4 ms·
The problem with anything but free speech is this: who decides what is "extreme"? I heard from many news sources that a Trump victory was extremely unlikely. I
by paulddraper 10y ago
The problem with anything but free speech is this: who decides what is "extreme"?
I heard from many news sources that a Trump victory was extremely unlikely. It turns out they were peddling falsehood.
I would be scared if what was legally permissable was limited to the conceptions and misconceptions of currently "mainstream" sources.
- guelo 10y agoAn incorrect prediction is not a falsehood.
- paulddraper 10y agoIt's partially false. If I say there's a 99% of a meteor strike, and it doesn't happen, I'm 99% incorrect.
- schoen 10y agoIs this possibly a form of Bayesian vs. frequentist debate? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Probability_interpretations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Probability_interpretations
- jhbadger 10y agoNo, you aren't -- you may have a perfect model of meteor strikes for all I know, and the 1% miss is exactly accurate. That's how statistical models work, whether of meteors or elections. Of course, if you say there's a 99% chance again and again and they are all misses, people rightfully have a case to doubt your model.
- fatbird 10y agoThe linked essay, in describing Mill's argument, carefully makes the point that free speech beyond legality matters. It's not just what's protected from interference by the government, it's what's allowed by consensus, by social pressure, by available platforms, and by circumstance; these aspects can all have a practical effect of allowing or denying someone's freedom of expression. Also, freedom of speech isn't a binary condition. As a practical matter, we're always balancing our attempt to maximize freedom against constraints required to continue to exist. Reddit, despite taking a radical freedom of speech line, won't allow child porn, but they also won't allow doxxing or incitement, which is their rationale for banning certain massively racist groups and not others. They've also woken up to the fact that certain very extreme subreddits threaten their long-term viability because people simply won't use Reddit while that association persists. Violentacrez was tolerated and encouraged right up until he became an existential liability.