10 ms·
New Zealand Court Rules Kim Dotcom Can Be Extradited to U.S
- rihegher 10y agoBasically he won but lost anyway https://twitter.com/KimDotcom/status/833510769362825216 https://twitter.com/KimDotcom/status/833510769362825216
- wbhart 10y agoI watched quite a bit of the actual trial, which was livestreamed. The judge frequently pointed out that he knew his decision would be appealed, no matter what it was, and that it wasn't at all clear how to rectify the problem that the case presented. There were difficulties if it was sent either forward or back. Nobody wanted the case sent back to the district court, and there was no point him making a decision on everything and having his ruling tossed out in a higher court. What was clear throughout the case is that the New Zealand parliament had made its intention clear in the law that there was no such thing as criminal copyright infringement in New Zealand. In effect, the judge made the only sensible decision he could: uphold the intention of parliament and the law, and yet leave the case in a state that would allow Dotcom and company to appeal.
- philliphaydon 10y agoAs a Kiwi, I hope he wins the appeal! Everything the NZ government has done in regards to this entire case makes me embarrassed to be a kiwi.
- kogepathic 10y ago> Everything the NZ government has done in regards to this entire case makes me embarrassed Not a Kiwi, but I agree the NZ government has mishandled this situation from day 1. I don't think Kim Dotcom should be extradited to the US. The way this was handled just reeks of judicial overreach by the Americans. But, from everything that I've read, and what I've seen on his Twitter, Kim Dotcom is not someone I would want to be friends with. In general he seems to be a bit of a scumbag. He likes the law, but only when it's in his favour. He even tried to finance a NZ political party, which failed spectacularly. [0] If the Americans are intent to prove a point that he's a criminal, instead of trying to get him for copyright violations (which judges have repeatedly shown don't apply in NZ), they could always chose to hit him for money laundering which is a crime in NZ. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom#Dotcom.27s_involvement_in_New_Zealand_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom#Dotcom.27s_involvem...
- sjwright 10y agoIt makes sense that we want to see someone get a fair hearing in court, even if we didn't particularly like them. If I ever find myself in a similar position, I would want judicial fairness in my case too. I am reminded of a quote from the film The Contender (2000) "Principles only mean something when you stick to them when its inconvenient."
- icu 10y agoI echo your sentiment, however after being called into jury service in New Zealand, I was dismayed to discover first hand that the probability of a fair hearing in court is based on the degree to which you can afford a defence. My perspective now is to avoid legal problems at nearly any cost, but to also advocate for understanding, respect--and when necessary--defence of the Law. To give an example, I believe Trey Gowdy (the U.S. Representative) is a shining example of this approach and if you are interested I would recommend watching a few of his speeches on YouTube.
- toyg 10y agoErnesto Miranda, of "Miranda rights" fame, wasn't a particularly savoury character either. You really demonstrate your adherence to principles and the rule of law when you apply them fairly to people you don't like.
- literallycancer 10y ago>He likes the law, but only when it's in his favour. Would you expect a rational actor to like the law when it's against them? >He even tried to finance a NZ political party, which failed spectacularly. How is trying to start a political party is controversial at all? In the 2014 general election, the joint Internet Party and Mana Movement gained 1.42% of the nationwide party vote but failed to win any seats. This isn't even a spectacular failure tbqh, many small parties don't get over the seat limit in their first few elections. In fact, I've only ever seen political parties do well in their first election when they were funded by extremely rich businessmen (meaning billions in net worth).
- 10y ago
- xupybd 10y agoYeah, I'm not a fan of Kim. I think mega crossed the line by incentivising popular content. But also as a Kiwi I don't think that the NZ government acted within its own laws in this case. Especially when they raided Kim's mansion.
- tankenmate 10y agoAnd even more so by handing over the hard drives to the FBI without proper authority or judicial review.
