5 ms·
I just don't get why smart people--even physicists!!--fall for this trap. AFAICT, Quantum mechanics adds no explanatory power to current theories of consciousne
by titzer 10y ago
I just don't get why smart people--even physicists!!--fall for this trap. AFAICT, Quantum mechanics adds no explanatory power to current theories of consciousness based on real, observable neurological phenomenon--like the quite obvious fact there is a huge neural network information processing system that is clearly doing the heavy lifting. No electrical activity, no consciousness. It's been shown over and over again. So what do the quantum superpositions add over mapping neural networks and simulating them? Does a quantum superposition of a single molecule somehow make the nodes of this neural network any more powerful or mysterious? Do they suddenly get a lot more storage capacity (the human brain is already estimated at 2.5pb just using neural connections)?
QM just doesn't add _any_ new explanations or make any predictions for consciousness. Until it does, or we meet something we really cannot explain, it does not make sense to obsess over it.
- Koshkin 10y agoQuantum Mechanics as a physical theory that describes behavior of particles, structure of atoms, etc. does not have much to say about behavior of larger molecules, let alone cells such as neurons, or their interactions. But at the core of the modern QM lies a mathematical theory that, unfortunately, only rarely is seen as something that is independent from the QM's concrete physical aspects. That theory is a kind of probability theory that is different from the one that we all know and love (or hate). It is exactly that difference that makes QM unreachable for our intuition. But as a mathematical framework it can be expected to be useful in describing behavior of some other systems that have nothing to do with Quantum Mechanics and which could possibly include mechanisms of consciousness.
- youdontknowtho 10y agoHow would that probabilistic model be applied to consciousness? Genuinely curious here. As far as I can tell, the definition of consciousness that Chalmers and others use doesn't seem to have measurable aspects.
- justifier 10y agoLook to the problems and limitations of nueral networks Local minima'maxima and the unyeildy nature of large numbers of nuerons are both currently being dealt with utilising probabilistic methods the mind functions on electrical signals and should be able to be understood through modeling This is the case regardless of where you stand on dualism
- youdontknowtho 10y agoThanks, that is a really good point.
- Koshkin 10y agoWell, Chalmers is a philosopher, and what philosophy does is it clarifies problems (which often creates more problems to clarify) rather than solves them... Whatever the exact definition, consciousness is a function of a living brain, a function required for the survival of an individual as a part of a group, and since the environment in which an individual operates is characterized by the high degree of uncerainty as to both its present state and especially its future, making decisions must involve probabilistic methods, and so must learning (because we all learn from our mistakes). The process of learning has a physical manifestation due to changes in the brain, which could be "measured," and if we assume the primacy of matter over function, we have to expect that the material substrate also must behave probabilistically. Which probability model is the best one in describing that behavior, remains an open question.
- youdontknowtho 10y agoSo, I agree with you completely that consciousness is a function of a living brain, where "living brain" is the physical substrate. I don't know if it follows that consciousness has to be probabilistic. The reason that I brought up Chalmers is that he, and others, will say that physical states don't map to subjective consciousness or qualia. Don't get me wrong, I'm much more of a "physicalist" in this regard. I'm not trained and I don't work in the field, but I can't help but think that humans overestimate the complexity and capabilities of consciousness. I think that there is a brain and, like you say, there is some function of it that results in consciousness. I think that we end up with a problem of definitions because the thing that Chalmers et al are describing, I think, doesn't exist. BUT if we are talking about the thing that Chalmers an co are talking about, then no...I don't see a way that you get to qualia and consciousness from protein. I'm kind of rambling. Sorry, it this isn't very coherent.
