3 ms·
I entirely disagree. Down-voting is a defense of the commons. The best way to teach us not to post shit, is for our shit to be down-voted mercilessly, with no e
by jessaustin 10y ago
I entirely disagree. Down-voting is a defense of the commons. The best way to teach us not to post shit, is for our shit to be down-voted mercilessly, with no explanation. I've got over 14k internet points, and I get down-voted every week at least, usually without discussion. I appreciate that, because it helps me learn to contribute better, without sucking me into a black hole of personality conflict. Every down-vote represents someone who was annoyed by what I posted, and we all benefit by reducing annoyance here. Truly unfair down-votes are typically corrected (...and then some) by up-votes from other users.
One probably doesn't understand why one is down-voted, the first time it happens. One probably doesn't understand every down-vote one gets, even with long experience. Over time, however, one gets a better and better idea about what we need here, and what we don't. It's even better if it's unconscious, and we edit our posts to be more "HN-style" without paying attention to why a particular expression conforms to that or not. This process is only disrupted by lengthy back-and-forth discussion of who said what and why and who interpreted that how and why.
Try not to think of down-votes as a reflection of your character or worth as a human. Rather, they are a snap judgment of a single verbal expression, made at a single point in time.