3 ms·
How dare they make a business decision to have standards for accuracy on their platform. The nerve of giant corporations in our corporatist world! The nerve!
by maxerickson 10y ago
How dare they make a business decision to have standards for accuracy on their platform.
The nerve of giant corporations in our corporatist world!
The nerve!
- skylan_q 10y agoHe's right, though. Google itself cannot be trusted. The size of the organization itself along with how many state actors it's colluding with should set off alarms.
- leereeves 10y agoCensorship is often hidden behind innocuous phrases like "standards for accuracy". It was fairly obvious when the media started talking about "fake news online" that the endgame was censoring the Internet.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, totally obvious. Robust freedom of speech doesn't mean that idiots get to have an equal voice. In fact, I think it depends on idiots quickly getting ignored, even in vile, pernicious, institutionalized ways.
- leereeves 10y agoSo you're arguing in favor of censorship? Who decides who gets ignored in "vile, pernicious, institutionalized ways"?
- maxerickson 10y agoLet me know when it becomes illegal to start up a news aggregator. Until then, it's whoever makes better news aggregators.
- leereeves 10y ago'Better' meaning? Popular? Then you're deciding truth by popularity.
- maxerickson 10y agoAnd? The alternative is to ban sorting news articles at all.
- leereeves 10y agoAnd you'll end up with a liberal echo chamber and a conservative echo chamber, and never the two sides shall read the same story.
- maxerickson 10y agoMaybe. In the US I think the more partisan media operations are pandering at least as much as they are influencing (I guess probably quite a bit more). The opinion bubble exists whether they sell ad space on it or not, they have some effect of making it bigger. There's also the fun problem where the sorting and other display choices of a news aggregator are speech. Why should that speech be suppressed?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- espadrine 10y agoMoving the debate to evaluating accuracy is better than what we were headed towards. The conclusion stops being a race-to-the-bottom "can we even know anything?" and becomes "how can we perfect our knowledge?"
- soft_dev_person 10y agoHow will a system like this handle unpredictable developments reported by new or few sources? And how will a system like this handle news or reports about events that challenge our world view? Not everything takes the form of Trump saying random outrageous stuff that is easily verified/rejected. Also, you may say that "Fact checked" is just an additional data point to judge whether to trust an information source, but you know as well as I do that lazy people (most people) will start thinking that "Fact checked" means truth and "Not fact checked" means lies. Even more so on Facebook. I think, in the long run, these systems will be detrimental to peoples' ability to judge any information themselves. This is a problem for democracy.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's not like we are starting in a place where people do a reasonable job of judging information. I remember sitting in a library years ago as two goofballs met each other for the first time and immediately extended each other more credibility than they gave to the institutions they proceeded to ramble about. It was fascinating to watch.
- soft_dev_person 10y agoThen they are not fixing the right problem.
- icebraining 10y agoThe articles aren't being marked as Fact Checked, they are being only tagged as being Fact Checking articles.
- soft_dev_person 10y agoThat's interesting. Not sure it will be interpreted that way by most people, considering how many are interpreting the announcement itself. Even after reading it again and the one announcing the "fact-check" tag, it was still not obvious what they meant until I read your comments in here. Anyway, the part regarding Facebook still stands, and we are moving in that general direction I believe.
- ksk 10y agoI found the word accuracy applied to an advertising company quite ironic.