4 ms·
We need to understand that the real enemies here are the owners But of course, the New York Times can't actually call out who the real enemy is. I own two sha
by mindcrime 10y ago
We need to understand that the real enemies here are the owners
But of course, the New York Times can't actually call out who the real enemy is.
I own two shares of GM stock, so I am one of the enemy?
And that's a key element that these kind of analyses almost always ignore: there is no bright line distinction between "the capitalists" and "the non capitalists." Everybody is eligible to own a share of any publicly traded company, and a large segment of the population do choose to participate as part owners of various enterprises.
We're all capitalists.
One big thing we're missing though, is education and awareness for large chunks of the population. With things like fractional shares (ala Sharebuilder), almost everybody who has any income at all, can start building an ownership stake in the various capitalist enterprises out there, and reap the dividends (in either the literal sense of a dividend paid our, or capital gains, whatever). But how many people don't understand how this works, or aren't aware of what their options are? Or how many are but just choose to spend their entire paycheck every week instead of investing in anything?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAren't there classes of stock? Essentially what a joe shmoe can (afford to) buy isn't going to benefit him much at all. The $100M CEO and his cronies are skimming all the fat. No sensible company profits much at all - because you'd have to share that with stockholders. Just my cynical view
- LesZedCB 10y ago> I own two shares of GM stock, so I am one of the enemy? If the amount of ownership gives you a controlling vote, yes. You should give up that level of ownership unless you work there. Control of the company should be directed solely by the workers affected by the decisions made (and possibly a government allowing greater long term control, such as reducing non-renewable energy consumption). One worker, one vote. http://www.democracyatwork.info/ http://www.democracyatwork.info/ is a good resource for more info on how I think enterprises should organize themselves.
- ue_ 10y agoAre you proposing a Socialist system of the workers taking control of the means of production, or merely the idea that companies (i.e entities that exist to provide profit for a bourgeois owner) ought to be democratically controlled?
- LesZedCB 10y agowhat exactly is the difference? If all industries become worker owned, is that not worker control of the means of production? Personally, I don't think worker coops will become widespread under capitalism to be a real threat to big capital. However, I think Richard Wolff's idea that they are practice for worker bottom up democracy which can be implemented under capitalism is correct. edit: i read your comment as "democratically owned" instead of "democratically controlled." In that case, I advocate the former, a socialist seizure of the means of production.
- ue_ 10y ago>I own two shares of GM stock, so I am one of the enemy? I'm by far not well enough versed in Marxist theory, though you're probably not. The bourgeoisie is defined by roughly the following characteristics: ownership of the means of production (i.e capital) and the extraction of surplus from the proletariat. The ownership of stocks is according to Marx 'fictitious capital', it does not count as capital which the bourgeois would be defined by, and as such, unless you are also the owner of machinery or materials used in conjunction with the machinery (including labour-time) then you are not a capitalist. A rough guide is as follows: do you directly profit from extraction of surplus value? If so, you are probably a capitalist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fictitious_capital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fictitious_capital
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 10y agoIt's true that "capitalist" and "worker" are real-valued rather than binary descriptors (the traditional "middle class", the petit bourgeoisie, is, in a sense, just a description of the group of people for whom those descriptors are in very-loose balance rather than one or the other totally dominating), but that doesn't mean there isn't a useful and meaningful distinction between those whose predominant means of support is as owners of capital surviving on capital rents and those whose predominant means of support is selling labor, and that those groups don't have radically different and often opposed economic interests in policy options.
- astrange 10y ago> With things like fractional shares (ala Sharebuilder), almost everybody who has any income at all Sharebuilder's fee is $4 per trade, and Motif is $5. They're the only people winning in the fractional share game, unless what you're buying is so expensive you want $1000 of it and still care about the fraction.