7 ms·
Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims
- Asparagirl 10y agoThey are shocked, shocked to find gambling going on in this casino.
- Analemma_ 10y ago"We investigated ourselves and found ourselves not guilty"
- nullnilvoid 10y agoOne thing to remember that those so-called "independent" investigators are almost never independent. They are hired by the company, provided with biased information, and will definitely serve the company's benefits in the end. This is more like for show. Look, we have hired the former U.S. Attorney General to do the investigation. We are taking it very seriously. That said, let's wait and see the result.
- metaphorm 10y agoI think you're correct in a lot of ways, but I still view this as a major improvement from an internal investigation, or an investigation conducted only by sitting members of the board.
- Asparagirl 10y agoYup. In the case of GitHub several years ago, the "independent" investigation never even talked to the woman who made the accusations! That's common.
- spangry 10y agoNot quite as common as you think. For instance, Github: "Rhoma identified the employees she wanted to talk to based on an initial list we provided, the evidence she gathered, employees who asked to speak with her, people Julie asked her to speak with, and anyone else she determined was relevant, including Julie herself." Sounds like she spoke to 'Julie' (i.e. the woman who made the accusations). As for independence: "When the allegations against GitHub were raised publicly we took them seriously and within days launched an investigation into what happened. We hired Rhoma Young, an independent, third-party investigator that GitHub had never worked with before. Rhoma has a long history of conducting fair and impartial investigations, with 30+ years of HR experience. She has worked with every type of organization, from Fortune 50 companies to local governments, and frequently testifies as an expert witness for both plaintiffs and defendants in depositions, arbitrations, and in litigation involving discrimination, harassment, retaliation, disability, and mitigation of damages. Most importantly, Rhoma does not have a history of siding with companies or otherwise being a partisan, industry spokesperson. Half of her litigation witness work is on the side of employees, half for companies. Her job is to investigate situations and figure out what actually happened, even when the people who hired her don’t want to hear it." The full report is available here if you want to read it: https://github.com/blog/1826-follow-up-to-the-investigation-results https://github.com/blog/1826-follow-up-to-the-investigation-...
- chimeracoder 10y ago> Sounds like she spoke to 'Julie' (i.e. the woman who made the accusations) Horvath herself says that she never received an email from Rhoma, and (iirc) Rhoma says that she only reached out a few days before the end of the investigation. Melissa Severini (who made similar claims against the same founder two years earlier) also said that she never heard from Rhoma, which is a glaring omission if you're an investigator looking to identify a potential pattern of behavior.
- vogt 10y agoIn the case of the NFL and Tom Brady, Exponent served a similar role. And their track record speaks for itself.
- moonka 10y agoI think Huffington is on the board, so between that and having the head of HR and Legal, I don't even know if I'd consider this "independent". I hope I'm wrong.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThe complaint specifically says that human resources not only ignored the problems but lied to and sabotaged those doing the reporting. I can't imagine having them on board will be helpful.
- dllthomas 10y agoIt's a new head of HR since the events in question (but before the blog post).
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThanks for that correction. Having a new ond is a good move.
- matt4077 10y agoMichael Garcia at FIFA comes to mind as an example of someone (in a very similar position) doing an excellent job.
- ben_jones 10y ago"Who can we pay to make it look like we're actually doing something?"
