5 ms·
> The economy can’t flourish without trade and immigrants. How is it that China flourishes with limited immigration and restricted trade?
by leereeves 10y ago
> The economy can’t flourish without trade and immigrants.
How is it that China flourishes with limited immigration and restricted trade?
- krapht 10y agoDefine flourishes. Being poor in China is 10x worse than being poor in the West.
- muninn_ 10y agoSure. And like 50 years ago Mao wrecked the entire country.
- Mikeb85 10y agoChina has the world's second largest economy and is growing at an astronomical rate. Keep in mind where they were at only one generation ago...
- oblio 10y agoI'm not sure that there's actual scientific evidence for this, but my overall observation regarding growth is: unless you're some sort of tax-haven, growth once you've reached middle-income economy status is much harder. China can't possibly become a tax haven: too many mouths to feed. And their per capita GDP is smaller than Romania's. When was the last time you heard someone praising Romania's standard of living over the US's? I mean, from many points of view I wish they'd keep up this growth because they'd take us to Mars within 30 years if they did, but I can't possibly imagine how they'd keep up rates of growth of 7%+ once the vast majority of their population has already been taken out of subsistence farming.
- wklauss 10y ago> China has the world's second largest economy and is growing at an astronomical rate. Far from astronomical. 6/7%. It's very good compared to developed countries but the key for percentages is always understanding what is the original value you are growing from. China was a huge country both in size and population that began a transformation into a modern economy. They'll, sooner or later, become the largest economy in the world. But these growth ratios won't be sustainable. They'll stabilize around 2/3% once they fully develop their economic potential.
- adrianN 10y agoIn China more people are leaving poverty every year than anywhere else in the world.
- yesbut 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_capitalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_capitalism
- _moin_ 10y ago> China flourishes Yea, lets be more like China, the leader in "quality of life" metric. /s
- patcheudor 10y agoFor China, replace immigration with movement of people from rural to urban. It's a big country and they've been undergoing dramatic population shifts. We don't have that luxury in the west. Also define flourishing economy. They are hurting pretty badly as well. http://www.marketwatch.com/story/chinas-economic-problems-will-come-to-a-head-in-2017-2016-11-23 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/chinas-economic-problems-wi...
- wklauss 10y ago>How is it that China flourishes without immigrants and with restricted trade? China has a lot of immigrants. Mostly from rural areas to urban areas. They are Chinese, sure, but because the different laws governing rural areas vs. cities they might as well be from another country. These cities (Shenzen, Hong Kong, Shanghai...) work with special trade regulations that are comparable to any other free-market countries around the world.
- marknutter 10y agoThat's... some incredible doublespeak there.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoBecause it has a massive population surplus of people who have not entered the industrialized urban centers where modern economies need talent and where the non-barely above poverty jobs are for the Chinese. For countries without surplus rural workers making barely above poverty, immigration is required, especially when we need skillsets that aren't growing domestically as fast as we need to fill open positions. China has 380m people making about $4-$10 a day in rural areas dying to migrate to better living conditions. That's more workers in rural areas than the US has people in total: men, women, children, students, retired, etc. These situations aren't comparable. http://www.realclearworld.com/articles/2016/09/16/china_is_still_really_poor_112050.html http://www.realclearworld.com/articles/2016/09/16/china_is_s... As of 2014, over half of China’s roughly 770 million employed workers were urban workers. The problem is that the other half – almost 380 million people – are employed in rural areas. The urban households aren’t exactly raking it in, but the rural households have not progressed far enough beyond the World Bank’s arbitrary $3.10 to say they have escaped much of anything, and certainly not poverty.
- candiodari 10y agoI don't know if you've visited a place like Hong Kong, but the short answer is this : Those cities are full of immigrants, taking up the badly paid shit jobs. They're all Chinese immigrating into China so "it's not immigration", but only in the same way Polish workers in the UK are "not immigrants" (not meant pejoratively, and frankly I admire what those people in the UK do, they deserve to be treated better than the British treat them. On the other hand, I do understand why the British labour class doesn't like them : they depress wages, conditions, and opportunity). China is a country of 1 billion people. A slight minority, let's say 400 million people, live in the countryside (ie. everywhere except for some 30 dots on the map). Not in abject poverty (certainly not compared to 20 years ago), but certainly making a LOT less money than they do in cities and living in nicer natural environments, but worse conditions. So they migrate to the cities, take total shit jobs, and slowly become part of the Chinese cities. This process has started, but is far from finishing (although I do think it's more than halfway through, but it's got another decade or so before it fizzles out) So TLDR: China is not doing this without immigration at all. It's just that it doesn't really look like immigration for the same reason that the pretty sizable migration out of Chicago doesn't really look like immigration.
