2 ms·
> or example at Chase Bank, if a poor person lets the balance drop below $500, they will be charged $30. How on earth is that legal? I understand that there ar
by mschuster91 10y ago
> or example at Chase Bank, if a poor person lets the balance drop below $500, they will be charged $30.
How on earth is that legal? I understand that there are overdraft fees or that the banks want interest on the debt if your account goes negative, and that's fine when those fees are not predatory.
But fining people for having too low positive cash balance?! That's theft.
- jasode 10y ago>But fining people for having too low positive cash balance?! That's theft. I just used casual shorthand when I wrote "charged $30". The way the bank's Terms of Agreement spells it out is that every account has a monthly service fee -- e.g. $30. However, if you maintain a minimum balance above $500, they will waive that fee. (Many in the HN demographic would have a higher tier account such as "Premiere/Preferred/Platinum" and those also have minimum balances of $20000 required to waive the monthly service fees. It's still the same idea, but a bigger number.) The banks word it in positive terms ("above/waive"). I just wrote it the opposite way ("below/charge") to match how people psychologically perceive it. For many people seeing the minus-$30 deducted from their account, it certainly feels like a penalty/fine instead of a +$30 bonus for all the other months that they were above $500.
- mschuster91 10y agoWhoa, that's still theft, even if you explain it this way. My bank (Sparkasse), for example, charges 8€ a month and that's already perceived as "near to extortion" - and the increase to 8€ actually led to massive public outrage. Many "direct banks" (i.e. banks without physical offices, services via ATMs and Internet only) are entirely free here.