- simonsarris 10y agoSo... not very independent. Holder has advocated for Uber in the past, we know he has a relationship with upper management already, which suggests it may not be a very impartial investigation. He's been in an advisory position to Uber since at least mid 2016. From July: > In one of the widest national efforts that Eric Holder Jr. has undertaken for a client since rejoining Covington & Burling last year, the former U.S. attorney general has written to lawmakers in three states on behalf of Uber Technologies Inc., urging them not to mandate fingerprinting for driver background checks. [1] > Holder's firm advises the company on safety matters and Uber asked him to write the letter, according to company spokesman Craig Ewer. [2] I hate to be negative and rude but I don't think this is going to generate the best outcome. What if Holder is just their go-to big name to get... political problems solved, and they just consider this to be just another pesky political problem? The article mentions Holder's firm, and they mention that the firm did an investigation into Airbnb, but they don't mention the previous relationship of that firm to Uber. This seems like relevant info for such a story and makes me wonder if the omission is intentional. [1] http://www.law.com/sites/almstaff/2016/06/16/eric-holder-advocating-for-uber-questions-regulatory-mandates/?slreturn=20170120215653 http://www.law.com/sites/almstaff/2016/06/16/eric-holder-adv... [2] http://bigstory.ap.org/article/01685274cc944196af9016ad0a875b72/eric-holder-weighs-uber-against-fingerprint-checks http://bigstory.ap.org/article/01685274cc944196af9016ad0a875...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flootch 10y agoEric couldn't find a single bankster guilty of anything in the 2008 meltdown, and he wasn't able to find anything wrong with Fast & Furious, so I have to disagree with you, his appointment will certainly provide the best outcome for Uber.
- falcolas 10y agoI think he is referring to a finding in Uber's favor by a biased party being bad in the public eye.
- 10y ago
- adamnemecek 10y agoWhat's Uber trying to message with this? Why Holder? Isn't he the guy behind the "fast and furious" debacle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATF_gunwalking_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATF_gunwalking_scandal?
- markbnj 10y agoCould be nothing more than having the description "former U.S. attorney general" next to a finding that Uber did nothing wrong. That would pretty much close the case for the average news skimmer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- freyr 10y agoSo they chose an Uber lobbyist, an Uber director, and the head of the department under investigation to lead their "independent investigation"? This company really has some audacity.
- jonursenbach 10y agoNot sure why anybody is surprised. This is how the company has always been.
- imron 10y agoHe's a high performer. And if he makes a mistake, I'm sure it'll only be his first offense.
- AckSyn 10y agoHigh performer meaning he lost hundreds of thousands of assault rifles in the "Fast and Furious" scam that sent small arms into Mexico. Which were immediately lost and use against US Citizens abroad and in our own country. That Holder?
- imron 10y agoRead this: https://www.susanjfowler.com/blog/2017/2/19/reflecting-on-one-very-strange-year-at-uber https://www.susanjfowler.com/blog/2017/2/19/reflecting-on-on...
- hiddencost 10y agoit's a joke, and a reference to the original blog post
- freyr 10y ago> That Holder? Right, the Holder who cut his teeth representing banks, became U.S. attorney general and refused to prosecute banks, and then went back to work representing banks. The Holder who has advocated on Uber's behalf in the past, and whose firm, Covington & Burling, has counseled Uber. I'm sure he's a real bastion of impartiality.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIf they hired me, I'd be talking to all the ground workers personally about company culture in general, any abusive behavior at all, any sexism on top of that, and effects on business achieving its goals. I'd probably visit or survey them a few times to re-question based on extra information I got over time. I'd anonymize the source material in final report to executives and investors. I'd highlight any damage to business objectives that I found along with changes that amount to new top-down agenda plus house cleaning at middle & lower management levels. If no response, I'd give the report and anonymized data to the media instead. Scheming politicians talking to scheming executives and management rarely results in good things. Hopefully this does but I'm not optimistic.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoWell I'm not defending Uber, nor the status quo of doing a political facade of investigation to cover your ass but I think you're making it out to be a little too simple. Uber has over 6,000 employees, so let's say you send a survey to all of them that's confidential asking about harassing behavior. Let's say you get a number like 6% [360] feel they've been harassed. Let's say you talk to the 6%, but half of those seem ambiguous (i.e. nothing in writing, this individual has complaints about a number of people and past jobs, individual's account seems inconsistent). Perhaps other employees don't even fill out your survey because they don't trust it's anonymous, or that when investigating their claims HR will be able to know who the "troublemakers" are. Nonetheless you take the 3% that seem solid and to find common threads (the same person being complained about, HR people failing to record/raise complaints, etc) but without everything in writing it's so hard to prove who raised a concern about what last year. Maybe many of those people already have left (voluntarily or not). I think if we want to solve these types of problems truly, we need to think about developing auditable systems (e.g. HR gives you a signed and written copy of every complaint, which their supervisor sees, and that lying on such a complaint be a legal offense on both the individual and corporate level).
