completely agree in that sense that Linux would work for average desktop users if OEM's installed it. The only major barriers I can think of are lack of MS Office and potential support overhead. Companies would have to hire a lot more dedicated Linux desktop support staff.
- enos 10y agoA big problem is that the Linux world loves to fragment itself. There is no "Linux" to bundle. You have to pick a distro. On the surface all major distros look like a good choice, but for unclear reasons they're all incompatible with each other despite doing the same things in the same ways. For techies it doesn't matter because they can get any distro to work if one works. But it matters a lot for non-techies because things like tribal knowledge and even packages are all incompatible.
- progman 10y ago> A big problem is that the Linux world loves to fragment itself. I am using Linux for >25 years. The "big" problem actually turned out a big advantage since I was never forced to go with any immature mainstream. For instance, when the KDE 4.0 and Gnome 3.0 disasters came which replaced the excellent KDE 3.x and Gnome 2.x desktops I could switch to another Linux Desktop without any hassle. This would have been impossible with Win 8. Windows users had to endure the pain (someone called it "epic fail") until MS recognized that they made a mistake. Now they have to get used to Win10 which loves to phone home. They have no other option, except switching to OSX or Linux.
- BoorishBears 10y agoToo bad 99.9% of the time Windows gets the UI right enough for most users. From what, Win 95? the first time complaints about the UI became mainstream was Windows 8 ("It looks like it's for touch screens!"), and from 8.1 onward those complaints faded back to being mostly from power users. Through all that I can still run a UI application written for Win 2000 and have it work fine. I'd be fine if I had to deal with one Linux desktop that took a wrong turn for a year or two if it meant that desktop would provide backwards compatibility to the 1990s instead of breaking API compatibility whenever it seems cool.
- progman 10y ago> Too bad 99.9% of the time Windows gets the UI right enough for most users. True for Win7, wrong since >Win7. I would have agreed if you mentioned iOS. Anyway, today Android has the greatest market share, and that's running Linux. > I'd be fine if I had to deal with one Linux desktop that took a wrong turn for a year or two if it meant that desktop would provide backwards compatibility to the 1990s instead of breaking API compatibility whenever it seems cool. Breaking API compatibility has always been a problem in the Windows world (first DOS, then Win16, then Win32, then .NET, now Metro). The Linux/Unix world is much more sustainable. You can likely still use applications which were written twenty years ago.
- scholia 10y ago> Therefore the main blocker wasn't the bad advocacy or anything of the sort, but the old and crooked stranglehold of MS on manufacturers. The only way to seriously increase Linux desktop adoption is for availability of Linux pre-installed computers to significantly rise. Plenty of companies have tried offering Linux pre-installed and almost all of them have failed for various reasons. The main reason is that people don't buy them. Either they are perceived as being too hard to use, or they don't easily run the business software or games that users typically want, or buyers are confused by Linux having 157 variants, or they are happy with Windows, or whatever. The other reason is that manufacturers can make money selling Windows PCs but can't make money selling Linux machines, partly because of the extra costs of hardware qualification, drivers, increased stock control, accounting, book-keeping and advertising costs, and massively increased support costs... unless support is either denied or sold separately as an ongoing cost. Of course, Linux is getting a free ride on the back of Microsoft's compatibility work. If you are using Linux then you are benefiting hugely from the cost of parts being driven down by Windows PC sales. (Apple switched to Intel partly to gain the same benefits.) > MS use their heavy leverage of Windows pricing to prevent that. One of the settlement terms in the anti-trust case was that Microsoft was not allowed to do deals on Windows pricing, so that all the leading OEMs were on a level playing field. This settlement ran for roughly a decade. Did you see a huge rise in Linux PC shipments? No. The only real difference was that it pushed up the average price of Windows and made Microsoft more profitable.
- shmerl 10y agoAnti-trust case revealed, that MS threatened manufacturers to raise Windows price, if they'd sell computers without an OS. That's another indicator of such blackmail. I don't think the court did anything about that. If all would have been clean deals wise, there wouldn't have been such a mess of Windows tax and never ending tying problem.
