3 ms·
Well, duh. Hotels are pretty profitable too. If you take a hotel and remove the requirements for safety regulation, taxes, use of commercial real estate and pr
by Spooky23 10y ago
Well, duh.
Hotels are pretty profitable too. If you take a hotel and remove the requirements for safety regulation, taxes, use of commercial real estate and provision of amenities, it will be more profitable.
Airbnb is great because the company turns a blind eye to many things and makes it easy.
- expertentipp 10y agoThe problem is the hotel regulations went really far. To the extend that many hotels only care to fulfill the requirements and then to squeeze the last cent from the guests (e.g. infamous fridges with expensive beverages) while disregarding whether the place is cozy, pleasant, or friendly. Initially, the temporary rental platforms were challenging this pathological situation.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoGiven that there don't seem to be any major harms caused by the lack of safety regulation and amenities on AirBnB, it seems like we can conclude that the hotel regulations are unnecessary. Surely, as people who favor good governance rather than just arbitrary governance, we can all favor eliminating those costly and pointless regulations now? Or do we just favor arbitrary regulations just because we like regulations?
- paulpauper 10y agoagree. Also the media tends to sensationalize anything bad that involves AirBNB and also Uber, but ignores problems that occur with hotels and taxis.
- brainfire 10y agoWhy are you so confident there hasn't been any harm?
- yummyfajitas 10y agoMainly because the critics seem unable to cite anything beyond "I saw strangers coming out of my neighbor's bedroom" and occasionally "some strangers were making noise in my neighbor's bedroom".
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's right... nobody gets raped in airbnb rooms (http://www.airbnbhell.com/i-was-gang-raped-in-budapest-and-airbnb-ignored-me-then-insulted-me/ http://www.airbnbhell.com/i-was-gang-raped-in-budapest-and-a...), or watched by creepy host (http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/this-is-terrifying-your-airbnb-host-can-legally-film-you-216361 http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/this-is-terrifying-your-airb...), or bait and switched (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8063313 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8063313), of firetraps (http://www.dailydot.com/via/things-i-learned-airbnb-caught-fire/ http://www.dailydot.com/via/things-i-learned-airbnb-caught-f...). The regulatory model around hotels is good governance.
- someguydave 10y agoIt is probably true that hotels are somewhat safer than rando's apartments. Is the increased safety of hotels worth their cost in terms of barriers to entry in the short-term leasing market?
- Sacho 10y agoEhh...you'd need to prove that the regulations on hotels reduce the amount of these incidents, and then also make an argument that reducing these incidents is worth the amount of regulation. Anecdotes don't cover 1) (unless you want me to show counter-anecdotes of people being raped in hotels, etc..), but let's assume you've provided statistical information that hotel regulations provide a 50% decrease in such incidents. You still haven't articulated why you think the regulations are worth the extra safety. As a counter-argument, here's a reductio ad absurdum - it would make hotels even safer if they installed cameras in each room and hired enough security to monitor all video feeds.
- Spooky23 10y agoYour ignorance doesn't put a burden on me. Spend 15 minutes to do some googling. Fire safety is the most obvious example. A modern hotel is engineered to slow down the spread of fire and preserve life. Sprinklers, fire resistant doors and walls, etc. Airbnb is an awesome thing when it does what it initially did -- handle house rentals. When that business model failed to provide growth, they pivoted to the current model where they've become the eBay of real estate by turning a blind eye to obvious fraud and abuse.
- _red 10y agoWhile this is true, it conviently leaves out the important question: Who pushed for those regulations? Many of those regulations that affect hotels were pushed by the large hotel groups - regulation is simply the most cost effective way for large multinationals companies to keep out competition. The regulation act as a floor that essentially ensures that only projects of $X millions of capitalization makes sense to pursue, which by default favors the large hotel chains.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's a common argument that really doesn't hold any water. The average mid market hotel (Holiday Inn, Hampton Inn) costs $50-75k per room to build, with the typical project costing $6-8M. Nearly all hotels like this are built from standardized components and are owned by small local or regional operators. If you go downmarket, that cost goes in half. If you look at older, but still legally compliant hotel property, acquisition cost is probably $5-10k/room in many markets. Obviously big city hotels costs more to build/buy and operate. That's why a NYC hotel is often 2x-3x other places -- and that is being challenged by lower operating cost business models. The large hotel chains don't own a lot of property. They are brands who license their trademarks and access to their reservation system.