6 ms·
They are illegal because the system is so broken. There's a market demand for those people, and they're moving here to work, by and large. Just because someth
by davidw 10y ago
They are illegal because the system is so broken. There's a market demand for those people, and they're moving here to work, by and large.
Just because something is set in law does not make it morally right.
- freehunter 10y ago>They are illegal because the system is so broken. They're illegal because what they are doing is against the law. Broken system or not, it's still illegal. >Just because something is set in law does not make it morally right. No, but it does make it the law, and breaking it is still illegal. Morals are grey, while law is much more often black and white.
- jimnotgym 10y ago>while law is much more often black and white. Really? Why does so much time get wasted in litigation if law is black and white? In the case of an immigration law, was the law made in accordance with the constitution? What about the Geneva convention? Should you obey a law that is unconstitutional? What if it was brought in without due process. Doesn't sound black and white to me. [Add your own black vs white joke about white law enforcement and black immigrants here]
- freehunter 10y agoNext time before you comment, you should look up what "much more often" means.
- davidw 10y agoRosa Parks broke the law too. No, it's not quite the same, but my point is that this is absolutely a case where the law is not working well, is not 'right' and ought to be fixed. There are a lot of similarities with MJ legalization: by legalizing, regulating and taxing, states like mine (Oregon) have hurt criminal enterprises and taken in millions of dollars in revenue, and brought a lot of businesses out of the shadows. It's a win all around.
- DashRattlesnake 10y ago> They are illegal because the system is so broken. There's a market demand for those people, and they're moving here to work, by and large. > Just because something is set in law does not make it morally right. ...and neither does "the market."
- davidw 10y agoNo, but if you have a huge market demand for something, and make it illegal... that demand will still get filled, but cause all kinds of other problems: Exhibit A: the "war on drugs".
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoThe fix here is to reduce demand. By fining companies which hire illegal immigrants we'll make it cheaper to hire american.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoMaybe, but that market demand exists because they are outside the law. Keeping illegal immigrants here allows a permanent underclass which can be abused by companies in ways that American citizens can't. It allows a race to the bottom where only companies which hire illegal immigrants can lower the cost of their product to a competitive level. The only way to end this cycle is to stop allowing illegal immigrants to work here.
- splawn 10y agoWhat industries does this occur in?
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoConstruction, food processing, restaurants and more. If any real progress is made on illegal immigration, I bet you'll see wages in these areas go up.
- splawn 10y agoperhaps... I wonder what impact automation will have as well though. I bet it will dwarf the impact that illegal immigration could ever have.
- leesalminen 10y agoSo, in a way our President is actually standing up to the corporations and fighting for human rights?
- davidw 10y agoProbably not. Here's one way it could easily play out: There's still demand for those people, and so they'll keep coming (and especially if by various means we contribute to wrecking the Mexican economy!), but they'll be pushed further towards the margins of society, and will be easier to exploit. Look at this, for instance: http://www.elpasotimes.com/story/news/2017/02/15/ice-detains-domestic-violence-victim-court/97965624/ http://www.elpasotimes.com/story/news/2017/02/15/ice-detains... - woman takes domestic violence to the courts, but gets detained herself. What will the next woman to be beaten or raped do? Probably not go to the cops. edit also: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/02/mexico-immigrant-workers-jobs-americans-braceros-history-immigration-214784 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/02/mexico-immigr...