12 ms·
'Acting Wife': Marriage Market Incentives and Labor Market Investments
- Clubber 10y agoWomen have been trained to be a timid, subservient partner to men for a millennia, and it's hard to get away from. The answer is the same for women and men: know your value, constantly strive to improve your value, and command that you get paid your value. Also, know your interaction with business is just that, business. Be more willing to cut a business relationship than a personal one. Don't blame yourself if someone doesn't see your value, just find someone who does. Disclosure: My wife is also a programmer.
- Chris2048 10y ago> it's hard to get away from Could have fooled me, many western women lean towards tsundere...
- arjie 10y agoThe set is so large and our sampling so biased that I doubt any of us can conclude anything based off our personal experiences.
- chongli 10y ago> it's hard to get away from Could have fooled me, many western women lean towards tsundere... These two properties are not incompatible.
- Chris2048 10y agofull quote: > Women have been trained to be a timid, subservient partner to men for a millennia, and it's hard to get away from suggests most women are "timid, subservient", which is not compatible with "many western women lean towards tsundere".
- khazhou 10y agoFor the benefit of people who don't have "tsundere" in their daily vocabulary like Chris2048: "Tsundere (ツンデレ?, pronounced [tsɯndeɽe]) is a Japanese term for a character development process that describes a person who is initially cold and even hostile towards another person before gradually showing a warmer side over time. The word is derived from the terms tsun tsun (ツンツン?), meaning to turn away in disgust, and dere dere (デレデレ?) meaning to become 'lovey dovey'. Originally found in Japanese bishōjo games, the word is now part of the otaku moe phenomenon, reaching into other media such as maid cafes, anime, manga, novels, and even mass media. The term was made popular in the visual novel Kimi ga Nozomu Eien."
- Chris2048 10y agoNot everyone has it in their vocabulary, but everyone has google in their tool-set...
- Kenji 10y agoMay I offer a counterpoint? In the current climate in western culture, it's more like women know exactly what they want and how to demand it, the problem is more that it is given to them without challenging them enough, thus preventing personal and professional growth. Right now, I get to witness how a coworker has to give private lessons to students in the evenings, beside working 100% as a software engineer, because he is forced to pay for the life of his ex-wife who moved in with her new boyfriend. He is financially ruined and barely able to make ends meet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- the_realist 10y agoYou can offer counterpoints in the voting booth. The Internet is taboo.
- Kenji 10y agoI can often estimate what HN's reaction will be to my comments and whether or not I get downvoted. However, I think it is of utmost importance not to censor myself and also spell out unpopular things that I am convinced of, even if it means that I am bleeding karma. It means I have challenged someone's opinion and they did not like it. That actually means that my message achieved its goal.
- j2kun 10y agoThis story is not realistic enough to be credible, nor is it reasonable evidence as a counterpoint. "Pay for the life of his ex-wife"? What does that even mean? Is it court-ordered alimony? I can hardly believe a judge would order alimony that is "financially ruinous" for either party, and if it is the case your coworker can appeal the judgement. Even if your story were true, it has nothing to do with the climate of western culture, nor is it reasonable to extract a broad judgement of women from this anecdote. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it also seems from your comment that you don't personally know the woman whose intentions you're inferring (from the evidence of a biased party).
- dominotw 10y ago>have been trained seems to be the crux of modern gender wars.
- devoply 10y agoIt's hard to say things about an entire group for 3.5 billion humans. Evolution has some stuff to do with it. Everything is not rhetorical.
- Chris2048 10y ago> t's hard to say things about an entire group for 3.5 billion humans I've not met all humans, yet I believe most (>95%) have two arms and two legs. Is this not a reasonable belief?
- mirimir 10y agoI'd say that the "timid, subservient" bit is mostly an illusion and male fantasy ;) It is true that women, in many cultures, were trained to focus on family and reproduction. And men were encouraged to "do great things". And to die in wars :( Maybe there's some biological basis for that. But mostly, I think, it was just historical accident. Driven by technological limitations, perhaps. And for sure, it's all in flux now :)
- guard-of-terra 10y agoMen are twice as stronger on certain operations - for example, grip by hand. That's a lot of biological basis, which nevertheless is much less relevant today.
