9 ms·
As I commented last night[1], the New York Times has cast Fowler's experience as a he-said-she-said story. Unfortunately I was not pessimistic enough: 1. The N
by brudgers 10y ago
As I commented last night[1], the New York Times has cast Fowler's experience as a he-said-she-said story. Unfortunately I was not pessimistic enough:
1. The New York Times spiked the most damning part of Fowler's story: that HR was actively involved in supporting the behavior.
2. It down plays Fowler's specific experience as typical for the industry and marginalizes it by bringing Pao's story into Fowler's narrative. Pao's experience was radically different, if for no other reason than Fowler is a rank and file employee of the most typical kind, an engineer. Pao is an executive. It also brought all the irrlevant ambiguities surrounding Pao's executive actions at Reddit into the mix.
3. It repeats nearly all of Uber's public response verbatim rather than linking to it as it does with Fowler's article.
Fowler's story gets one paragraph (or two if the one sentence paragraph about going to work for Stripe counts). The same amount is devoted to Pao. Uber's PR gets the bulk of the article with no critical analysis.
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13683159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13683159
- Tloewald 10y agoI'm curious as to whether you're complaining about the story. What do you mean by "spiked"? The coverage seems fair and open-ended
- brudgers 10y agoFowler's statement describes ongoing and systematic patterns of discrimination, retribution and harassment against and of women and its facilitation by the human resource department. The headline leads with Uber's damage control message and ignores the most serious part of Fowler's description.
- Terretta 10y agoIn case you're still following, another Uber engineer's voice: https://medium.com/@hadrad1000/reflecting-on-susan-fowlers-reflections-e2dccb374b47 https://medium.com/@hadrad1000/reflecting-on-susan-fowlers-r...
- brudgers 10y agoMy remarks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13697010 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13697010 The piece is consistent with the Rogue Actor narrative as is the subsequently disclosed investigative structure which involves lawyering up. Most likely to assess the legal risk and perhaps to come up with a strategy that allows truthful but non-incriminating statements should the fallout turn out to entail deposition by hostile lawyers. Still nobody fired and the official narrative is that the CEO is moved to tears rather than taking personal responsibility.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Joeri 10y agoWere you there when the alleged facts happened? If not, it is definitely he-said-she-said. It is probable that things happened as Fowler claims, but we have no way of knowing without evidence. The article mentions the facts, which are basically who said what, since neither side has shared any evidence. Personally I'm not going to pass judgment either way without knowing more, but this is definitely going into my something-fishy-over-there file.
- mcguire 10y agohttp://bit.ly/2kCE416 http://bit.ly/2kCE416 She claims to have a record of all of the events, although she (rightly) didn't post them.
- jacquesm 10y agoIt might not stay that way like this.
- logicallee 10y agoMaybe the reporter didn't read the blog post, because it was beyond his attention span. Honestly, it just sounds like an editor assigned him to report. If he had read it he wouldn't have summarized it as "a lengthy post on her personal blog": he would have written that Fowler wrote about her experiences which began " On my first official day rotating on the team, my new manager sent me a string of messages over company chat. He was in an open relationship, he said, and his girlfriend was having an easy time finding new partners but he wasn't. He was trying to stay out of trouble at work, he said, but he couldn't help getting in trouble, because he was looking for women to have sex with." After she rightfully brought this to the attention of HR, she was told "I was then told that I had to make a choice: (i) I could either go and find another team and then never have to interact with this man again, or (ii) I could stay on the team, but I would have to understand that he would most likely give me a poor performance review when review time came around, and there was nothing they could do about that." with no further penalties or reprimand. That latter part is what's shocking, that she was told her performance would be reviewed poorly, even though she was very qualified (this team was the best fit for her and the work she wanted to do.) She also wrote that HR told her regarding such complaints that they were first-time offenses, though she heard the same experience from multiple women. In her account she didn't talk about harassment much (except the one incident) and instead said that she was given poor reviews (changed after she saw that the performance reviews were good) in order to keep from transferring. A lot of the blog post was about the lack of responsiveness by HR. Her biggest issue was the way in which women were driven out. The important quote is "When I joined Uber, the organization I was part of was over 25% women. By the time I was trying to transfer to another eng organization, this number had dropped down to less than 6%" and then at the end that "Out of over 150 engineers in the SRE teams, only 3% were women." Instead of reading her blog post and reporting on it, the reporter simply reported without reading, in a cookie-cutter way. (Or it certainly reads that way.) Having read the source yesterday (along with everyone else here), I don't like the reporter's summary at all.
