4 ms·
"Well perhaps they should consider what literally anybody would have considered long before some HN rando suggested it." It's not the jobs that make people not
by eropple 10y ago
"Well perhaps they should consider what literally anybody would have considered long before some HN rando suggested it."
It's not the jobs that make people not want to work there. It's everything around the jobs. Money has diminishing marginal value. For many, many people, not living in a heavily drugged-up rural area where nobody else has any prospects is going to outweigh any wage increases that aren't going to drown the company. People aren't spherical cows.
The company exists there because it's the closest thing to the Third World that exists in America, with the commensurate low worker compensation and the weak worker rights that that implies. Because it probably couldn't exist anywhere else.
(Whether that company's continued existence is valuable to the society that grants it its imprimatur is a different question entirely, and one where reasonable people can differ.)
- wlesieutre 10y ago> People aren't spherical cows. And more importantly, people aren't in a vacuum.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoSmall cities and rural areas don't grow or wither by accident. They grow when the government enforces competition laws at every level, preventing markets from being captured. They wither when markets are captured and the network effects of oligopolized megacities become more valuable than genuine market experimentation. http://washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/novdec-2015/bloom-and-bust/ http://washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/novdec-2015/bloom-and-...
- eropple 10y agoI agree with you in general, but there is also the specter of international competition that is a lot harder to meaningfully regulate (we've seen what protectionist policies do, to all of our detriment). Those network effects of big cities are not intrinsically tied to oligopolic structures. They're also just bigger and more attractive to a big chunk of the population, yeah?
- leereeves 10y agoHow is China able to be so protectionist and so successful?
- eropple 10y agoBecause they can be an order of magnitude cheaper because the health of the workers they barely pay doesn't matter to them. This is starting, already, to change, if slowly, both due to external pressures (PR) and the rise, again slowly, of markets that are in turn cheaper and even less give-a-shit than they are. (EDIT: Also, it's important to realize that that "success" very much does not extend to rural China. They're not airlifting money out there the way that we effectively do for our rural populations and so industry is even more concentrated than in the United States, when you adjust for relative population size.) And this is the argument of the types who want to rail against OSHA and minimum wages and the like in America, but frankly, I like not living in a society with factory-crippled invalids and suicide nets on the windows so I am so very unsympathetic. It's an externality that I'm certainly not comfortable overall with, but the bright spot is that those dangerous, barely-paying jobs are a rear-guard action as we play out the clock towards ever-cheaper, more-pervasive automation; that said, the inevitably oppressive effects of modern capital owning that automation is why I am effectively, if not in name, a socialist in 2017.
- scarface74 10y agoA lot of that "success" is not real. China is building infrastructure that no one is actually using. Temporarily propping up the economy but not tied to long term gains. https://www.google.com/amp/www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/2016/12/19/china-bubble-economy-2017/amp/?client=safari https://www.google.com/amp/www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/20...
- leereeves 10y agoThat's a minor quibble compared to how far they've come from where they started.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago
- mindcrime 10y agogovernment enforces competition laws at every level, preventing markets from being captured. ROFLMFAO. It's government that causes markets to become captured. Ex: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture It's extremely unlikely for a true monopoly to form in the absence of government regulation.
- eropple 10y agoRegulatory capture is by far not the only kind of capture, and a well-run government can avoid it. Just as a fair free market can avoid whatever you're goalpost-hauling at when you say "true monopoly". Of course, it's also much more likely that a market without regulation enables collusive behavior on the part of actors with the greater balance of power who don't have to answer to the society around them. Monopolies are not and have never been the only, or even the biggest, societal threat. Oligopolies and cartels exist because cooperating against the public is a better option for them than competing with one another and (as any game theorist will tell you) the first to be disloyal gains only a small edge at the cost of significantly reduced results for everybody. The only real threat to an entrenched oligopoly or a cartel in your sufficiently-free market is a necktie party on the streetcorner, and that in practice is rare 'cause paying for guns takes money.
- mindcrime 10y agoand a well-run government can avoid it. Which is about as likely as the proverbial "sufficiently smart compiler". Oligopolies and cartels exist because cooperating against the public is a better option for them than competing with one another and (as any game theorist will tell you) the first to be disloyal gains only a small edge at the cost of significantly reduced results for everybody. But in reality, cartel members cheat all the time. Take OPEC, for example, where members are always producing more than their official limits.
- x0x0 10y agoExcept over and over again online -- and even more if you've ever gone to a Chamber of Commerce meeting in a small town -- these business owners do what the valley does. Whine they can't hire, and refuse to raise wages. I collect these links because I find it funny; I'd paste some but I'm on the wrong computer. But my guess is lots of these places are paying shit wages for shit work with low or no benefits and few advancement options. It's weird they can't seem to find decent employees, eh? This also matches my experience with family that still live in a similar area. Employers whine endlessly about the lack of workers for their $14 and hour factory job with expensive shitty health insurance. On the other hand, my brother runs his own chain of pizza restaurants in the midwest. He starts at 50% over minimum wage and pays for health insurance. Guess who has no problems hiring as many reliable employees as he needs?
- eropple 10y agoI grew up in a town where this was going on. Some just complain, you're right. Others literally can't make the math work, and I watched a local company submarine themselves for trying. There are few advancement options because there are few ways to advance. They're dead-end jobs, and there's a wage ceiling because their competitors don't have to play by the same rules. They're jobs that won't exist in twenty years, maybe not even ten, because of a number of factors; the question is not how to better employ the people who would be their workers, but how to give everybody a baseline-decent life regardless of "work" (in an economy where most "work" is rapidly becoming less important).
- x0x0 10y agoSure, some businesses aren't going to work out / the economics don't work. Others are like the wire manufacturer MLP Steel: there will (probably) continue to be a need for someone who can make custom stuff fast, and that requires you to be local so it's a couple day delivery instead of a month being shipped from China. But their claim is they pay "$12 to $20 an hour, plus health care and benefits", which means they start you at $12. The fuck do they expect for $12 an hour? That's under $20k/year after taxes, in an area where craigslist suggests it's going to cost you $700/mo to rent and heat a place to live. Again, my brother who runs pizza restaurants starts employees at $16.