3 ms·
I normally find Gates to be pretty sensible but I fail to see how this is a good idea. Isn't impossible to avoid that by extension any machine must be taxed bec
by alkonaut 10y ago
I normally find Gates to be pretty sensible but I fail to see how this is a good idea. Isn't impossible to avoid that by extension any machine must be taxed because robots are after all machines? Otherwise, who is to say which 5-axis milling machine is a robot and which isn't?
Why not just tax the things we have always taxed (income, profits, purchases, wealth, pollution, ..) and do so in a way that lets everyone enjoy any wealth created by robot automation? That's what we did last time (industrialization).
If all labor is replaced by robots that must be a good thing. Solving the redistribution of wealth and work is the easy problem here.
- bobwaycott 10y agoThe simplest thing to consider is what kind of revenue will be collected as far fewer people earn income and, as a consequence, purchase fewer goods and services. These things require jobs and income.
- alkonaut 10y agothey just require the same amount of wealth to be created and redistributed. If a factory that used to employ 100 now employs 1 robot the taxes need to be the same (so higher taxation, since now those taxes come only from the corporate taxes plus income/wealth of owners of the factory and people who make robots and not income/payroll of employees. These taxes now basically have to finance universal income as well as the roads/schools it used to fund). But I don't see the problem with having the same taxation given that the same value is created. Potential problems I see are only international when huge taxes on wealth or corporate profits cause people and corporations to move - but that should be solvable too. Rather - it will be possible in countries that accept a system of massive redistributive taxes.