- scholia 10y agoYes, it did. The DoJ fixed the price of Windows for all the major OEMs, and all sales had to be made via the same OEM-only website. I don't appear to have a record of how many OEMs that applied to (or else I can't find it), but the number I remember is 40. This had the very amusing effect of increasing the price that IBM paid for Windows. IBM went to court to complain that Microsoft had tripled its price, but as far as I recall, that price increase was from $9 to $27. Either way, nothing stops anybody from setting up a company to sell Linux PCs -- you could do it yourself. Is there really nobody in America who can sell Linux PCs at a profit, when the OS is free? Since that's evidently the case, blaming Microsoft just looks like a fig-leaf for some more fundamental failure(s).
- wazanator 10y agoThe problem you run into when it does come preinstalled is users are not familiar with it and don't know how to use it. Take this example[0] from years ago when Dell had Ubuntu installed on some laptops. This is an example of an average user. For lack of a better words dumb as dirt. If it doesn't work right away and they can't solve it in under 5 minutes they get mad. The article also brings up a relevant often over looked point, you need certain software that only runs on Windows or macOS. Libre Office will export to a Word format but the default is set to odt, expecting average users to know how to change format is pushing it. I've gotten in the habit of just exporting all my documents as PDF's because there's no question that the receiver will be able to read it but that isn't something that goes through the minds of most people I imagine. [0]http://www.wkow.com/Global/story.asp?S=9667184&nav=menu1362_8_6 http://www.wkow.com/Global/story.asp?S=9667184&nav=menu1362_...
- shmerl 10y ago“Years ago” is not an indicator of things today. I've installed Linux for multiple non tecnical people, and they fared fine.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smitherfield 10y agoVery well said. When I see people in here say they installed Linux on their parent's computer, I have to hope Mom and Pop are old Unix hackers, or their kid has a lot of free time. We don't realize just how much non-technical people struggle to do the most basic tasks on their computer. They struggle mightily to so much as connect to a new wireless network or download and run a graphical installer on Windows or Mac. Adding a printer, changing settings or connecting to a Bluetooth device are probably beyond their abilities. My parents are both extremely intelligent, and early adopters of technology who've had PCs since the 80's; every time I see them they've filled their Macs with adware ("No, it's good; it does a cleanup! It's from Amazon!"). To send them an email is to risk it being lost in the flood of hundreds of newsletters they inadvertently subscribed to. I know fellow developers with Macs who run all their apps off of the still-mounted disk image instead of dragging them to the Applications folder. You expect non-technical people to use a package manager? To find the non-free repository, or have the slightest clue what "package manager" or "non-free repository" even means? To hack on the command line? To edit configuration files? I often need to run to the docs and StackExchange for those kind of things, and I'm the guy my (intelligent, competent) team members come to about that stuff. You expect them to find and install drivers? To deal with stuff breaking when they update their distro? To update in the first place? Like the woman in the story, they're likely to give up when they see MS Office isn't available. People in my graduate CS courses claim they can't open .docx files because they don't have MS Word. It's a more-competent-than-average person who even knows about and recognizes file extensions. Think about how painful it is to get your coworkers to so much as try out a new language, library or development tool. How much hand-holding they need. How they whine and complain about the slightest difference, even when the new way is clearly superior. And this is talking about highly-intelligent people above the 99th percentile for knowledge and interest in computers. So yeah, I don't think Linux is really in a state where it's usable (without handholding) by non-developers without lots of time, ability and interest to learn Unix. Even Windows and MacOS are something of a losing struggle. People do better with the more idiot-proof iOS and Android, but I'm still troubleshooting my folks' phones on a regular basis.
- bubblethink 10y ago>The only way to seriously increase Linux desktop adoption is for availability of Linux pre-instsalled computers to significantly rise I don't know if there's a term for this, but ironically, that's like a self-destructive goal. Most people who use Linux currently would wipe the hard drive as the first thing if they bought a laptop that came preinstalled with an OS. So if everyone became an enlightened linux user, everyone would start wiping their drives right after buying the machine, invalidating the need for preloading in the first place.
- type0 10y agoNo it's not. Let's say I buy a Dell with Ubuntu on it, that alone is a good indication that many other distros would run just fine. If I buy a laptop with Windows there are absolutely no guarantees for being able to run Linux without issues.
- shmerl 10y agoSome users. Most users aren't going to install any OS on their own, no matter what OS. They are the majority. And to gain adoption among them, Linux should be preinstalled.