- mirimir 10y agoYes, that's why I said "technological limitations".
- VodkaHaze 10y agoI don't think it's a male fantasy. I also don't think it's biological. Just look at how women and men are socialized from a young age. Example: up until recently, many young girls in the west grew up on Disney princesses. Rewatch the movies, and pay attention to the female protagonists in those movies being active vs passive agents. Most are passive -- they're simply dealt a series of events (which generally happen only because they are beautiful or otherwise intrinsically valuable, not because of how they act). Being exposed to those narratives from a very young age surely has an effect on identity, personality formation, etc.
- mirimir 10y agoYes. I totally agree. I was arguing that how societies got to that point, over the past few millennia, was an historical accident. Or a series of accidents. There have been matriarchal cultures, for sure. With modern military technology, there's arguably no reason why they couldn't become dominant. But just a few decades ago, there was.
- elindbe2 10y agoIf that's the case then why do married women not change their responses? If it's just a matter of "training" then why would getting married affect the answers? A simpler explanation is that single women realize that the type of men they would like to attract tend to prefer more feminine women. Married women don't have to care since they're not trying to attract a man. Now sure, no woman should be forced to care about being feminine. Nor should she be forced to care about beauty or any other traits that the men she wishes to attract like. But at the same time, men shouldn't be forced to like any certain person either and if they happen to favor more feminine women, then that's 100% their choice to make.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoWow, your post was dead (I vouched it), but you are exactly right. Everyone in this thread is missing the point. Shocking to see the one scientifically valid interpretation of the article downvoted below threadshold. I thought we were pro-science on HN? If women were just "choosing" to approach their career in a different way, or had just been brainwashed, then they would react the same regardless of who is around. What this study shows is that single women expect single men to react badly to their ambition. Not that the women actually have less ambition. Yet so many in this thread are discussing this as if it's evidence that women have different inclinations. Incredible confirmation bias.
- Chris2048 10y agoToo culturally dependant. I, to some degree, have to push my (female) partner to be more ambitious. She has no problem being assertive otherwise...
- u_wot_m8 10y agoI wouldn't say "trained", I would say evolutionarily selected. Sexually dimorphic phenotypes and differences in IQ distribution show this.
- CryoLogic 10y agoIn my experience, it is deathly hard to meet ambitious women. I've known many ambitious men, but women in my experience seem to lack the desire to really go all out in their careers. I am sure there are biological factors, including variations in androgenic hormones etc. But I do believe it is largely cultural and this study matches what I've seen in my own life quite closely. This is unfortunate because I am attracted to more ambitious women.
- tsunamifury 10y agoIt's actually quite easy to meet ambitious women in a major city. I mean, realistically, they are so ambitious they probably neither have the time nor need to meet you.
- dajohnson89 10y agoCan confirm, living in DC.
- sokoloff 10y agoI had a direct report for years. She was very smart, capable, effective, and a great thinking partner on my leadership team. She also got an unfair (IMO) amount of blowback from her interactions with other leaders. "Rough", "abrasive", "difficult" were the common labels. While there were things she may have done differently, I don't think I'd have seen the same blowback from an identically-acting male leader. I suspect that her experience is common and that if it's gender biased (I think it is), this continual molding could tend to create the outcomes you observe. Thought experiment: How often do we tell young girls "Don't be so bossy" as compared to how often we say that to young boys? Or "Imagine that you just heard a mom tell her kid, 'Don't be so bossy!' What gender is the child that she is addressing?"
- jjoonathan 10y ago> How often do we tell young girls "Don't be so bossy" I can't say, but every time I wind up watching a children's show targeted at girls (usually in a lobby or exercise room), the protagonists are all highly assertive and there's often heavy-handed promotion of the subtext "boys are dumb and useless and it's OK to be a complete asshole to them if it gets you what you want."
