5 ms·
You say that like it's a bad thing, but if that is the most productive use of property (i.e. the use that people are willing to pay most for), then I think that
by jstanley 10y ago
You say that like it's a bad thing, but if that is the most productive use of property (i.e. the use that people are willing to pay most for), then I think that is what should happen, and I don't see any issue with AirBnB facilitating this.
- taway_1212 10y agoAgreed. If a location is attracting tourists (and their money) from across the globe, it would be wasteful to turn all that money away because locals want to live there and not 4 subway stops further. Or, to put in other terms: your historic city centre is a gem, a rarity and such things are understandingly more valuable (in monetary terms) than ordinary locations. Want to live there? Make enough money to afford it.
- mjn 10y agoWhy would it be "wasteful" to prioritize quality of life for residents over investors' profits? Some cities (like Copenhagen) structure their housing mainly as owner-occupied cooperatives for a reason. A functioning city that works for its residents is valuable, and it'd be wasteful to throw one away in hopes of speculating on some kind of Disneyland attraction.
- jstanley 10y ago> Why would it be "wasteful" to prioritize quality of life for residents over investors' profits? Because investors' profits don't come from nowhere. You're prioritising the residents' wishes over the tourists' wishes, despite the fact that the tourists are willing to pay more to use the property. That's not fair.
- gotchange 10y ago> Why would it be "wasteful" to prioritize quality of life for residents over investors' profits? Fair enough but are you willing to compensate the investors/landlords for the lost income from foregoing these opportunities or asking the govt to have the tax payers foot the bill to help tenants stay in their properties at artificially lower than market rates? I say let supply and demand sort this out and just focus our efforts on exposing anti-competitive violations like price collusion among landlords etc etc. Usually landlords/investors who are attracted to this "trade" are lured by the prospects of short-term profits and if that doesn't materialize for any reason, they'd seek more stable income by entering into long-term arrangements at more economic rates with permanent tenants.
- expertentipp 10y agoThis turns the districts into cheap theme parks (even though everything is expensive). It takes 10 min bus ride to discover that people in the country actually don't speak English, beer doesn't have to cost 8 euro, the history left many marks many of which are not photogenic, and not all local females work in strip clubs.
- timthelion 10y agoYes, it is a good thing when the rich enjoy the best quality real estate and normal working people live in slums on the outskirts of the city and commute for hours into the city. Normal people deserve to live on the outskirts, because they aren't smart and hard working like the rich.
- jstanley 10y agoIf that's what you think the problem is, then I've got bad news for you: this system applies to a whole lot more than just housing. This is how all scarce resources are allocated, and it's the most fair and efficient system that has been invented so far.
- timthelion 10y agoIt is neither efficient nor fair. It is a system that is good at keeping power and a system that is destroying nature and the earth.
- mafribe 10y agoHow empirically adequate is the claim implicit in your criticism that Airbnb is primarily used by the rich? Au contraire, Airbnb is primarily used by the young and (comparatively poor), students and young adults. The kind of person who comes to Berlin, Praha and Barcelona by Ryanair and Easyjet. It is precisely the low-cost nature of Airbnb that has made it so popular: in order to save money you can fit multiple people into a small Airbnb if you really want, you cannot easily do that with a hotel. The wealthy (usually older) stay in posh hotels. Airbnb, like low-cost airlines, has made travelling to major cities more affordable to the masses. * * * A more general point: I don't see why having zones dedicated to short-term lodging and entertainment on one hand, and zones for long-term lodging is necessarily a bad thing. Such zones allows for more specialisation, hence better offerings for either. E.g. dwellings suitable for short-term dwelling probably have somewhat different characteristics than dwellings suitable for long-term dwelling. Another example, nightlife comes with noise pollution, so nightlife isn't really all ideal in residental areas (and typically subject to severe legal restriction). Restricting nightlife to small zones with a dense stocking of nightlife is one way of getting around this problem. Moreover, the entertainment value of a city increases dramatically with increasing tourism, and that's good for long-term inhabitants too. I would like to up the ante: great party zones is one of the key things that make cities livable.