- wbhart 10y agoNew Zealand law has a principle known as natural justice. It's a term that refers to the right to a trial that is fair when considered in totality, and the right to have a judge that is not biased. It was argued by Dotcom's team and the legal team of his coaccused that the District court judge had hurried the trial so much that there was no opportunity to even present a case. He wasn't allowed to present expert testimony on the commonplace practice of using deduplication in filesharing technology, or expert testimony on US law, etc. The question came up in the trial that if natural justice had been so badly denied, then it wasn't clear how the problem could be rectified. Evidence came to light during the trial before this judge that largely discredited the Crown case, but wasn't properly before the judge (wasn't allowed to be considered), further compounding the problem the case presented. The Crown Prosecution Service of course argued that Dotcom and co would have the opportunity to present such evidence in the US after being extradited.
- wallace_f 10y agoYour points reveal the nature of NZ how I found it after living there. It is a nation of well-mannered, and sometimes incredibly friend people, yet with far-more-corrupt-than-you-would-imagine institutions. They have the highest per-capita War on Drugs in the world that includes selectively-enforced laws and no progress on the harmful impact to society of drug abuse. Yet with all that money spent on law enforcement, one at a hostel who was mugged could not even get police to investigate the crime. NZ ranked as the #1 least corrupt place in the world is some major bullshit. They have government-sanctioned monopolies in everything from office property to ski resorts. Telecom industry is even more of a joke than Australia or US. Nowhere else in the Western world have I seen such a disgusting display of sex workers as I did in NZ. Of people mugged and beaten up for no reason. Of overt racism. However, there's also some of the nicest people in the world there, and it is a beautiful country. Anyways, Kim Dotcom's case just adds to the list of bullshit to what should otherwise be a utopia.
- kefka 10y ago> NZ ranked as the #1 least corrupt place in the world is some major bullshit. Or that the ratings are so corrupted to portray this place as a bastion of corruptlessness.
- jonathanstrange 10y agoI don't understand how civilized countries can even consider extraditing anyone to the US in light of the known deficiencies of the US justice and prison system. I don't know about NZ, but for example in Germany the maximum sentence for intentional, commercial copyright infringement is 5 years, whereas in the US it seems to be a life-long confinement in some federal maximum security prison where apparently inmates are sometimes even raped - or so, I've heard, quite shocking if that's true. Moreover, this guy has never set a foot inside the US, and the US do often not extradite people for much more serious crimes. On top of that, many federal US prisons violate basic human rights, as even some US experts occasionally admit. For example, Marion prison in Colorado was on a permanent lockdown for 23 years, because two prison guards were killed.[1] That means that all inmates were in strict solitary confinement for 23 years, no matter whether they had anything to do with these murders or not. NZ should offer the US to sue Doctcom in New Zealand or wherever his company resided in. He can then spend a few years in prison, if he's really guilty, and justice is served. [1] http://www.slate.com/blogs/crime/2013/10/23/marion_prison_lockdown_thomas_silverstein_how_a_1983_murder_created_america.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/crime/2013/10/23/marion_prison_lo...
- tellarin 10y agoI agree that the US prison system has many human rights issues, but Kim's extradition was approved due to the fraud and racketeering charges, not due to the copyright infringement accusations. No idea how it works if he's extradited and the US tries to prosecute him for the copyright infringement cases though.
- shambolic 10y agoThe fraud and racketeering charges are a sham, manufactured to work around the non-extraditable copyright infringement charges.
- rndgermandude 10y ago"He [NZ Judge David Harvey] also confirmed that the charges in the indictment relating to money laundering, racketeering and wire fraud are not separate criminal acts but dependent on the claim of criminal secondary copyright infringement." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megaupload_legal_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megaupload_legal_case which links the actual legal documents
- rubyfan 10y agoCan anyone explain the concept where a foreign person can commit an act on foreign soil and be considered that the U.S. has jurisdiction to charge them with a crime? How is that possible?
- type0 10y agoBecause, Team America World Police, that's how.
