7 ms·
Why check-cashing stores are a good deal, according to a UPenn professor
- mindslight 10y agoObviously patronizing these stores makes sense to their customers. The true criticism has always been about the conditions that lead to them making sense. This "revelation" indicates more about the professor's amazement at toning down her own paternalism than any economic discovery!
- afarrell 10y ago> Outsiders may think the signage at a check casher — resembling that of a fast-food menu — is gauche compared with simple, polished interiors of their local bank branch. But that's a feature, not a bug. Of course. It reduces the cognitive cost of using your service. All else being equal, doing that is going to make your service better. Of course, doing that may make you look uncool as the article alludes to.
- caseysoftware 10y agoNo kidding. I just did a handful of financial transactions and at every step of the way, every bank said "oh, in terms of disclosure, there's a $X fee attached to that" where X was $10-30 each time. Nowhere was that documented until I started the process. I was able to push back and get all except one dropped (and that was halved) but unless you're used to saying "no," they would have gotten me for another $60. That much isn't going to make or break the vast majority of people here but we're outliers in many ways.
- valuearb 10y agoThe anti-check cashing and payday loans movements have always been somewhat patronizing. People have different needs and sometimes it's worthwhile to pay extra fees to access money quickly, or get short term loans. Rarely in the rants against these services do I read any discussion or analysis of why the customers use them, and what their other options would be without them.
- caseysoftware 10y agoOddly, the people who claim to care the most, don't want to apply some empathy and try to understand..
- michaelchisari 10y agoIsn't the argument not to get rid of check cashing, but to provide it as a highly regulated, low cost service of the Post Office? http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-post-office-banking-20160102-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-post-office-banking-20...
- twblalock 10y agoPostal bank accounts are a pretty old idea. The US used to have them, and a lot of other countries still do. I suppose the US got rid of postal bank accounts before check cashing places were common, but I think proponents of reintroducing postal bank accounts need to explain why the poor would prefer them to the services they currently use. Such an answer needs to take into account the possibility that many poor people might be willing to pay a fee to avoid contact with a government agency, which many people believe the postal service to be (even though it isn't anymore).
- Cyphase 10y ago> .. a government agency, which many people believe the postal service to be (even though it isn't anymore). Can you clarify/defend this? I realize the USPS is not a government agency in the usual sense (it's an "independent agency of the United States government"), but I don't think it's accurate to say that it's not a government agency. Specifically: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Postal_Service#Governance_and_organization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Postal_Service#G...
- twblalock 10y agoIt's effectively independent. The postal service is not going to bust you for violating parole, put your welfare checks in jeopardy, or ask you about your immigration status. But a lot of poor people avoid contact with government because they fear those things will happen, and a lot of them may not understand that the postal service is different.
- jasode 10y agoThe article's title promises a provocative contrarian view but it turns out that the UPenn professor is only "right" in a narrow sense that the criticizers of "payday lenders" are not even talking about. To the professors point... yes, a traditional bank's service fees can exceed the fees at check cashing stores. For example at Chase Bank, if a poor person lets the balance drop below $500, they will be charged $30. (To many of us, $500 doesn't sound like much but to people living paycheck-to-paycheck, it can be very hard to stay above that amount every month.) Account holders on the lower tier also get limited check writing privileges. Some account fee waivers also don't kick in unless their paychecks are direct deposit. However, many laborers still get paper paychecks so they can't meet the bank's criteria for the reduced fees. The criticism that the professor's math doesn't tackle is the ~400% interest rates on payday loans: http://www.paydayloaninfo.org/facts http://www.paydayloaninfo.org/facts Yes, $0.89 money order at RiteCheck is less than $5 charged by Chase Bank but that's not what the criticism of predatory practices is about.
- ghufran_syed 10y agoI once ran out of cash when driving across the country with my family, because the bank froze my account 2 days after supposedly clearing a check and telling me I had access to my funds. My bank told me it might take up to two weeks to get access to my funds. I would have been much better going to a check cashing place, because of their clarity and transparency. I almost ended up having to sleep with my kids in the car, or in a park somewhere, but we managed to find a pawn shop that was open 24 hours. We paid around $60 to borrow $1000 for two weeks, which is a high rate compared to a regular bank loan if you can get one. But it was the difference between my kids sleeping in a hotel and being homeless. People who want to shut down these kind of services have good intentions, but the effect of their paternalism would be to reduce choice for poor people, and make their lives worse.