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI'm describing a method already implemented by many large companies and one-man shops that do "efficiency engineering" by basically listening to ground workers. One of my employers got better survey results than you're describing despite being over 10x bigger than Uber. Getting the info out of workers hasn't been the hard part in industry. It's getting management to act on it that's hard. Things have to get bad enough, esp in media, that executives are forced to respond and handle policy change top down. Uber is halfway in that position.
- ultrahate 10y agoYall, I'm down with Uber. I know there's a lot of mudslinging lately, but I am so damn excited about the future. A world where we can do pub transit + big data, freight + big data, air freight + big data, food delivery + big data et al. Bad shit happens sometimes. There's a lot of shitty assholes in the world, but crucifying a worthy cause and successful business because a couple of morons work there just seems counter productive. As other comments have noted, this smells like the github situation a while back, and I'm no fan AT ALL of github, but even I concede that they are making a real difference for open source. I think uber is making that difference for moving people/things. I want to see some justice, I want to know exactly how it went down and how it was able to get to that point ie a dependency resolution as far as who shirked policy and who didn't, AND THEN I want business as usual. Shit happens, fix it, move on.
- striking 10y agoI mean, it sounds like basically all of Uber's HR was shirking policy here. I kind of agree with you that "shit happens and it needs to be fixed..." but there seems to be a lot of fixing that needs to be done here. Uber's "crucifixion" is well-deserved in this case. Time after time, Uber has proven itself to be an irresponsible company. Whether it's "God View" or the weird data blog they published on people's private data or this sexual harassment thing, they deserve some backlash. I don't think "crucifying a worthy cause" is a good idea either. But I also don't think that Uber is a company working towards a brighter future. The future's definitely not brighter for their employees- I mean, contractors-, as those people's rights as employees are currently in the middle of a legal battle. I think it's cool that Uber's breaking down the monopoly that taxi companies had. I think it's great that people are trying new things. But Uber has proven time and time again that it's an irresponsible company and the sooner we realize it's probably not going to bring us the future we need, the better.
- dandelany 10y agoFirst off, how cool and futuristic you judge a company's tech to be should have absolutely zero bearing on how an investigation like this is treated, and the fact that you even bring it up makes it hard to take the rest of your post seriously. Secondly, Fowler did exactly the right things in response to these incidents, over and over: she kept evidence, and she talked to the people in the company who were ostensibly supposed to help her deal with them. For a year straight. The fact that things continued to steadily get worse for her throughout this process shows pretty clearly that this is not a couple of morons. This is an institutional problem at Uber that must be dealt with at an institutional level.
- isubkhankulov 10y agoI'm not trying to defend Uber here but there are two sides of every story and I'm sure we'll find out more in the coming weeks and months one way or another. I could see how many people could jump to conclusions about Uber after reading the original blog post. However, by headcount- it is a medium to large company at this point while at the same time has an uncertain future and still taking big bets. I could see how that could cause chaos in some or all areas of the company. Maybe- the blog post provide one point of view into Silicon Valley culture/gender dynamics. Maybe- this culture often exists within engineering departments of elite companies (vs the business/marketing/sales side). There are a lot of moving parts in the original post: HR department acting unprofessionally, manufactured performance reviews and awkward IM's. I've encountered situations where new employees just didn't fit in well with their coworkers, for a variety of reasons. They typically don't last long as employees. Usually a year or less.
- MegaButts 10y agoI've heard nothing but awful things about Uber since before they tried to recruit me years ago. Everybody I know who's met the CEO specifically used the word 'sociopath' to describe him, along with a litany of other unpleasant terms.
- muglug 10y ago> I'm not trying to defend Uber here Well, insofar as you present an alternative reality wherein Uber didn't do anything exceptional (by the standards of their peers), you're defending Uber. And then "I've encountered situations where new employees just didn't fit in well with their coworkers". If the engineer's claims are true, what happened to her and to others has nothing whatsoever to do with culture fit.