- ikeboy 10y agohttp://www.kktg.net/Notes/hacking-jurisdiction/ http://www.kktg.net/Notes/hacking-jurisdiction/
- oh_sigh 10y agoBecause NZ agreed to extradition terms with the US. If they hadn't done that, then the US could try him in absentia but good luck enforcing it.
- csomar 10y agoPlanning a terrorist act that will happen in the US?
- megous 10y agoThat does not create a jurisdiction to charge someone. Just a justification (in the eyes of US citizens) to kill them straight away.
- freehunter 10y ago>Just a justification (in the eyes of US citizens) to kill them straight away. You mean the eyes of the US government. The citizens aren't out there killing foreign nationals. Saying US citizens are responsible for extra-judicial killings is like saying Muslims are responsible for terrorist attacks. It's wrong and it's offensive.
- 10y ago
- Zorlag 10y agoI recall getting a letter from megaupload a couple of years ago after I downloaded Firefox through their services "for free", asking me to pay some bullshit amount of money. Somehow they got their download link on top of all the others in Google. Did not pay because it was clearly a fraud. Many paid though. Later they busted the operation. In Germany that was. That's my share on Kim Dotcom. Filesharing is fine but the dude is a criminal trying to rationalize his deeds to evade punishment.
- skilled 10y agoIt would help if you could back your claims. Were the Mozilla servers down that you couldn't get it from an official source?
- freehunter 10y agoYears ago Firefox used to have a disclaimer of "Only use this software from official sources, you should never pay money for this software" kind of thing, because that practice happened all the time. Companies made money reselling Firefox to people who didn't know any better or weren't paying attention. No idea if Megaupload was responsible or not, but it was certainly a popular fraud.
- undersuit 10y ago>I recall getting a letter Prove it please. They mailed you? That letter would be a fine piece of evidence to back up this improbable story on the internet. >Later they busted the operation. In Germany that was. OOOOH, that looks like more evidence you could provide, maybe a link to a news story even if it is in German.
- coldcode 10y agoNote that he can't be extradited for copyright infringement, but they allowing it for fraud, which makes no sense.
- d--b 10y agoAm I the only one to think he had it coming? I mean, the guy publicly boasts to have made hundreds of millions of dollars ripping off the entertainment industry. The US wouldn't be so aggressive if the guy hadn't been in hiding and taunting them for years. As far as I know, Sean Parker didn't go to jail over Napster...
- tptacek 10y agoNo, you are not. But Schmitz's outcome is not going to be the same as Sean Parker's.
- d--b 10y agoSure, but that's only because he clearly violated a lot of laws and fled instead of facing trial. I am surprised that most people here seem offended by NZ's decision. The guy's clearly a thief, he got a lot of money from people who wanted to watch TV shows, while he didn't make those shows. If someone stole my stuff, fled to NZ and bragged about it online, I'd be pretty pissed too, and surely I'd like the guy to be extradited.
