4 ms·
Upvote manipulation doesn't work on Hacker News because both the voting ring detector is strong, and flagging is significantly more powerful and serves as count
by minimaxir 10y ago
Upvote manipulation doesn't work on Hacker News because both the voting ring detector is strong, and flagging is significantly more powerful and serves as counteracting force to upvotes and serves as a check to submissions which legit aren't good for the site. (both of these are in contrast with Product Hunt, which turns a blind eye to voting manipulation and asking-friends-for-upvotes-but-not-explicitly is often recommended as a promotion strategy on that site: https://medium.com/startup-grind/my-startup-launch-on-product-hunt-was-disappointing-ff5c8e70860 https://medium.com/startup-grind/my-startup-launch-on-produc...)
There is also a Hacker News "growth hacking" tactic of linking to /newest on Facebook/Twitter instead of linking to the submission directly to avoid the voting ring detector, which also doesn't work and is blatantly obvious: http://i.imgur.com/08pAFOw.jpg http://i.imgur.com/08pAFOw.jpg
- nadermx 10y agoI'm sure where there is a will, there is a way...
- austenallred 10y ago> Upvote manipulation doesn't work on Hacker News I'm pretty sure that's unequivocally false. It's difficult enough to make it work that it probably wouldn't be worth it, but I'm close to 100% sure I could force something to the top if I wanted to. I don't particularly want to spend the time automating accounts to make them "look natural" and I don't really want to shell out the money to spend on IPs. But I know for a fact the same thing is happening on Reddit with great success every day. I could spell out how, but I don't think the HN mods would be too keen on that. Any hacker should be able to figure it out, though. Furthermore, if you produce something solid, all you'd really need is the first <10 upvotes to get on the front page and let it catch on "organically." I can promise you that is happening _all the time_ on HN. I'm glad you keep your Twitter search running and keep calling people out that blatantly ask for upvotes; the easiest way to kill spam is just to make it difficult, but to say that manipulation doesn't work is just not true.
- minimaxir 10y ago> I just don't have the time or the money to shell out and buy IPs. You need a Hacker News account to upvote, and obviously having a large number of new accounts upvote something would trip a voting ring detector. > Furthermore, if you produce something solid, all you'd really need is the first <10 upvotes to get on the front page and let it catch on "organically." Much easier said than done. The median score of a HN submission is 1-2 points last time I checked. (the discoverability of HN submissions on /newest is an issue, but that's another topic) And if it's actually solid, it's not the market for vote brigading. I agree manipulation does happen, but it doesn't mean it works and instead silently penalizes the submission to death.
- austenallred 10y ago> You need a Hacker News account to upvote, and obviously having a large number of new accounts upvote something would trip a voting ring detector. Correct, but what if I gave myself a couple or few months to prepare accounts? Do a search on blackhatworld (or another spam forum) for "aged accounts" and you'll see that you can generally buy them in tiers - the older they are the more expensive they are. I'm not saying it's worth it or I think it's something people should do, but saying it's not possible or doesn't work is absurd.
- clickbait 10y agoI think it'd be fairly obvious that something suspicious was going on if a large number of dormant "aged accounts" just happened to login for the first time in months to upvote a specific thread.
- elastic_church 10y agoExcept this is why there is an economy of aged accounts.... It directly affects the cost of the promotional service
- nostrademons 10y agoI'm pretty sure upvotes from different users are unequally weighted when it comes to getting a story onto the front page, and that upvotes from fresh users aren't counted with nearly the same weight as someone who's been here a while and has a track record of predicting which stories will perform well on the front page. There've been times that I've given a story languishing on /newest its 4th upvote and it pops onto the front page, and there've also been times that I've seen stories get 10+ upvotes in short succession and get stuck on page 3. It also wouldn't surprise me if receiving a lot upvotes from newly-created accounts, or accounts that have all upvoted the same things, ends up tripping the voting-ring detector.
- krapp 10y ago>Upvote manipulation doesn't work on Hacker News because both the voting ring detector is strong, and flagging is significantly more powerful and serves as counteracting force to upvotes and serves as a check to submissions which legit aren't good for the site. You say this, and it may or may not be true, but of course, Hacker News isn't releasing the code to prove it.
- Artemis2 10y agoIt would be a lot easier to get around vote manipulation detection if the code was public.
- FeatureRush 10y agoCrypto industry is a step ahead in this game, they would release white paper proving that even the creators of the system can't manipulate upvotes.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThis isn't crypto, and there's no concrete definition of manipulation that would support proof (unlike the kind of threats crypto deals with); it's a fuzzy problem domain.
- krapp 10y agoIf that's true, it implies that vote manipulation detection is already easy to get around. It's just relying on security through obscurity and probably direct human intervention to cover for unpublished flaws.
- dang 10y agoAren't you holding us to an impossible standard here? The problems we're talking about are not cryptographic; they're much closer to, say, law enforcement. Has anybody figured out how to model such things with mathematical guarantees?