7 ms·
We've all pretty much given up on the idea that social media will 'democratize' the media. That slippery slope was passed long ago. I was just reading a book b
by dmix 10y ago
We've all pretty much given up on the idea that social media will 'democratize' the media. That slippery slope was passed long ago.
I was just reading a book by William F Buckley from 1959 about early American conservatism. Many of the points sound straight out of modern day partisan media:
- Liberal Bias in newspapers and universities: Buckley specifically cites NYTimes, NYPost, WaPo, and other prominent papers at the time all exhibit a noticeable liberal leaning. He also included a number of examples in higher education, especially at elite universities.
- Liberal Mania: Buckley noted that the hardcore liberals have a habit of grouping up on anyone who dares to become a prominent public proponent for Conservatism. They try to get them fired or formally reprimanded by authorities (such as by congress leaders). He also notes a level of smug/elitism. A view point that the left believe they have discovered the correct ideology and anything else is heresies.
- Opponents = Hitler: This was the left's favouritve label for right leaning opponents. He shared a story about how Eleanor Roosevelt famously labeled McCarthy-ism as Hitler-ism. When challenged by a reporter on this label she was asked if she would make the same comparison for this Soviet diplomat she had a known positive relationship with. But she refused - despite the fact he played a leading role in Stalin's purges. It was something reserved for the right.
This was written 58 years ago.
Whether these generalizations are true or not, it's funny how history repeats itself.
- Tloewald 10y agoWilliam F. Buckley's idea of what constitutes liberal leaning is hardly any kind of gold standard. Bear in mind that no real left wing policies or media platforms exist in the US, it's right vs. far right. The Economist is considered a left-wing organ here.
- judah 10y ago>> "Bear in mind that no real left wing policies or media platforms exist in the US" Newspapers in the US are overwhelmingly and verifiably leftist[0]. Out of the 46 major newspapers in the US, 41 of them endorsed Hillary Clinton for President, several endorsed Gary Johnson, and only 1 endorsed Donald Trump. [1] [0]: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/clinton-leads-trump-and-obama-and-reagan-in-the-newspaper-endorsement-race/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/clinton-leads-trump-and... [1]: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/09/clinton-trump-newspaper-endorsements http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/09/clinton-trump-ne...
- dmix 10y agoClearly, he meant no true scotsman leftist policies or platforms exists :p Even then I'm not sure that argument could be made.
- Tloewald 10y agoMother Jones is nowhere near is leftist as Fox News is rightist.
- dmix 10y agoWho is comparing Mother Jones to Fox News? At most you should be comparing MSNBC, CNN, NBC, ABC vs Fox News, or Mother Jones/The Nation vs National Review. > the Democratic Party received a total donation of $1,020,816, given by 1,160 employees of the three major broadcast television networks (NBC, CBS, ABC), while the Republican Party received only $142,863 via 193 donations https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Media_bias_in_the_United_States https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Media_bias_in_the_United_States
- Tloewald 10y ago"Leftist" by American standards in 2017 is, again, not leftist by world standards or even US standards in 1970-1990, except on a few social issues (e.g. Gay rights) or things that aren't even political in other countries (basic science). Bear in mind that Nixon tried to pass Obamacare and set up the EPA. Teddy Roosevelt set up the national park system.
- judah 10y ago>> "Leftist" by American standards in 2017 is, again, not leftist by world standards" Yes, if your standard for leftism is Joseph Stalin's Soviet Russia. But that's like saying, "The right by American standards isn't actually on the right according to world standards, where the right wing == Benito Mussolini's Fascist Italy."
- dragonwriter 10y agoWilliam F. Buckley was pretty much the father of the modern American Right, and they've largely been following his propaganda script since. So, no, the fact that his attacks on the left mirror what's seen today isn't an example of "history repeats itself", it's an example of a movement that's been using the same propaganda nonstop the whole time between then and now.
- m52go 10y agoI'm not familiar with Buckley's work but what aspects of the parent response are incorrect? It seems spot-on to me.
- and0 10y agoAnd of all the examples of "history repeats itself" to use right now why would you go with "liberals are mean!" and not the whole rising fascism thing that, yes, is actually happening again.
- judah 10y agoIt's not, "Liberals are mean." It's, "Leftists often dismiss diversity of thought with personal slurs." To the left, virtually every opponent is a sexist, islamophobic, xenophobic, homophobic, intolerant, racist bigot. This tactic, along with identity politics, are prime reasons why so many people voted for the current President of the United States.
- heurist 10y ago
- tn13 10y agoThis pretty much sums up while a silent majority kicked left's butts this election. Peter Thiel supported Trump and these people wanted Zuck to fire him. That is absolutely ridiculous. Now, it is a democratic/free speech right to make a demand public but then there will be consequences. The consequence here was the mass consolidation of votes against the left. Even Sam Altman's recent piece suggests that people overwhelmingly voted "against left" rather than "for trump". I know bunch of Profs who got fired or cornered for nothing other then their support of one opinion v/s the popular leftist opinion.
- wfo 10y agoYou need an actual majority in order for there to be a silent majority. The correct phrase would be "vocal minority, concentrated in a few specific geographic areas engineered to have more power over the electoral process" which is nearly the opposite of a silent majority.
- tn13 10y agoIn American presidential elections the only majority that matters if of electoral college. The majority of heads does not matter, majority of head adjusted for privilege points does not matter, votes of global citizens do no matter. In that sense my use of the word "majority" is perfectly correct.
- wfo 10y agoWhy are you talking about privilege points? Who said anything about that? Why are you introducing things like privilege into this conversation? Perhaps you want to dodge the rest of the argument because you know you aren't correct and talk about your feelings about privilege instead, because feelings can't be wrong? I've seen the tactic before and nobody really falls for it outside of /r/the_donald. Certainly not on HN. You don't have a majority of American citizens. You don't have a majority of people living in America. You don't have a majority of American voters. You don't have a majority of people who voted in the 2016 presidential election. You have a majority of electors in the electoral college, but they are the opposite of silent. Their votes are published online for the world to see. They make public protest votes. Their lack of silence is how we know who won the election. 'Silent majority' could not be more wrong as a description of what is going on here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]