- syshum 10y ago>>and fled instead of facing trial. Where did he flee to? Megaupload was started when he lived in NZ, was shutdown when he lived in NZ, and as far as I am aware he still lives in NZ. So where you do you that he fled somewhere? >I am surprised that most people here seem offended by NZ's decision. That is because clearly you do not value due process >The guy's clearly a thief That is not clear to me, of course I also reject the very idea of "Intellectual privilege" and do not believe a download is the equivalent of theft. Which by the way is the factual legal position as well, because when you infringe on copyright, you do not "steal" you infringe. >If someone stole my stuff, What did he steal, I have seen no complaints, or charges in regards to theft. Copyright infringement sure. But that is not theft >fled to NZ he did not flee to NZ,
- undefined0 10y ago
- contingencies 10y agoFirst, they came for the hackers. Yes, I am a criminal. My crime is that of curiosity. My crime is that of judging people by what they say and think, not what they look like. My crime is that of outsmarting you, something that you will never forgive me for. - The Mentor, The Hacker Manifesto (1986) The internet and the hacker community, much like New Zealand, were built on sharing, which we know to be a net good. Despite character failings and profiteering - the political ramifications of Mega clearly gave Kim an enjoyment that many of us (especially those of us living in or exposed to the developing world, or who made our start in computing through piracy) can and should empathise with, which clearly demonstrates that his motivation exceeded that of profit. I would argue, therefore, that Kim is one of us, and that we owe him our heartfelt - if conditional - support. While Kim - like many of us - is certainly a fallible and occasionally (quaintly) antagonistic character, if humans are to stand any chance of solving the more pressing issues of the planet what we need is transparency and legitimate cross-border community, not "with-us-or-against-us" rhetoric out of the 1950s (via the cold war). Despite the international media saga of Kim vs. USA, Kim fundamentally wins hands down on the big picture (eg. not wielding an army of drone-assassins with a stated 'whole planet, intra-minutes death-dealing' goal, not producing and exporting torture equipment, etc...). The whole MPAA/US argument basically rests on the allegation of lost profits... as if commercial exploitation of the entire planet's population is some kind of global, monocultural, border-free given. Frankly I don't know what's more offensive: the assumption, or the methodology. I'm more willing to risk imprisonment (or any other negative outcome) personally than I am willing to risk the curtailment of my intellectual freedom and that of those around me who I care for equally as I do for myself. - Edward Snowden, NSA whistleblower
- microtherion 10y ago> I would argue, therefore, that Kim is one of us, and that we owe him our heartfelt - if conditional - support. Kim Dotcom is a career criminal. Having been convicted (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom#Investigations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Dotcom#Investigations) of dealing in stolen phone cards, insider trading, embezzlement, and Ponzi schemes, he finally figured out that ripping off musicians is one profitable crime widely condoned in society.
- elliottkember 10y agoI am from New Zealand, and I had a friend who was working for Kim Dotcom leading up to the time of the raid. I never got close enough to actually see anything, but just from the stories I heard I was deeply suspicious. It didn't sound like much was done "by the book", people were paid in cash, stuff was hushed up... it all seemed really, really shady. At the time, Dotcom was loathed by his neighbours in Coatesville for driving sports cars really fast around the area, scaring people on horseback, antagonizing the neighbours, and generally being an asshole. I met a few of them once and they all had the same opinion - they just didn't want this guy around any more. Since the raid he's been on a PR kick, including releasing an album called "Good Times" with pictures of his face holding a flower all over buses around the country: https://www.nbr.co.nz/sites/default/files/story_imgs/BeZ4ZHwCAAAigLt.jpg https://www.nbr.co.nz/sites/default/files/story_imgs/BeZ4ZHw... I don't know nearly enough about the by-the-book legality of what was happening with Megaupload. But to your average Kiwi he's a bit of a disingenuous prick with enough talk of criminal bullshit to make him unpopular. Our small island nation's culture is precious to us.
- metaphorm 10y ago> Our small island nation's culture is precious to us. Peter Thiel...
- djsumdog 10y agoHis debate with John Key was spectacular though: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ZcFQOOwjTE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ZcFQOOwjTE ..and he did organize the broadcast with the Internet/Mana Party, Snowden and Assange. That CD of his, terrible. So terrible. "oh the good good life," fuck it's stuck in my head now. Sure he's a huge asshole. The American film industry is worse. The MPAA has a lot of pull in NZ because of all the contracts that go from Hollywood to Wetta. Regardless of what you think of Kim Dotcom personally, the way his assets were seized and this whole process carried out should be of great concern to all Kiwis because of the far reaching legal implications. Remember, the GCSB bill that allowed spying was just making legal what the government was already doing. The original spying on Kim Dotcom was totally illegal, and no one is in jail for it.
- appleflaxen 10y ago
- iknowyoukimdotc 10y agoThere is more to this story. Kim Dotcom didn't made his money with megaupload. He made his money hacking companies around the year 2000 and threatening them to release the information to competitors or the public if they didn't pay without X amount of time. This is payback time and Kim Dotcom knows it.