5 ms·
I feel I need to write the inverse article "Stopping an Internet Service Provider", since I just shut down mine. Although this stuff can be great fun, you have
by dboreham 10y ago
I feel I need to write the inverse article "Stopping an Internet Service Provider", since I just shut down mine.
Although this stuff can be great fun, you have to stop and ask yourself why the market is "under served" and why there isn't already some dude supplying these customers, driving around the city in his Lexus and waxing his new boat on the weekends.
The unfortunate truth is that there just isn't that great a business there, especially in light of its quite high capital costs and quite significant risks.
It is a business that suits larger players who can spread the fixed costs across many cities. It is a business that suits providers offering a basket of services, not just IP transit (TV, Phone, value-added network services). It is a business that demands either a) high price boutique offerings (e.g. the people you end up buying your upstream connectivity from) or b) rock-bottom/who-cares-about-quality, high-volume products (e.g. Charter/Comcast). A small new player can't compete in either of those markets.
I could go on, but really : would you be super-excited if you had the idea to build better electricity transmission lines to a bunch of folk; or a better sewer system? No. And the reality is that IP connectivity is not much different to these other utilities.
- ng-user 10y agoIf you ever get the time, I'd love a written response similar to the OP detailing the contrary.
- dboreham 10y agoI'll put it on the "articles to write list".
- chrishacken 10y ago> No. And the reality is that IP connectivity is not much different to these other utilities. I understand where you're coming from, but it is different. You have ample power to power your home; utilities can fulfill whatever your power requirements are. The same can't be said about IP. I am literally incapable of live streaming from my parents house, no matter how much I'm willing to pay. There's no internet option, among the few available, that are capable of fulfilling my requirements.
- wingworks 10y agoYou could get fibre put in, if your budget is big enough, but I get what you mean.
- fludlight 10y agoI agree with you that rural-broadbandification will be as important as rural-electrification was in the '30s. That said, I think that most lucrative (read: capital efficient) business model here is low-bandwidth web sites, not high-bandwidth ISPs. Does a news site really need to ship 2Mb of JS, a 20Mb auto-play video, and 5Mb of ads to communicate 1.5Kb of plain-text? Maybe if your users have fast connections but not if they're in rural Idaho and it takes 2 minutes (that's 2,000 milliseconds) to load a single page. Edit: numbers
- lotkowskim 10y agoSmall correction 2 minutes is 120000 milliseconds
- dboreham 10y agoYeah no need to explain the situation because I started my own ISP 16 years ago because I bought a house in Montana that the telco assured me could get T1 service. But they lied, so I had to build my own wireless ISP 10 miles out from the nearest town to get service. And to justify the investment in upstream and equipment I decided to serve the "underserved" businesses in town. Been there, have the T-shirt. Consider the analogy further : if you built a house in a place with no power line, you would expect to either not use much power, or to pay a hefty fee (10's of thousands) to get power brought in. But folks expect to get Internet capable of streaming Netflix 4K (on two screens concurrently) for $50/mo.
- mildlyclassic 10y ago>A small new player can't compete in either of those markets. We're Wifidabba.com and we're in the current batch of YC. We provide low-cost internet in India at tea-stalls and bakeries. Consumers buy tokens and get access to wifi. In effect, we take a broadband connection and slice it into tiny pieces and sell that as wifi. I guess in some ways we're an ISP, the government certainly thinks so, we've had to apply for an ISP license. We're only a few months old, but we're reasonably profitable and the future looks good. I think there's room for new ISP's if you're willing to be creative about how to grow the number of customers you want to reach. For example, we're getting tons of inquiries about being an IOT platform amongst other things. *edited for clarity
- sumedh 10y agoThe pricing looks super cheap. All the best.
- mildlyclassic 10y agoWe believe in charging for a good service. We don't ever want to show ads or mess with your connection in any way. thanks !
- bluesign 10y agothis is mesh network, right? can you tell a bit about your technology?
- mildlyclassic 10y agoIt's a mesh built on low cost custom hardware. Each node is also super powerful with >128gb storage and some nice computation power, with a GPU to boot :) We're looking to be more than just an ISP in the long run.
- jbpetersen 10y agoFor what value of "more than just an ISP"?