- notadoc 10y agoYou'd probably get different answers if you didn't study MBA students.
- jcoffland 10y agoI think the assumption is that MBA students are more ambitious than normal. Students often choose the MBA degree because they are unsure what they really want to do. An MBA is seen as a generally useful degree which could lead to a high paying job in many different fields. Limiting the study to students who had made that choice, for whatever reason, could very well have an effect on the study's outcome.
- ben_jones 10y agoI fear instead the MBA and post-undergrad route has become the new "safe way to go". Extend your student loans, stay with your friends from college, keep going out on the weekends, keep a relative life of leisure (subjective, the course loads of some people are egregiously harder then others but from what I've seen it tends to be similar to undergrad for most).
- notadoc 10y agoSo why not study medical students? You'd get vastly different responses.
- jcoffland 10y agoMaybe.
- tabeth 10y agoI don't have access to the full paper, but I'm surprised to see that there's no definition of "ambitious." Is it ambitious to want to start a company or to want to raise children successfully? Perhaps women have a different definition of "ambitious", therefore men are trying to hold up women to their standard.
- BurningFrog 10y agoI'd rephrase that to Perhaps women have different ambitions than men. On average, with large individual variation, of course. To me "ambitious" is about both how big your ambitions are and how hard you pursue them.
- huac 10y agoIt is self-reported and relative to others. > "The questionnaire asks how often students are willing to travel for work, the number of hours per week they are willing to work, and their desired compensation. They were also asked to rate their ambition relative to their most recent work colleagues and their tendency to lead in day-to-day interactions on a 1-to-5 scale."
- BurningFrog 10y agoSo it's about ambitions in the workplace.
- srssays 10y agoAmbitious in this context seems to mean materialistic.
- wikibob 10y agoFull Text PDF: http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/pallais/files/acting_wife.pdf http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/pallais/files/acting_wife.p...
- thedevil 10y agoThe funny thing is, I preferred ambitious women, especially when contemplating marriage. It seems easier to get along with someone who has a career and therefore similar goals and troubles and life-rhythm. And a wife with a career is less likely to look for long term alimony in the event of a divorce.
- kchoudhu 10y agoBe ready to have serious discussions about the two body problem when you're in a relationship with an ambitious woman. When opportunities come, someone's going to have to take the hit and swallow the disruption. Men are accustomed to having their way in these matters -- this is not necessarily the case anymore. In my case, it forced me to rejig my career plans and strike out on my own. I'm far, far, far better off for having done so (and so, more importantly, is my family), but at the time, it did seem like the end of the world.
- Pxtl 10y agoAs a developer who took 7 months off of pat leave, I'd recommend devs seriously thinking about it. A remote working dev has the flexibility to earn a good keep while also letting their partner have the more rigid location and schedule.
- kchoudhu 10y agoThe year I took off for paternity leave was simultaneously the greatest ("wow, it's fun spending time with my kid!") and worst ("holy crap, we've been leaving women to deal with this?") thing I've ever done. I seriously suspect a lot of jabs directed at feminism would die away if more men took paternity leave and used it as directed (and not, say, as a way to goof off for an extended period of time).
- graeme 10y agoSo you're not a location independent entrepreneur/freelancer? I was talking about this with my girlfriend recently. She's leaving the city in a year to do graduate studies. I'm a mostly location independent entrepreneur. But, leaving Canadian tax residency is complicated, and there are some big advantages to the fixed office setup I have here, because I do some video production. I was thinking of keeping my residence here, but frequently traveling to visit her. There's some types of work I can do quite easily on the go. I'll only find out how well that works once we actually do it. How did you arrange things?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- z3t4 10y agoi think down grading your worth is negative in the partner market. and that is why they are single. or that they rated themself acording to social rank to not piss off their class mates.
- jelliclesfarm 10y agoI am going to guess that there aren't any women in this thread..
- lazyasciiart 10y agoTry reading it to find out next time instead of just popping in with a mindless comment. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13681690 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13681690