- waqf 10y agoCredit cards seem tailor-made for this case, because they give you four weeks or so interest free and then start with the usurious rates.
- 10y ago
- twblalock 10y agoI remember this professor's articles on this subject from around five years ago. I suspect this is in the news again because she published a book this January. It's not hard for me to see why poor people would prefer check-cashing services to banks. I'm nowhere close to poor, and I've had to get my bank to reverse fees they should not have charged me on a number of occasions. I was also a Wells Fargo customer during the period of the fake account scandal. On top of all of that, I was the beneficiary of a class action against Wells Fargo because they used to order deposits and withdrawals in the way that would maximize their overdraft fees. I overdrafted once when I was in college in a way that would be impossible today because the bank changed the order of my transactions, and I got stuck with overdraft fees of a few hundred dollars. If I had been truly poor, I would not have been able to make my rent that month. In most of these cases, I had to persistently call my bank and speak to multiple people to resolve the problem. I'm socialized into the middle class because of my upbringing, so I can pull that off -- many poor people can't. Being able to deal with government and businesses in this way is part of the intangible cultural capital that most poor people don't have. This is one of the reasons poor neighborhoods get better services when they gentrify -- the well-off newcomers know how to get things done.
- skookumchuck 10y agoThis has happened to me as well. What I do is go to the bank and sit down with the manager, and push until I get those fees reversed. Going in person is much more effective than calling on the phone, and the manager will just fix it to get you out of his hair.
- twblalock 10y agoIf you dress or talk like the kind of people who use check cashing stores, the manager is likely to call security and have you removed.
- skookumchuck 10y agoI dress in t-shirt and jeans. Of course, one does need to talk in a polite manner. Walking in with an abusive and abrasive manner won't get results.
- Pxtl 10y agoCarlos needs a credit card. If he's got a $5k checque in hand and needs to buy materials, depositing it in a proper checking account and using a credit card would be far less fees, even if he has to pay transaction fees on that bank account when it comes time to pay off the card. The downfall is when expenses come up that he can't pay on plastic if he's under his bank account's transaction-free level. Paying subcontractors, buying exotic or used materials and equipment, etc.
- mschuster91 10y agoIn Germany, one can't get a credit card without a good credit rating, and even then it's mostly the "pay in full after a month, or else" type. Carlos could not get a CC here, I'd guess.
- ada1981 10y agoThis feels icky; she focused on the check cashing fees, which my guess is a loss leader for the payday loans they really want to offer people.. no mention of that anywhere in the article.. is it possible this place didn't offer loans, just check cashing???
- raverbashing 10y agoBanking fees in the US (and Canada) are extortionate Not to mention all the BS about banks making sure they credit last and debit first, causing accounts to overdraft (and more extortionate fees on top of that) They like you if you can keep > some k$ in your account per month, if that's not the case you're being explored. Funny thing is that it seems the avg "fee" obtained by the bank (let's say, it's around 5% of money of your minimum balance per year - so if the minimum balance is 1k, this is $50 p.y.) is higher if you're a paying customer (that is, one with a lower balance) as opposed to a "no fees" customer
- Veratyr 10y ago"Check" cashing shouldn't even exist. Most of the western world has functional electronic transfers and bank accounts with no minimum fees. At home in Australia, all it took for anyone in the country to send me any amount of money within around a business day (soon instantly) and for free was two numbers: my BSB (bank branch number) and account number. Getting a bank account was essentially free (no fees if you deposit at least $2k/month or are under 18, a student or qualify for low income government benefits) and as a result pretty much everyone had them and used them. I'd actually only seen a "check" once in my life and it came from my grandmother. Employers, friends, parents, everything really was electronic. The US for some reason is way behind the rest of the world here. The answer isn't to force people into the ancient and backwards banking system, it's to update it so that they can and want to use it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- callmeed 10y agoThe US has a very large population of people known as the "unbanked" who cannot/will not get a bank account. Reasons include immigration/ID status, history of writing bad checks, bank levy, etc. They must use check cashing services, pre-paid debit cards, etc-often with high fees. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbanked https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbanked
- Veratyr 10y ago> Reasons include immigration/ID status, history of writing bad checks, bank levy, etc. The first can be a legitimate issue (though your link says the majority of the unbanked are American-born), the last two should be resolvable by modernizing the banking system by removing the outdated checking system entirely and offering basic accounts without fees/minimums (at least to low income individuals), bringing the system in line with the rest of the civilized world.