5 ms·
Isn't this a GitHub TOS violation.
by kevin_thibedeau 10y ago
Isn't this a GitHub TOS violation.
- fortyseven 10y agoIf it turns out it is, I'll remove the infringing content. But considering the age and circumstances, I'm giving it a shot for now.
- JonRB 10y agoI'd recommend possibly sticking it on archive.org - I've seen other old software on there. Either that or reach out to lucasarts and ask if it's okay, I suppose. (As long as you get it in writing)
- fortyseven 10y agoAye, that's actually my next step. :) (Archive.org, that is.)
- sildur 10y agoI went through all the links, clicking on them and asking archive.org to save a copy. I also did it with the "Download", "Raw", and "Download ZIP" links.
- voltagex_ 10y agoDisc image and photo if possible - they're librarians, remember.
- fortyseven 10y agoThe disc is deeply worn, so a full ISO is probably not going to happen -- though I'll try a bunch of stuff. Maybe I'll get lucky!
- shinymark 10y agoYou'd need to contact Disney. They own the IP now.
- zer0t3ch 10y agoI thought LucasArts still owned the IP, but Disney owned LucasArts?
- tradersam 10y agoLucasArts still owns the IP, Disney is just its parent company now. LucasArts is the licensor, so I'd still recommend contacting them.
- shmerl 10y agoIt is Disney today. They own and decide.
- fludlight 10y agoIIRC, Disney shut down the game division when they acquired LucasFilm, so you would have to talk to someone at the parent co (Disney). Disney has a lot of old IP that's still very valuable, so they guard it aggressively[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steamboat_Willie#Copyright_status https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steamboat_Willie#Copyright_sta...
- glandium 10y agoTechnically, neither Disney or LucasArts own DeluxePaint.
- JonRB 10y agoWho owns it? Edit: Looks like EA owns it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deluxe_Paint#Legacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deluxe_Paint#Legacy
- aussie123 10y agoFor Deluxe Paint you will probably have to ask Electronic Arts.
- nether 10y agoAt the time, these files were worth six billion dollars.
- tradersam 10y agoHow so?
- fortyseven 10y agoSeveral points someone might have a problem with: - This is content that shipped on a commercial product - It contains proprietary LucasArts content, including a development tool - It also includes minimal copies of Deluxe Paint 2 (whoops!) I looked past all of this considering the age of it, but I won't fault GitHub for yanking it. I'll host it elsewhere if that happens.
- tradersam 10y agoMakes sense, thank you for the explanation.
- mmastrac 10y agoTechnically yes. Technically it's infringing copyright. The important question, however, is whether this is old enough that nobody cares anyone. I would wager that it falls on the side of not raising any flags anywhere, even though at one point this was valuable IP.
- peterkelly 10y agoYep, I don't think it's going to last very long there
- cooper12 10y agoAt the risk of sounding crass, who cares? If LucasArts cares, they'll send a DMCA to GitHub. Software from 1993 isn't depriving them of any profit and it's being shared for educational reasons. (it's not even the game itself) Preemptively freaking out over copyright is exactly what the MPAA wants you to do: they want you to forget that it's your right to share things. This has a chilling effect that we should avoid lest we enter a cultural black hole where we can only confidently share anything published before 1923.
- Houshalter 10y agoThis is why I wish copyright would expire after 15 years or so instead of forever. Especially for software. Very, very few people are profiting from 15 year old software.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Very, very few people are profiting from 15 year old software. Except the ones (for example Nintendo) who do have a lot of cash, influence groups and lawyers to enforce their rights as long as they want.
- qumemx 10y agoIf there were a mechanism whereby it could be extended for a fee, profitable 15yo+ software would still be protected but the community would benefit from everything else.
- peterburkimsher 10y ago15 year old software, like Windows XP and MS Office XP?
- kuschku 10y agoYes. Both are abandoned by microsoft — if they weren't protected anymore, people could add their own patches and fixes and distribute them.