2 ms·
I'm pretty sure upvotes from different users are unequally weighted when it comes to getting a story onto the front page, and that upvotes from fresh users aren
by nostrademons 10y ago
I'm pretty sure upvotes from different users are unequally weighted when it comes to getting a story onto the front page, and that upvotes from fresh users aren't counted with nearly the same weight as someone who's been here a while and has a track record of predicting which stories will perform well on the front page. There've been times that I've given a story languishing on /newest its 4th upvote and it pops onto the front page, and there've also been times that I've seen stories get 10+ upvotes in short succession and get stuck on page 3. It also wouldn't surprise me if receiving a lot upvotes from newly-created accounts, or accounts that have all upvoted the same things, ends up tripping the voting-ring detector.
- austenallred 10y agoIf you look at how PG originally created the algorithm in Arc this behavior makes a lot of sense, especially when alongside it is the explanation that HN will cancel out votes that look shady. (I could be wrong, but I believe this is the case). Basically the algorithm looked like: Score = (p-1) / (t+2)^g p = points (the -1 is to negate the point of the original submitter) t = time g = gravity (or some gravitational constant) So the p value matters a lot; especially when there's a smaller t (a new story). This gives newer stories a chance to bubble up with fewer points against the ones that have 1,000 points but have been on the front page for days. It's a pretty ingenious algorithm, actually. It makes sense, given that formula, that even if all p values are weighted equally, moving p from 3 to 4 would make a big difference, and would be able to push something new to the front page. You'll see them now and then with 2-3 upvotes on the front page, because they're very new and the front page is relatively stale. Anyway, I'm ~100% sure spammers can get around the vote ring detection, but I don't think that's happening on HN in a major way.
- nostrademons 10y agoThese were cases where the submission was both older and the point value was lower than other submissions that were not on the front page, though. It's possible that flags, voting ring detector, or spamkiller were negatively impacting the other story, but it definitely isn't a straight votes & time formula anymore.