- khazhou 10y agoRight now all you know is that blog post. There's no denying that there may be another side, which can only be known after they investigate. That's the basic principle of our legal system... why wouldn't it apply here, despite this still being handled privately within the company?
- aorloff 10y agoThey certainly appear to be taking their own liability in the matter very seriously.
- flootch 10y agoQ: What are the ethical implications of an engineer taking on employment with Uber given what we know as factual regarding Uber's behavior and given the high demand for software engineers in today's economy? Q: If you do not have family, and are reasonably healthy, what are the ethical implications of retaining a position at Uber and not resigning?
- matt4077 10y agoA: If the engineer has any reasonable alternatives (which they should have, as you're pointing out) it's somewhat indefensible on moral terms. Maybe, possibly, you could count this news as indication that the process is working as expected and defer judgement for a while. More importantly, though: it's completely stupid to join Uber now. It's pretty clear that the work environment has always been the sort of thing that kills any humanity people may have had. With this investigation, the backstabbing will only get worse. You'll get there (without any knowledge of the internal structure) and have to navigate a maze while it's on fire. Somewhere above, I'm also making the case of an upcoming Uber->Under transformation. They were burning cash as if Elon Musk was trying to escape from the Federal Mint. Now, their revenue is taking a hit and investors won't touch them with a 10-foot pole in an open relationship. Apart from engineers, their management may at the verge of collapse: If your vesting is nowhere in sight (and I believe Uber's vesting is tied to exit scenarios, so good luck with that), it's time to cut your losses before Holder's successor starts the actual investigation. If there's anything suspicious with their finances (which people have long been speculating about, considering they stopped publishing them), you don't want to be an innocent guy/gal in a guilty org.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoI think you're exaggerating just a bit. This is going to result in 7-8 figures of hush money being paid to Fowler.
- stale2002 10y agoUber was legitimately at the top of my list of companies that I was going to apply for. After what happened to Susan.... Yeah, not anymore.
- pasbesoin 10y agoAll this does is further reduce my opinion of Holder.
- dpweb 10y agoJust read the blog post and it's a really terrible story. Just awful. Assuming it's true.. You can take the Nixon position - didn't know what subordinates were doing - and probably didn't - but this goes to culture and that means - the very top management levels. Like it or not, the very top management is responsible for culture. Could be no one in the world more horrified reading about this, than the CEO. I would be. However, I wouldn't be too harsh on bringing in people somewhat friendly to the company (doesn't mean they can't be impartial or follow the leads where ever they lead) - there is an interest in protecting (call it, saving) the company from people who did know about it and perpetrated it.
- samstave 10y agoholder is a criminal - and before you downvote me, you'd better have your history in order. The guy is scum.
- grzm 10y agoYou'll likely be downvoted just for mentioning the downvotes. Also, the tone comes across as uncivil, which will likely attract downvotes as well. If you're concerned about this, I suggest removing the last sentence and the remarks about downvotes, and provide some of the facts that support your initial statement. It makes for a much more substantive and strong comment.
- samstave 10y agoSure, downvote me on tone, not on fact. He is scum. anyone defending that guy.... I dont care about stupid points on HN... -- Eric Holder and his ilk are criminals. If you disagree, prove me wrong. They are all murderers.
- grzm 10y agoIf you read me as disagreeing with you or defending Holder, you're reading me wrong. Why did you post your comment on HN? I believe it was that you believe Eric Holder is a criminal and want to let other people know. Who is your audience? If it's people who already agree with you, you haven't told them anything they don't already know. If you're trying to reach people who aren't aware, you've given them nothing other than your angry words to make a decision. They're likely not inclined to look up any additional information based on your comment: there's plenty of angry posters on all variety of issues, and a lot learn to discount them given no additional evidence. If you're trying to reach people who disagree with you, you've already picked a potentially adversarial audience already inclined to dismiss you. As for why I posted my comment, is that I really want to see substantive, constructive discussions, and often see people include in their comments references to potentially receiving downvotes, and perceive them as due to the content, rather than the the presentation. On contentious issues in particular, presentation is so important to productive discussion.
