4 ms·
I don't know when we as humans are going to fucking get it together and start acting like a better species. I hope that the rate of climate change will push us
by neom 10y ago
I don't know when we as humans are going to fucking get it together and start acting like a better species. I hope that the rate of climate change will push us to stop worrying about what bathroom another human decides to use or whom one selects to love and focus more on the ill's of the collective.
- ianai 10y agoI genuinely think people will not change until the worst affects of climate change begin.
- salesguy222 10y agoIn my opinion, even the worst possible effects of climate change (flooding, storms, acidification, desertification, species die-off, restoration of crocodiles living on Greenland)... will not be enough of a problem for the most-polluting humans to care about
- linuxkerneldev 10y ago> will not be enough of a problem for the most-polluting humans to care about I live in the country that pollutes the most per capita. I'm ashamed to say I haven't significantly changed my behavior and consumption patterns. But I look around myself and nobody else has either. Heck, we even voted in someone whose team wants to take actions that accelerate climate change. So this party will keep going until something terrible happens that actually impacts the folks at the top.
- salesguy222 10y agoI don't blame you :) it is a crisis of leadership for sure, since so many rich businesses are polluting, and so many individual consumers justify things to themselves by saying "but i NEED my SUV, mcmansion, refrigerator" and etc in my opinion it will be more necessary to find a way to suck co2 out of the atmosphere and place it somewhere, rather than attempt to limit how much demand there is for things that produce it as a waste product
- neom 10y agoSeems promising: Meet the Scientist Turning CO2 Into Ethanol - http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/green-tech/interviews/a23472/co2-ethanol-interview/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/green-tech/interview...
- salesguy222 10y agoGreat, thank you! this would help put a dent in climate change AND land use complaints surrounding ethanol :)
- jeremyjh 10y agoIt is just a battery, and not a very good one. The energy efficiency is only 20% - meaning you have to use 4 times the energy to run the reaction and convert the CO2 as you will get from burning the ethanol. And of course burning the ethanol releases the CO2. If you want to sequestor carbon I don't think this is a promising route to take.
- throwaway5752 10y ago"find a way to suck co2 out of the atmosphere and place it somewhere" That's what forests do, and we're cutting them down with alacrity. Also, I don't think you're done the "number of humans" x "energy consumption of suv + mcmansion" + "carbon density of likely fuel sources" math yet. It is simply impossible to sustain.
- salesguy222 10y agoI am not pro SUV or pro mcmansion i am pro forest
- throwaway5752 10y agoMe too! Wasn't implying otherwise :)
- 10y ago
- griffinmmahon 10y ago>I haven't significantly changed my behavior and consumption patterns You shouldn't be ashamed about this per se, because the type of action that will combat climate change is action by governments and corporations. An Inconvenient Truth made everyone think that small personal decisions are the way toward a greener future (think changing your lightbulb), but they aren't.
- flurdy 10y agoNo, small personal decisions are the way forward. As that accumulates opinion which then changes which party and policies people vote for, their buying patterns, etc and therefore changes government/corporations.
- ferbivore 10y agoHow do you think people decide which small personal decisions to make?
- graeme 10y agoWill it though? That's what worries me about climate change. I think the whole situation is subject to Jevons Paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox Using less CO2 (for a given activity) without reducing well being much just means we are becoming more efficient with it. Which means we could potentially use more CO2, globally. Don't get me wrong, I think individual action is good. But will it solve it? I think the only things that would solve it are: 1. Making a source of energy superior enough to CO2 that people don't even desire carbon 2. Leaving the carbon in the ground I think #1 may be a precondition for #2. Of course, if the small personal decisions help develop the technology in #1, they may help more directly than simply reducing consumption.
- griffinmmahon 10y agoThis position though is pretty much contingent on nearly every person making nearly every environmentally-friendly decision then, no?
- 10y ago
- throwaway5752 10y agoThey will move to New Zealand or make Hail Mary effort to colonize off-planet, and then war and famine pick off the 5-6 billion people that the earth cannot sustain (absent massive changes). Some of the people at the top know about this (in the country you are referencing), and they don't care. This is why they are attempting to systematically take apart health care, education, means of disseminating information, and other pillars of a resilient civic society.
- guelo 10y agoQatar?
- Nocturnals 10y agoWhat makes you think that people will change when the worst effects will begin? I don't know if I'm a pessimist or a realist.
- M_Grey 10y agoAre your views consistent with the sum total of human behavioral history? If so, I'd say you're not being pessimistic at all.
- nickparker 10y agoMy biggest fear today is that we're already screwed and just don't know it. This article turned out to be a "We expected this and now we've found it" but every morning I worry I'll see a headline like this and it'll be "We turned over this one rock and found something we didn't expect. Prepare for global famine in 2 years." On our current course I'm quite optimistic that we'll be able to turn the ship around - I think between tech accelerating and the climate itself starting to put the screws on us, we'll have powerful enough tools and enough resources poured into them to save ourselves. However, that's if we stay on the apparent current course. I'm really scared we'll hit a discontinuity of some sort.
- specialist 10y agoWe know it. Release of CO2 has entered a positive feedback loop. Thawing tundra, burning forests, ocean acidification. Even this we could counter (painfully) with massive industrial scale sequestration. What worries me is methane. I'm not sure we can mitigate methane released from the tundra. And if the stuff tucked under the ocean pops, we're toast. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoWhat I don't get about the positive feedback loop argument is that it seems completely at odds with what the IPCC is saying, namely limiting emissions in order to stabilize global warming at 2 degrees. If we were in a positive feedback loop, then global warming will just continue to accelerate no matter how small our emissions are. In fact, we'd be equally screwed if we magically stopped emitting CO2 in 1950, it would just take a little bit longer before we're screwed. Can anyone explain how to reconcile these arguments?
- nikdaheratik 10y agoMethane doesn't stay in the atmosphere nearly as long which means that, in theory, it would cause some short term warming, but then the methane would break down and we would slowly return to more normal levels. There are alot of unknowns, and while a very worst case scenario involves runaway methane causing warming, we don't know how likely this is to happen. We do know that CO2 takes hundreds of years to dissipate and will cause the ice caps to melt which will lead to higher sea levels overall.
- M_Grey 10y agoWe won't. We're going to die as we lived, like dumb animals.
- concinds 10y agoThis isn't about "getting it together". "If only humans were more perfect, everything would be ok" arguments are obnoxious, and pathologizing all of humanity reeks of a recycling of the "original sin" dogma on the right. It's ironic to both laud the greater good and write off a whole species in a single comment. There are people high in conscientiousness, who like to follow innumerable rules, moralize others who don't, and administer justice and revenge (on both sides of the political spectrum). There are people high in openness and empathy, who like to think "big picture" and try to improve the world. These are just personality traits. Both types of people have existed throughout history, exist now, and will exist. Defeatism will not bring about any change. Build your own platforms, brands, build followings, and change things. The masses have never brought about any change, they only ever did so when being led.
- neom 10y agoPontificate away young man, pontificate away.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoNever. It is similar to the reason we have economic bubbles even when everyone knows it's a bubble. Some people just want to "get theirs" before it all comes crumbling down.
- rdiddly 10y agoPeople are so worried about "which bathroom" precisely BECAUSE there's climate change and resource depletion going on. It's a giant collective act of procrastination, orchestrated by an elite whose profits depend on keeping that procrastination going as long as possible. The worse it gets, expect all the more ferocious distraction attempts and non-issues presented as issues for you to deal with and get excited about. (See flag burning, gay marriage, gun control... Anything to prevent a realistic consensus.)