3 ms·
> So we celebrate paying our taxes, because we're helping the thing that makes us money. So why doesn't Amazon and it's ilk? Because they have competitors who
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> So we celebrate paying our taxes, because we're helping the thing that makes us money. So why doesn't Amazon and it's ilk?
Because they have competitors who don't and it isn't reasonable to compete with them on uneven terms.
The problem isn't corporations paying no taxes by following the law, the problem is that the law allows them to pay no taxes.
The shell game is very simple in principle. Microsoft Offshore owns the copyright to Office. When Microsoft US sells a copy of Office, they collect money from the customer and then pay Microsoft Offshore almost that much for the right to sell it, so Microsoft US makes no profit.
The solution is equally simple. Replace corporate income tax with VAT. Then when Microsoft US sells a copy of Office, they pay VAT on the full purchase price and can deduct any US VAT already paid. Since Microsoft Offshore doesn't pay US VAT there is nothing to deduct and they have to pay their taxes.
Though Amazon in particular is actually a different case -- they don't pay taxes because they spend all their revenue expanding their business. They're not diverting profits offshore, they legitimately don't have any. This is completely unproblematic and meritorious, because as long as it continues they're creating jobs and growing the economy, and the instant they stop and actually turn a profit they owe taxes.