- jbapple 10y agoEric Holder said that it met the constitutional bar of "due process" for a Anwar al-Awlaki, a US citizen living abroad, to be assassinated by the executive branch as long as they talked about it a bit beforehand. I am doubtful that his investigation will result in meaningful change at Uber.
- diminoten 10y agoHe may have said that, but it wasn't specifically his call to make.
- jbapple 10y agoDo you mean the the President could have told the CIA to assassinate Anwar al-Awlaki even if Holder disapproved? If so, then we agree that President could have done that. Eric Holder could have spoken out against it in private, and, after the assassination was made public, in the media. He could have resigned in protest as other AGs before him did in the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturday_Night_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturday_Night_Massacre. At the very least, he could have declined to tell the public that the President's actions meet the Constitutional bar of due process. Clearly, the stakes are much lower, here, unless Uber is also running a drone assassination campaign. But we have seen Holder before in a situation where his employer holds immense power over a departed stakeholder who has become a vocal critic, and we have seen his unwillingness to challenge power in that circumstance. I hope I am wrong, and I hope that Holder can make a meaningful difference in preventing Uber from continuing to treat its employees so poorly as it did in the blog post in question.
- stuckagain 10y agoPeople who are at war with the United States are not "assassinated" by that country. They just lose. Numerous people have lost their lives in this fashion.
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not so clear cut as you make it out to be. In the phrase "due process," the word "due" literally means "what is warranted." I.e. "Due process" has always been understood as the idea that people are entitled to the amount of process warranted under the circumstances. It's about fact-specific inquiries, not bright-line rules. How much process is "warranted" when a U.S. Citizen wages war against the U.S. abroad and actively tries to evade any attempts at accountability through other means? Is military action against a U.S. citizen abroad never warranted? Maybe, but maybe not. I wouldn't have made the same call as Holder, but that's just me opinion, not an inexorable legal conclusion.
- photonwins 10y agoI am not aware of how the system works, but shouldn't authorities voluntarily (don't know the legal term) investigate this case even though there is no official complaint? There is victim's statement out in the open right?
- freyr 10y agoI'm not a lawyer, but sexual harassment is usually a civil offense, not a criminal offense.
- simonk 10y agoMost of this would be a civil matter and not criminal.
- vimalakirti 10y agoCorporations like Uber universally coerce their servants to sign away their rights to litigation. The only mechanism they have is arbitration, chosen by the corporation.
- battlebot 10y agoOh wow, that sucks! Eric Holder--how that man has any credibility at all is beyond my ability to comprehend. But I won't forget Fast & Furious and what happened there and neither will millions of other Americans. I guess it could be worse: Uber could have hired the Clintons and then the whistleblower lady would be in danger for her life.
- thathoo 10y agoI wish we take from this not that uber has a toxic culture (it may well have that) - but rather see if there are lessons here to help improve their own company cultures. The cost of a good culture is constant vigilance and such blogposts raise important questions. We should introspect and ask - does this happen at my company? What can I do to change this?
- getpost 10y agoAsking Holder and Huffington to get involved is grandiose. I imagine isn't difficult to avoid being grandiose when you have a multi-billion dollar valuation. The thing is, what's needed is a culture change, and these people aren't going to change the culture. It'll just be another distraction.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- intrasight 10y agoHiring Eric Holder to me means that they aren't going to handle this "internally". So this could be very interesting. But likely this is Eric Holder as big PR bandaid, and that's all we're likely to see unfortunately.
- snowwrestler 10y agoUber is treating this like it's a situation that they just stumbled upon, rather than the way that their own company, which they painstakingly created from scratch, works. The goal of this sort of investigation is to try to reset the clock--to try to get people to say "well let's see what the investigation finds," like the situation is a complete mystery, like it's a dead guy in a locked cabin with nothing but a puddle of water. "What a mystery we have stumbled upon! Let us investigate." The reality is, this should never have happened in the first place, and it was 100% in Uber's control to prevent it. The very best you can possibly say right now is that executive management at Uber placed zero emphasis on preventing harassment. If they had, their HR team would not have acted so stupidly.
