2 ms·
I don't think I'm humourless, but I value HN as one of the few places on the public internet where intelligent discussion is still possible without being drowne
by nkurz 17y ago
I don't think I'm humourless, but I value HN as one of the few places on the public internet where intelligent discussion is still possible without being drowned out by regurgitated memes and fart jokes. While in theory it's possible to have both, I haven't seen it happen elsewhere.
The comparisons to Reddit are discouraged not because they are baseless, rather for fear that they may be self-fulfilling. Reddit used to feel like a community as well, and I used to enjoy reading the comments there as well. It's worth asking 'What changed?' and 'What could have been done differently?'
I just looked at your link: http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2010/05/nerdy-cute-girl.php http://www.whattofix.com/blog/archives/2010/05/nerdy-cute-gi...
It struck me as a parody of the worst possible thing you could post here: non-funny, sexually stereotyped, ethnocentric, and devoid of insight; but with just enough of a hook to get a significant number of upvotes. It's soft porn with a plausible excuse. And once people saw that this was acceptable, I'm sure we'd see more of the same.
If I were the moderator, I'd have not only deleted it but emailed you to tell you that if you do it again your account will be banned. This isn't because I'm against humor, or against porn, but because I can't see the community I enjoy remaining intact while adding this sort of boorish fluff.
I don't want to pick on you too much, but did you picture the conservative religious users being amused by this, or did you set out to offend them? Did you consider how it might seem to a young female programmer to see your post on the front page? I'm very far from politically correct, but I can scarcely conceive of what you were thinking.