- chimprich 10y ago> Does a quantum superposition of a single molecule somehow make the nodes of this neural network any more powerful I think you meant this question to be rhetorical but I think this is a reasonable question to consider. It's speculation without evidence but it is interesting (to me) speculation. > Quantum mechanics adds no explanatory power Occam's Razor indicates that we should prefer the simplest explanation that explains a phenomenon. Unfortunately we don't have anything like a good explanation for consciousness so discarding hypotheses for not being simple enough isn't necessarily helpful. > No electrical activity, no consciousness. It seems that this is necessary, but that doesn't mean it is sufficient, to explain consciousness. > or we meet something we really cannot explain, it does not make sense to obsess over it. Like the hard problem of consciousness? This is something we really can't explain with our current level of knowledge (unless you are in the "there is no hard problem" camp). It may well be the case that consciousness can be explained within our current understanding of physics but given the uniqueness of the phenomenon it doesn't seem unreasonable to keep something of an open mind.
- titzer 10y ago> Like the hard problem of consciousness? This is something we really can't explain with our current level of knowledge (unless you are in the "there is no hard problem" camp). Yeah, I am with Dennett and the others that think the Hard Problem is basically made up. My thinking is pretty close to what Thomas W. Clark has written on the subject (http://www.naturalism.org/philosophy/consciousness/the-explanatory-gap); http://www.naturalism.org/philosophy/consciousness/the-expla... basically, that your consciousness and awareness actually _is_ the experience that your physical brain is having in response to stimuli and self-reflection.
- chimprich 10y agoI read your link, but I don't find Clark's argument terribly convincing. He writes in the conclusion: "If indeed qualia are identical to certain functional informational processes, then the hard problem of consciousness (what Chalmers more or less takes to be the easy problem) is the empirical one of discovering just what these processes are." But why should certain "functional informational processes" be a certain experience? Even if Clark is correct it doesn't seem to really explain anything. I'm not sure it's even scientific; is it at all testable? It seems to me that no one has come up with a good explanation of what consciousness is, or even made any sort of dent in the problem. Saying that consciousness is the physical experience of the brain, or that it's quantum mechanics, or it's an illusion or whatever are interesting guesses but they haven't led us anywhere.
- justifier 10y agoSpeculation of currently unknown theory leading to circular thinking to follow: Stead a direct link between qm and consciousness, as in protein strands exhibiting superposition, I think both utilise, and thus are consequence of, the same, or similar, underlying mathematics There are flaws in both that require probability for us to even get a glimpse of what is happening it is my intendeded inference that with a new mathematical model that solves high dimensional problem spaces we will understand both more For me qm and consciousness are intuitive evidence that p=np, but we will only be able to show that indirect relation when we have proven the math
- neutralid 10y ago> QM just doesn't add _any_ new explanations or make any predictions for consciousness. Until it does, or we meet something we really cannot explain, it does not make sense to obsess over it. As an aside, how would scientists develop/validate explanations for long-term behaviors, i.e., behaviors that occur over a longer period incrementally with low-energy processes? I think we're lucky to have have astronomical data to observe physics at logarithmic time scales, but I wonder about the general case of low-energy, long-term system behavior that may not exhibit itself in astronomy.
- corey_moncure 10y ago>So what do the quantum superpositions add over mapping neural networks and simulating them? https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ When I read your comment I immediately recalled this article about an experiment that designed tone discrimination circuits on FPGAs by stochastic processes (genetic algorithm). The highlight is that at the end of thousands of rounds of controlled evolution, the researchers obtained a circuit that achieved unexpected efficiency through mechanisms they initially failed to explain. There were closed circuits within the overall structure which only interacted with the main structure passively. Its design was the product of its unique electro-magnetic environment to the extent that results could not be replicated on another board of the same type. In other words, a circuit appeared to originate with properties that would not have been arrived at by applying the conventional theory of circuit design. Considering that organic brains are made up of many trillions of unit neurons, which grow into networks that will be trained by stochastic processes, it makes sense to expect them to exhibit a similar level of exploitation of their environment. If that environment is one in which quantum phenomena can result in real effects on the behavior of the system, why shouldn't we expect them to be exploited by real brains?
- Nomentatus 10y agoLong history of this - experts in physics becoming fools the moment they stray an inch or two from what they do in fact know. Heisenberg wrote a book in the realm of philosophy, which I've read because a Philosophy prof of mine handed it to me along with his yellowed and very negative published review. It was indeed excrement from start to end.