3 ms·
I keep wondering why, the day it happened, they didn't hire a crack team of scuba divers to go down there with a hunk of steel and oxy-acetalyne torches to weld
by sliverstorm 17y ago
I keep wondering why, the day it happened, they didn't hire a crack team of scuba divers to go down there with a hunk of steel and oxy-acetalyne torches to weld it shut. I don't think oil would burn underwater, even in the presence of the torches, though whether you could pull off a weld is an open question.
- starkfist 17y agoThe leak is too deep for divers.
- _delirium 17y agoHolding something in place over the opening long enough to attach it is a significant problem, since the oil's coming out at thousands of psi. I don't think a diver would be able to do it without significant machinery, even if it were somewhere shallower where divers can work. Edit: Which actually is why blowout preventers were invented in the 1920s, even for land-based wells. Before that, oil would gush out of the opening when a high-pressure reservoir was struck, and it was really hard to shove a cap onto a well once it was spewing out at high pressure. This one in 1910 took 18 months to cap: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lakeview_Gusher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lakeview_Gusher
- sliverstorm 17y agoInteresting. I guess I need to learn more about oil mining tech. I was under the impression that after the initial strike, most of the pressure is released- hence the pumps we use to extract it.
- jacquesm 17y agoThink about this for a moment: The area you are talking about is very deep under water, a column of 1600 meters, then there is a very large layer of rock. All that stuff weighs down on the saturated rock/oil underneath, and then you poke a hole in that hard top layer of rock. The pressures we're talking about are immense, so high that methane in spite of the temperature is a solid. Containing the pressure is the problem. The only places where pumps are needed to get oil out of the ground are shallow wells, especially in a newly drilled well the pressure will almost always be 'on'. The deeper we drill, the higher that initial pressure will be. Over time, as the well is depleted the pressure can go down, and depending on the substrate the oil is in (usually some kind of porous rock, it's not quite drilling in to a lake of oil down there) this will happen faster or slower. Once a well is 'depleted' the rule is really that there is still plenty of oil down there but it can't be moved to the surface economically. There is plenty of research in this area (such as controlled burns to use the gas pressure from the burn to push the oil to a collecting well), but simply pumping it out is usually not the way things go. My personal big fear about this particular 'gusher' is that the longer it lasts the more the oil under pressure has to erode the wellhead, if it gets to the point where it starts widening the well head (like say the tip of a plasma cutter that is used a bit too long) that the cavity will get larger than what can be plugged up.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoThe leak is at about 5,000 feet. The deepest a human can go is about 2000.
- sliverstorm 17y agoAh, I wasn't aware it was so deep.
- jacquesm 17y agoAre you joking or what ? A crack team of scuba divers at 5000 feet below ? http://www.scubarecords.com/ http://www.scubarecords.com/ Really, it surprises me that just knowing the basic facts of the case you would make this suggestion. 5000 feet below sea level has conditions that make working there in a suit comparable to (or worse than) setting up a deep space mission. We're talking about a column of a mile or about 1600 meters of standing water here. A scuba diver would be crushed like a pop can at that depth. Sending people that deep without protection around them to withstand pressures that are beyond our everyday imagination would be the same as killing them on the spot. There has never been a human that deep, unless in a device called a 'Bathyscaphe', and even that is quite an undertaking, and definitely not without risk. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathyscaphe_Trieste http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathyscaphe_Trieste 'regular' submarines will go to about 4500' and are pretty much useless in this case. Too many hollywood movies.
- sliverstorm 17y agoI wasn't aware it was so deep. To describe a little bit better my sentiment- they are an oil giant with tons of cash facing a crisis. I'd have expected a faster reaction. I'm aware it's not an easy task, but they hardly lack resources. I was chalking the slow movement up to bureaucracy.
- starkfist 17y agoThere is a crack team of scientists on the project now who have no idea what to do. BP is fucked, and they know it. It doesn't matter how fast they didn't respond because nobody inside of BP or otherwise knows how to fix the problem.
- jacquesm 17y agoLet me put it this way: if you have any BP stock I suggest you sell it, and if you plan on eating fish in the next 10 years start your prayer wheels and hope that someone comes up with something really smart that hasn't been tried and discarded yet. If you live in the south-east of the United States and you have survived hurricane Katerina then I really sympathize because nobody should have to live through one, let alone two disasters of this magnitude in a single lifetime. Out of control doesn't begin to describe the problems they are having there. They can hardly plug the hole with cash, that's not the problem. The problem is a viable solution. When someone suggests exploding a nuke to see if that will cure it and he's not immediately sent off to the funny farm you know there is a real problem. Especially when you think of what could happen if that option were to fail.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- percept 17y agoWhat happened to "There are no stupid questions"? Why beat up on someone who asks a (seemingly) legitimate question?
- jacquesm 17y agoAgreed in principle, but I see no question marks in that post.