- pizzetta 10y agoThat describes internal migration rather than immigration (international migration). In the end the results may be similar, but it's a different thing. You can't be deported out of China (though you can be sent back to your village) but they are generally speaking the same culture and people, for the majority of cases. Every large country which has transformed from agrarian to industrial has gone through this internal migration phase. From former USSR down to Bolivia or Mali.
- theossuary 10y agoYes, they are different, but from an economic perspective they're very similar, which is what the OP was talking about.
- gumby 10y agoChina has a huge unemployment problem and heavily restricts internal migration. The hukou /internal passport system sends unauthorized immigrants from the countryside into an "illegal alien" system. Without the right passes, your kids don't get into school, you can't rent a home etc. If you look at country-sized subregions of China (e.g. Shanghai region, guanghzou) the economics and dynamics parallel those of the USA. And china is a WTO member; if you look at it honestly, its trade is not more restricted than the US. Yes, it does try to make its own special standards, but they are similar to what the US does (e.g. with automative regulations or electronics regulations) -- it's simply that the US is a far more valuable market so people are more willing to jump through the necessary hoops). Yes the US is even more open, but part of that is via agreements (like the now dead TPP) that were specifically intended to give preference to countries that were not China. As for "flourishing"...let's just say that most of the poorest quintile in the US are wealthier and healthier than most of the richest quintile in China. Any absolute growth from a small number is a relatively large percentage. Note: I am very much opposed to Chinese policies in many areas including the ones described above. But I can form that opinion without cliches like you hear from politicians).
- Bartweiss 10y agoThis is a great summary - China has quite a bit of immigration (in an odd, internal sense) and engages in massive amounts of trade regardless of the tariff and dumping questions people bring up. On the flourishing point, I'd just add that China is struggling with flourishing not just on an individual wealth level but on a structural macroeconomic level. The move from state-sponsored heavy industries to consumer goods is still in huge jeopardy, and while its growing rapidly China is working hard to circumvent economic crisis.
- danm07 10y agoGrowth is not a function of immigration, but of population size. Immigration itself is just a means to get more people. It also increases diversity, which is like bringing in new people in into a company, which is always stirs things up... in a good way, most of the time.
- niftich 10y agoThey have a large domestic population of people willing (~needing) to perform work despite scant worker protections, forming continuous domestic rural-to-urban migration; they have plentiful extractable raw materials and aren't particularly concerned about the environment; they are able and willing to take on government debt partly because internationally their combined their military and economic might doesn't make it very likely that anyone will bother to collect. The problem is as China's acquiring a "middle-class" that begins to resemble its American counterpart in the 1950s, the pool of people in China who will do just about any job is decreasing. Middle-class people use their increased economic security to develop a sense of vested agency and are less likely to voluntarily let their living and working standards dip. Therefore, the most exploitative production is moving out of the Chinese mainstream and into the rural fringes of its own society, or elsewhere altogether.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mc32 10y agoOr Japan. Despite low birth rates low immigration and a less open economy, rigid educational system, rigid new graduate hiring system, it's still the no. 3 economy in the world.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoThis is because it's functionally a part of the American empire with all the economic benefits that brings. It never would have rose to prominence nor will it maintain this position without US backing of its economy/security. This is why Abe has been so desperately scrambling to buddy up with Trump. It may have an alternate future underneath the umbrella of a Chinese empire, but would likely being strangled by the compounded corruption.
- gthtjtkt 10y agoYeah, that sentence stood out to me too. Kind of like starting a philosophical debate with the statement "Obviously God exists, so I will now proceed with the other parts of my argument". Definitely not as axiomatic as the author assumes. And even if our current economy truly can't flourish without immigrants and trade, there's still a viable argument to be made that building an economy on immigrants and trade was a bad idea and we should try to undo some of that.
- mynameishere 10y agoThe New York Times wants mass immigration into the Western world and if the subject is culture, they say, "You need immigration for great culture." If the subject is cuisine, they say, "You need immigration for great cuisine." Everything from economics, art, science, "Freedom [TM]", "The American Dream [TM]", down to clean toilets, harvested vegetables, blown leaves, etc, etc, etc, all have one necessary ingredient according to the elites: Mass immigration. You will find this to be 100 percent consistent across the media. The rational person recognizes that, in fact, NONE of these things depend upon mass immigration. The elites aren't daft, and so they clearly want it for a separate, undisclosed, reason.
- selimthegrim 10y agoWhy is any immmigration at all always mass immigration to you guys?
- acchow 10y agoChina is a developing country. Policies that work well for them generally won't translate to a fully-developed economy. Primarily, their growth (in terms of the Cobb-Douglass equation) comes from increasing technology (the "A" in the equation) by adopting already-created technologies. If you're at the frontiers of technology, you can't just implement pre-existing technology. You need policies that will help you invent new ones.