4 ms·
Knowing what we know now, I'd say the sexism angle holds up. Pao was treated viciously during a short tenure during which she didn't do very much. She was blame
by snowwrestler 10y ago
Knowing what we know now, I'd say the sexism angle holds up. Pao was treated viciously during a short tenure during which she didn't do very much. She was blamed for problems that predated her, like mod support and relations, which had been going sour for years. She was blamed for things she didn't do, like firing Victoria (done by Ohanian). She was blamed for relatively mild and obvious moves to prevent abusive content on the site.
Steve Huffman was greeted as a savior when he replaced Pao. But he has been far more aggressive in curbing nasty content, and done nasty things himself, like secretly editing other users's posts directly in the database. And yet, he is still CEO. And people don't post nasty and abusive things all day about his looks, his sex life, etc.
The Ellen Pao tenure was not the Reddit community's finest hour.
- jordanb 10y agoPao already had a pretty explosive reputation before she took the helm. That reputation certainly stems partially from her being a woman but specifically she was an extremely high profile litigant. Imagine if some other Valley insider with an explosive reputation had been put in charge of reddit at that time and made similar moves. For instance, imagine if they had brought in Kevin Rose. I expect that you'd see a similar pattern of reactions from the community. I've also always had a bit of trouble reconciling the Pao controversy being about sexism with her most controversial move: firing a well-liked female staff member.
- MegaButts 10y ago> I've also always had a bit of trouble reconciling the Pao controversy being about sexism with her most controversial move: firing a well-liked female staff member. OP mentioned that it was not Ellen Pao who fired her, but Alexis Ohanian. This has since been confirmed by Ohanian, so it seems pretty believable.
- curtis 10y ago> ... This has since been confirmed by Ohanian,... Do you have a source for this?
- MegaButts 10y ago"It was my decision to change how we work with AMAs and the transition was my failure and I hope we can keep moving forward from that lesson." I guess the quote is a little less concrete than I remember, but given the context I don't know how else to interpret it. https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3cucye/an_old_team_at_reddit/csz2p3i/ https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3cucye/an_ol...
- Semaphor 10y agoAFAIK it was never proven beyond doubt, it just looks that way: https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/13/details-emerge-about-victoria-taylors-dismissal-at-reddit/ https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/13/details-emerge-abo...
- Lazare 10y agoYishan Wong (ex Reddit CEO, and thus someone who would be in a position to know) said Ohanian did it as part of an attempt to change how Reddit handled AMAs, and criticized Ohanian harshly for his actions and failure to defend Pao. Ohanian, for his part, has never denied it, and in fact has apologised for the "decision to change how we work with AMAs" as "his failure". I personally consider that confirmation.
- gpawl 10y agoIt's absurd to suggest that because User A wants one female to keep her job, that means that User A isn't mistreating someone else in a sexist way.
- jordanb 10y agoIt's not absurd when the argument is that reddit didn't like Pao just because she's a woman. Demonstrably there were women with authority on reddit who were well liked by the community. So her gender was at most a partial explanation for the reaction.
- bsder 10y agoEllen Pao is not a particularly good icon if you wish to discuss sexism. She filed a sexual harassment lawsuit over a relationship that she agreed was consensual. Once you decide to start sleeping with coworkers, you're pretty much sunk in a sexual harassment lawsuit irrespective of whether you are male, female, defending or prosecuting.
- snowwrestler 10y agoContrary to what you might think, women do not need to comport with your ideas of how they should conduct their personal relationships, in order to expect fair and professional treatment in the workplace and the world in general. You probably think you're making some kind of point that sexism wasn't an issue in how Pao was treated--when actually you're providing a good example of it.
- stagbeetle 10y agoHis comment was specifically addressing all genders. Irrespective, sleeping with coworkers is not a smart choice for anyone and the issue supersedes womens' right to "conduct their personal relationships."
- snowwrestler 10y agoIt's honestly none of your business who she sleeps with. And what you're implying--that because of a personal issue in her past, it was ok to harass her out the door at Reddit--is offensive and a classic tactic against women in the workplace. How many coworkers has Huffman slept with during his career? You don't know, because it never comes up, because he's a white guy. But we know that in his actual job as CEO as Reddit, he has abused users' trust in the system for his own benefit; but apparently Pao is still a worse villain. The double standard stands intact.
- stagbeetle 10y agoThis is beyond Pao, recognize that. People may have sexual-liberty, just as they may have the freedom of speech. But, freedom from consequences is not guaranteed under these liberties. If you sleep with the boss (man or woman) or a co-worker (man or woman) you are putting team dynamics in jeopardy. Likewise, if you openly bash your place of employment and revel in hate speech, you are putting the company's image in jeopardy. I'm not fond of the SJW rhetoric, but I will acknowledge it when it contains rational arguments. Using the guise of liberty to mask irresponsibility is not a rational or useful argument.
- kneel 10y agoPao had no business running reddit, everyone could tell early on. She didn't understand reddit and made very hasty unpopular decisions, well intentioned as they were, reddit was not used to censorship at the time and the execution was terrible. She also didn't understand how to use reddit, I remember her trying to post messages from her own inbox. There were a couple of other factors that contributed. They weren't very nice to her that's for sure but I wouldn't call it sexism.
- akhilcacharya 10y ago> She also didn't understand how to use reddit, I remember her trying to post messages from her own inbox. That was debunked, admins have that ability on private subreddits and she just posted in the wrong tab. https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3cbo4m/we_apologize/csu47pn/?utm_content=permalink&utm_medium=front&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=announcements https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3cbo4m/we_ap...
- mdekkers 10y agoThe Ellen Pao tenure was not the Reddit community's finest hour. Reddit stopped having a "finest hour" years ago, as is the way when online communities grow very large.
- forgottenpass 10y agoI won't say the sexism angle is bunk, but the difference in attitude also strike at the very question of what the role of a CEO is. Just with a reddit-y spin: Are the CEOs ultimately responsible for the behavior of the company beyond simple profit/sustainability? (This is a series of rhetorical questions, but do remember that your position for Pao/Huffman also applies to Kalanick). Is it their job to jump on the grenade so the area is clear for everyone else to pick up the pick up the pieces and move a never version of the company forward? To eat the problem so the baggage doesn't weigh on the company forever? I think under Pao, we saw a reddit userbase that expected the CEO to be a leader. A case where forcing a CEO to confront the dissent and dissatisfaction would compel action. In the wake of her ouster, and under Huffman it has become known the top brass DGAF. They have an addicted userbase and will skirt ownership and responsibility of the orgnization's actions like weasly middle managers (or politicians). The userbase appears to have adapted to operating under those terms. Why would the userbase maintain the same dissent towards Huffman? That would be insanity (doing the same thing, expecting different results).