- urahara 10y agoIt is actually seems that Ubber executive management and CEO not only place 0 emphasis on preventing harassment, but also supports and promotes harassment.
- lsiebert 10y agoFrankly, seems like Uber and any large workspace should have regular company wide training on appropriate workplace behavior, before it's an issue for anyone. You get the culture you create.
- wpietri 10y agoTraining isn't entirely useless, but it's a pretty small part of preventing problems like this. It's not like her manager didn't know that hitting on his employees was wrong. He didn't do it out of ignorance. He did it because he could get away with it.
- walshemj 10y agoThe point of the training is to stop the employee saying I didn't know it was wrong
- wpietri 10y agoDid somebody say that here? And don't most companies cover this stuff during orientation and in the staff manual? Even if they don't, so what if employees claim ignorance? There are a whole host of firing offenses that professionals are expected to know without being told. "Nobody told me I couldn't punch my boss," is not a reasonable excuse.
- nowarninglabel 10y agoThat training is actually mandated by the state of California by AB 1825 for employers with > 50 employees. If they were not having regular harassment training for supervisors then they were breaking the law.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 10y agoUber does have such training.
- 234dd57d2c8dba 10y agoIsn't this the "fast and the furious scandal" guy? Yuck. Another strike against Uber for me...
- Asparagirl 10y agoI'm curious whether Holder's "investigation" will also look at Uber's historical attitude and pattern of behavior towards women as a whole, not just their female employees. For example, there's Uber's refusal to background-check their drivers using a system that includes fingerprints, which is something that most traditional taxi companies are required to do. The SF District Attorney has publicly called a background check without fingerprints "worthless." Journalist Sarah Lacy of PandoDaily linked Uber's fingerprinting refusal to the number of cases of women kidnapped and/or raped by their Uber drivers, and how Uber seemed to think that this was either not happening or wasn't their fault. Lacy claimed in one article that that Uber PR would even smear the passengers as having been drunk and dressed inappropriately. In one case, a woman was choked by her Uber driver and police were called to the scene, but CEO Kalanick claimed in an interview in "GQ" that it didn't happen. (We're talking about hundreds of incidents of assault; a partial list is here: http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/rideshare-incidents http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/rideshare-incidents ) Lacy also pointed out Uber's collaboration with escort services in Lyon, France -- which objectified Uber's female drivers as lingerie-clad escorts, and offered passengers free 20-minute rides with them... And there was BuzzFeed News reporter Johana Bhuiyan, who had her trip information accessed on two occasions without her consent... And then there was the report from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), which is non-partisan and non-profit, that found in a two-year study covering 1500 rides and published last October that female Uber passengers were taken on longer and therefore more expensive rides than male Uber passengers...
- eh78ssxv2f 10y agoI have seen that list of incidents that you shared (http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/rideshare-incidents http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/rideshare-incidents). That list includes regular driving accidents too which could happen to anybody. After seeing that website, I think the first few questions I had were: (i) During a given time period, how many rideshare trips were taken? (ii) How many rideshare riders were affected (killed, assaulted etc.)? (iii) During that same period, how many taxi trips were taken? (iv) How many taxi riders were affected? That website only answers (ii), and not the rest of the three questions which makes the presented data meaningless (and also misleading, IMO).
- KevinEldon 10y agoThe real test is how Uber specifically addresses Susan Fowler's comments. If they recognize issues, create programs, wave hands, weep openly, hire someone to yell "shame", etc. then it's all about correcting how they are perceived. It's understandable. If they pay Susan something larger than an annual salary and request that other female employees who suffered similar mistreatment come forward for similar compensation then they're serious about resolving the issue permanently and addressing their mistakes (I'm imagining Uber running ads like a personal injury lawyer 'are you a woman, have you worked at Uber corporate, were you sexually harassed and mistreated, please call Uber for $150k or more in compensation for the wrongs you were forced to endure). No company actively prosecutes themselves. No lawyer seeks outcomes that aren't aligned with their client's best possible outcomes. Eric Holder, despite his name recognition and alignment w/ President Obama, is not there to help women who work at or have worked at Uber. He's there to help Uber look better.