- eanzenberg 10y agoYeah unfortunately NYT mixed the 2 to try to get sympathy for Pao and paint a broader gender issue within SV. These 2 cases are quite far apart.
- cbtacy 10y agoSo profoundly disappointed in not just the NY Times but all the media coverage. The story is not that Travis has ordered an investigation - it's that Uber is a cesspool. And for those who are saying "do you have evidence" - please... Like we ALL don't know what working at Uber is like. Cmon man.
- jimmywanger 10y ago> Like we ALL don't know what working at Uber is like. That's circular reasoning. The reason that working at Uber is bad is because we all know that working at Uber is bad. That's the sort of logic that starts witch trials and Communist hunting. "Well, she's a witch because we all know she's a witch." How about "Well, she's a slut because we all know she's a slut?" That's about the same level of logic as your statement.
- ryandrake 10y agoOnly in the court of public opinion does "Cmon man--you know it's true" hold any value. On the whole it's not looking very good for Uber, but it's hard to say with any certainty until facts materialize.
- brudgers 10y agoThe main stream media caters its reporting to maintain access. Alternative media tends to do likewise. A reporter whose beat is Silicon Valley tech companies has to maintain access to those companies so that they can get an email from the CEO when the story breaks. If the reporter spent significant time muck raking the employment practices of the tech industry, the reporter would be frozen out. The Anti-Trust collusion case wasn't based on a story that some reporter broke or news outlet broke.
- mcguire 10y agoNeither the NYT nor Reuters articles mention the other 90% of the alleged activities: http://bit.ly/2kCE416 http://bit.ly/2kCE416
- SeoxyS 10y agoNYTimes is a news organization with a mandate to report on verifiable fact, not rumor or opinion. You're complaining that it's reported as a he-said-she-said type of story… but for now, that's exactly what it is. The claims are quite plausible and convincing (and likely true), but at this point they still are merely unsubstantiated claims. If I were to imagine the right way to report such a story at this point, it would go like this (1) summarize the claims made, (2) include the response from the accused, and (3) emphasize that this is a developing story. That's pretty much what the NYT did. However, until a court or investigation corroborates the report, they shouldn't be reported as irrefutable fact. That said I agree that the comparison to the Ellen Pao case has no place in this report. Pao's case was quite different and much less convincing. In my distanced armchair opinion, she deserved to lose that case.
- Retric 10y agoIf you want an objective fact, there was a drop from 25% women to 3% women. Now, it's not just he said she said.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI don't doubt for a second that that it's true, but what is the likelihood that the New York Times was able to verify it in less than a day? Is that something Uber is going to fess up to? They can simply say "no comment", and likely have. For all we know they're scrambling to move women into that department so that when the actual verifiable statistics do come out they're not so bad. To verify this comment well enough to publish it, the NY Times is going to have to go find enough SREs at Uber who are willing to talk to them (and likely risk losing their job if discovered) about these issues.
- xg15 10y agoIt's not just about verified vs unverified claims, it's also how the claims are presented. The quotes from Fowler's blog are selective to misleading: As an example, the part where she describes HR's excuses is quoted in full ("first offense", "honest mistake") but the part where she notes those excuse are likely complete fabrications is left unmentioned. That makes it appear as if Fowler were overreacting even by her own claims when her actual claims are much more grave and substantial.
- acjohnson55 10y agoYou should consider taking your issues with the story to the Public Editor [1], who is the point person for feedback on NYTimes' reporting. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/column/the-public-editor https://www.nytimes.com/column/the-public-editor
- brudgers 10y agoAn interesting idea. Conversely, the public editor could make an account here and defend the story. It would be an interesting read. Now as absurd as that might sound, that's probably something that would fall within the Public Editor's job description and that the Public Editor would be paid to do it. On the other hand, I'm not getting paid to improve the New York Times and the reporters and editors and so forth who are being paid, all felt the story was fine and dandy. So the odds that my efforts will change the institutional character of the New York Times are proportional to the degree to which it actively is soliciting my opinion...which it does not need to do since I have stated it here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jeffdavis 10y agoThe facts are not in yet; this is a developing story. We've seen at least a couple big cases where journalists were too quick to take a side, ended up very wrong, and lost a lot of credibility for themselves and future accusers. Restraint is warranted. That being said, the NYT needs to follow up after the drama dies down, and not just leave the final story as a footnote somewhere.
- dllthomas 10y ago> It repeats nearly all of Uber's public response verbatim rather than linking to it as it does with Fowler's article. A single paragraph was included verbatim. A >20 paragraph piece was linked. Similar amounts of text were included from both parties. It's not a great article, but this particular objection seems overstated.