- ComodoHacker 10y ago>If they pay Susan something larger than an annual salary and request that other female employees who suffered similar mistreatment come forward for similar compensation then they're serious about resolving the issue permanently and addressing their mistakes How paying off victims has anything to do with resolving the issue permanently?
- kyle-rb 10y agoI agree with Comodo; paying off victims does not solve the problem. Clearly what needs to happen is for Uber to discipline/fire the offender or offenders. Establishing that they will follow through on complaints would (ideally) dissuade people from doing things like this in the first place, as well as assuring other victims that if they come forward, something will actually be done about the issue.
- hueving 10y agoKeep in mind this isn't an independent investigation from the perspective of Uber. Holder has ties to Uber and it's only independent in the sense that he was not involved with the parties in question. In order to get a truly independent investigation, there will likely have to be a lawsuit, because companies very rarely want actual independent investigations.
- Canada 10y agoI'm reticent about sharing thoughts on sexual harassment in the workplace, given the emotionally charged nature of the issue. I've seen men get away with completely inappropriate behavior toward women at work, and I've also seen women make absolutely false claims against male coworkers and get rewarded with unearned benefits. I see how hard it can be for a neutral third party to judge the difference when all there is to go on is he-said-she-said. In this case however, the accuser claims to have verifiable evidence that her direct supervisor propositioned her for sex and then punished her for declining. And not only did Uber not remove him for it, it covered for him. If her accusation is true, and it probably is if Uber isn't denying it at this point, then Uber is causing incredible self-inflicted damage by allowing some employees bully over 1/7 of its technical/product workforce with impunity. Uber has taken over 8 billion dollars from investors. To those investors, how much has Uber represented that 1/7 of its workforce is worth? Yeah, not surprising they're getting some famous names to help explain this.
- ithought 10y agoWhat happened to being normal, getting to know people and then once having some sort of familiarity, maybe mildly flirting with them? IF they reciprocate, then go from there -- if not, forget about it? Of course, if you're in a position of power over someone, you shouldn't do this or at least be aware of the consequences. But this culture of texting girls that are co-workers direct sexual or relationship stuff without even knowing them is just crazy. It's never appropriate.
- yeukhon 10y agoI'm going to say I believe in Ms. Flower's statement. It can't just be some make up story if so many people echo on the culture at Uber (it would be big conspiracy to organize). I'd look forward a criminal case opened on this, but it's up to Ms. Flowers. I am very aggressive person, I don't let people get away easily if they offend me like this. Anyway, when the investigation is concluded, and when the investigation result matches the victim's statement, I expect no less from the CEO but a public meeting with reporters, bow to the TV audience like how one does in Japan. I expect no less. Leader who is "misled" and "misinformed" by his or her workers should feel scared. Think about the whole national adviser talking to Russia scandal. Uber recruiter, you can take my name off your recruitment list.
- JCzynski 10y agoOn one hand, he has reputation to risk. On the other, he has reputation to burn.
- yuhong 10y agoPersonally, I don't dislike sexual harassment laws as much as employment anti-discrimination laws, but I do question whether they are really needed.
- tdeck 10y agoUsers of the tech employee chat app Blind won't be surprised to see this is happening at Uber, it seems like that forum is full of nothing but complaints about their toxic work environment. I remember in particular seeing this thread and being horrified: http://m.imgur.com/22JWxGQ http://m.imgur.com/22JWxGQ
- mankash666 10y agoWhy doesn't she sue Uber. By law, emails under litigation are required to be retained, so the evidence must exist.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoTo what end? It's unlikely she'd get enough money from the lawsuit to justify the expense and difficulty. And it would consume her life for perhaps a year or several years. On a pure cost/benefit analysis it makes no sense. If she couldn't find other work in the tech field it might make sense, but if you're pulling down a silicon valley average 6 figure salary at another job you just move on.
- Ensorceled 10y agoOr, you know, we could wait to see if Eric Holder and Ariana Huffington actually do nothing about this before we assume they're merely paid shills for Uber.